New Combat System vs Healing
Re: New Combat System vs Healing
Just spitballing here, but what about weighting melee class skills when it comes to religious lvl. For instance let's say a priest has 1/3 more available skills to lvl than melee. Why not just weight the melee related skills to 1.3 for every 1 priest/mage lvl.
Re: New Combat System vs Healing
I'm not sure where to begin, but this has been an enjoyable thread to read and I'm pleased to see so many different takes on the new combat system. If you haven't figured it out yet, that's the point. It's something different for everyone, even within the same classes.
For starters, I never said it was easy for Draven to hunt above his level. His class based focus on skills combined with his race choice and high end gear allows him to do so. That is exactly what we had in mind with this system. If he were more well rounded in skills he would have a higher religious level, but not hunt as effectively as he does now and would probably have to step back to lesser hunting grounds. It is by no means easy what he's been able to accomplish, and he has to stay on his toes to hunt where he does.
As far as healing goes, this is considered a support skill and not directly related to combat. As I've said in this last cwc and in others, combat had to come first. We are now free to revisit the other skills out there to bring them in line with the new system. We certainly take all your feedback into consideration when making these changes, but it's important to understand where we are with them.
Let's see, what else.
Weapons do have different AR and damage based on size, not just material. We are looking into the differences between weapon types and materials now that combat has been updated, but it's not a change we'd make lightly. There's a lot of weapons in the game that would need adjusting, so we will weigh other options first. On a slightly unrelated note, you will soon see short hammers that act like daggers, and throwing weapons that work with your ranged combat skill. (No boomerangs)
On a more overall topic, we're not ever going to explain the exact mechanics of how things work. I know some players will always devote their time to trying to figure these things out, but we aren't that kind of game. We strive to create multiple ways to approach the world with no right or wrong answer. There's no single defining way to master combat. We try to find balance between the different races and classes while making each one feel unique. Even within the same class there should be many different ways to approach combat. And while we do try to give every playing type a home here, like every game out there, our larger focus is on group settings. The largest voices in this thread do not group hunt. I'm pleased you are able to find ways to enjoy yourself, but we are a social game at our core and we're always going to focus are efforts there first. What impresses me is that while doing that, we've still provided an environment where the casual player can solo hunt or craft and still be able to contribute to group hunts or events when they want.
We are working on another round of skill updates to be implemented before the OOC games coming up. Thank you all for the continued feedback that goes into making these changes.
P.S. Support classes are always first target in pvp games. This is not a new concept. If you are helping your team survive, you gots to die.
P.S.S. As I've stated before, we are not going to weight skills differently as they apply toward your overall religious level. You decide which skills are important to you. Yes mages and priests have more skills currently and can reach level 50 faster than a warrior or barbarian, but that does not automatically make them better. Yes, religious level is heavily factored into combat, but it is not the only factor. Your individual skills, your race, your class progression, your gear, and your stats all matter, and it's only going to get better as we move forward.
For starters, I never said it was easy for Draven to hunt above his level. His class based focus on skills combined with his race choice and high end gear allows him to do so. That is exactly what we had in mind with this system. If he were more well rounded in skills he would have a higher religious level, but not hunt as effectively as he does now and would probably have to step back to lesser hunting grounds. It is by no means easy what he's been able to accomplish, and he has to stay on his toes to hunt where he does.
As far as healing goes, this is considered a support skill and not directly related to combat. As I've said in this last cwc and in others, combat had to come first. We are now free to revisit the other skills out there to bring them in line with the new system. We certainly take all your feedback into consideration when making these changes, but it's important to understand where we are with them.
Let's see, what else.
Weapons do have different AR and damage based on size, not just material. We are looking into the differences between weapon types and materials now that combat has been updated, but it's not a change we'd make lightly. There's a lot of weapons in the game that would need adjusting, so we will weigh other options first. On a slightly unrelated note, you will soon see short hammers that act like daggers, and throwing weapons that work with your ranged combat skill. (No boomerangs)
On a more overall topic, we're not ever going to explain the exact mechanics of how things work. I know some players will always devote their time to trying to figure these things out, but we aren't that kind of game. We strive to create multiple ways to approach the world with no right or wrong answer. There's no single defining way to master combat. We try to find balance between the different races and classes while making each one feel unique. Even within the same class there should be many different ways to approach combat. And while we do try to give every playing type a home here, like every game out there, our larger focus is on group settings. The largest voices in this thread do not group hunt. I'm pleased you are able to find ways to enjoy yourself, but we are a social game at our core and we're always going to focus are efforts there first. What impresses me is that while doing that, we've still provided an environment where the casual player can solo hunt or craft and still be able to contribute to group hunts or events when they want.
We are working on another round of skill updates to be implemented before the OOC games coming up. Thank you all for the continued feedback that goes into making these changes.
P.S. Support classes are always first target in pvp games. This is not a new concept. If you are helping your team survive, you gots to die.
P.S.S. As I've stated before, we are not going to weight skills differently as they apply toward your overall religious level. You decide which skills are important to you. Yes mages and priests have more skills currently and can reach level 50 faster than a warrior or barbarian, but that does not automatically make them better. Yes, religious level is heavily factored into combat, but it is not the only factor. Your individual skills, your race, your class progression, your gear, and your stats all matter, and it's only going to get better as we move forward.
-
Bocon Lampor
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 51
- Joined: Tue Jul 19, 2016 4:09 am
Re: New Combat System vs Healing
Thanks for the reply. I'm happy that no 2 people of the same class are alike, it gives people options on what to do. Though I think people should know what they are getting into when they make those choices. Going in blindly could end with failed expectations and wasted time.Snaek wrote:I'm not sure where to begin, but this has been an enjoyable thread to read and I'm pleased to see so many different takes on the new combat system. If you haven't figured it out yet, that's the point. It's something different for everyone, even within the same classes.
For starters, I never said it was easy for Draven to hunt above his level. His class based focus on skills combined with his race choice and high end gear allows him to do so. That is exactly what we had in mind with this system. If he were more well rounded in skills he would have a higher religious level, but not hunt as effectively as he does now and would probably have to step back to lesser hunting grounds. It is by no means easy what he's been able to accomplish, and he has to stay on his toes to hunt where he does.
As far as healing goes, this is considered a support skill and not directly related to combat. As I've said in this last cwc and in others, combat had to come first. We are now free to revisit the other skills out there to bring them in line with the new system. We certainly take all your feedback into consideration when making these changes, but it's important to understand where we are with them.
Let's see, what else.
Weapons do have different AR and damage based on size, not just material. We are looking into the differences between weapon types and materials now that combat has been updated, but it's not a change we'd make lightly. There's a lot of weapons in the game that would need adjusting, so we will weigh other options first. On a slightly unrelated note, you will soon see short hammers that act like daggers, and throwing weapons that work with your ranged combat skill. (No boomerangs)
On a more overall topic, we're not ever going to explain the exact mechanics of how things work. I know some players will always devote their time to trying to figure these things out, but we aren't that kind of game. We strive to create multiple ways to approach the world with no right or wrong answer. There's no single defining way to master combat. We try to find balance between the different races and classes while making each one feel unique. Even within the same class there should be many different ways to approach combat. And while we do try to give every playing type a home here, like every game out there, our larger focus is on group settings. The largest voices in this thread do not group hunt. I'm pleased you are able to find ways to enjoy yourself, but we are a social game at our core and we're always going to focus are efforts there first. What impresses me is that while doing that, we've still provided an environment where the casual player can solo hunt or craft and still be able to contribute to group hunts or events when they want.
We are working on another round of skill updates to be implemented before the OOC games coming up. Thank you all for the continued feedback that goes into making these changes.
P.S. Support classes are always first target in pvp games. This is not a new concept. If you are helping your team survive, you gots to die.
P.S.S. As I've stated before, we are not going to weight skills differently as they apply toward your overall religious level. You decide which skills are important to you. Yes mages and priests have more skills currently and can reach level 50 faster than a warrior or barbarian, but that does not automatically make them better. Yes, religious level is heavily factored into combat, but it is not the only factor. Your individual skills, your race, your class progression, your gear, and your stats all matter, and it's only going to get better as we move forward.
I know that combat needed to be fixed and worked on first. The last time I asked about healing updates, it was basically non-existent on the list. Maybe that changed, maybe it didn't, I dunno. Because I know that warriors and barbs and such need their new skills so they can raise their RL easier. It would be nice to hear your thoughts on where you see an actual place for high level healing specializations in the game's future. Cause I'm having a hard time seeing it atm.
With such a small playerbase, I agree that group settings are fine, though it really leaves no room for real conflict. Let's say the game grows larger and you now have 2 priests who have specialized in healing in the same group. 1 of them is going to be 100% completely useless as it stands right now, if both of them want to heal. Offensive priests can add to dps, especially with turn. Much like a normal MMORPG, a group only needs 1 healer and 1 tank. DPS scales, the others do not.
I know why we are targeted first, but it doesn't change the fact that it sucks. Maybe people will go for Xiija first, now that they know that she's far ahead of me in player level, lol.
"You decide which skills are important to you." I think that people can make that decision now, though my decision was based off of having to guess on what would be important, with no imformation on the NCS. If I had foresight, I'd have stopped leveling everything past 50 and thrown them into skills that would raise my RL and ones that actually have meaningful uses in a group setting. That's what's important to me and I'm sure everyone has their own version of what's important. Much like Creon said, I feel like I'm being punished for my choices, which feels really bad.
- Bastion Mannix
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 64
- Joined: Wed Jan 18, 2017 4:28 am
- Location: Pearl
Re: New Combat System vs Healing
I understand that staff don't want to weight skills, but why not make RL based on total uses (without changing where it's currently at), instead of levels, that way someone who puts 100 levels into something is still rewarded for going above and beyond? It takes significantly more uses for those higher levels, 99-100 shouldn't only give you one point toward total RL, so making it use based could balance that.
Walking in Her Light, each and every day,
Bastion Mannix
Priest of Astraeva
Bastion Mannix
Priest of Astraeva
-
Bocon Lampor
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 51
- Joined: Tue Jul 19, 2016 4:09 am
Re: New Combat System vs Healing
This is a good idea.Bastion Mannix wrote:I understand that staff don't want to weight skills, but why not make RL based on total uses (without changing where it's currently at), instead of levels, that way someone who puts 100 levels into something is still rewarded for going above and beyond? It takes significantly more uses for those higher levels, 99-100 shouldn't only give you one point toward total RL, so making it use based could balance that.
Re: New Combat System vs Healing
The speed at which one class over the other reaches lvl 50 only is an issue if it is extremely dispoportionate. Which it is. It reward more for doing less. Reaching level 10 in 10 different spells is not the equivilent to reaching level 100 close combat. I think functionally we are a lot closer in terms of effectiveness for what we do. But when you say well rounded that. I dont think thats what you mean. What you is you havent leveled equally a lot of other skills. Which circles back to my original point. If you don't want to weight skills for certain classes I would at the very least bump up the contribution that leveling up a skill very high makes. If achieving level 3 presents the same religious level contribution that achieving level 100 is than I would say you do have a issue, and it will turn players off because it makes them feel unrewarded for devoting there time into their character.
I think one of the big things that I have pushed since the begining is their has been such a emphasis on seperating combat and crafting. Which has made interaction between players less rewarding. We have a opportunity to add excitement here and even more importantly interaction. Ie the gnome mines has Parisum. Making that mine filled with creatures that are difficult to kill and have low pay, but making the most rare and valuable material available to mine but only for skilled miners. It is only an example their are still going to be plenty of no risk gathering areas available. I am merely suggesting that the option to get some of the better materials have some risk to encourage interaction in the community and one that wouldnt require staff involvment. Also, by adding a level check to your mining makes the ability scale outside of output and effectiveness. Just some food for thought.
I think one of the big things that I have pushed since the begining is their has been such a emphasis on seperating combat and crafting. Which has made interaction between players less rewarding. We have a opportunity to add excitement here and even more importantly interaction. Ie the gnome mines has Parisum. Making that mine filled with creatures that are difficult to kill and have low pay, but making the most rare and valuable material available to mine but only for skilled miners. It is only an example their are still going to be plenty of no risk gathering areas available. I am merely suggesting that the option to get some of the better materials have some risk to encourage interaction in the community and one that wouldnt require staff involvment. Also, by adding a level check to your mining makes the ability scale outside of output and effectiveness. Just some food for thought.
Re: New Combat System vs Healing
I quoted everything but I wanted to bring only one thing to light. Focusing the healer is just a tactic and it is frustrating, but by communicating with your team and developing a strategy you can extend your life. Ie if you knew me and Blink were in a team. You would likely focus Blink while having the mage keep slow on me and blink as priority 1 and shields and dmg mitigation on you as priority 2. This would take away from some dmg to the enemy team but the utility of heavy healing you offer on top of the extremely powerful utility mid lvl mages offer.you can mittigate me and Blink's burst potential with your team comp while wittling our health down with plague and the rest of your team.Bocon Lampor wrote:Thanks for the reply. I'm happy that no 2 people of the same class are alike, it gives people options on what to do. Though I think people should know what they are getting into when they make those choices. Going in blindly could end with failed expectations and wasted time.Snaek wrote:I'm not sure where to begin, but this has been an enjoyable thread to read and I'm pleased to see so many different takes on the new combat system. If you haven't figured it out yet, that's the point. It's something different for everyone, even within the same classes.
For starters, I never said it was easy for Draven to hunt above his level. His class based focus on skills combined with his race choice and high end gear allows him to do so. That is exactly what we had in mind with this system. If he were more well rounded in skills he would have a higher religious level, but not hunt as effectively as he does now and would probably have to step back to lesser hunting grounds. It is by no means easy what he's been able to accomplish, and he has to stay on his toes to hunt where he does.
As far as healing goes, this is considered a support skill and not directly related to combat. As I've said in this last cwc and in others, combat had to come first. We are now free to revisit the other skills out there to bring them in line with the new system. We certainly take all your feedback into consideration when making these changes, but it's important to understand where we are with them.
Let's see, what else.
Weapons do have different AR and damage based on size, not just material. We are looking into the differences between weapon types and materials now that combat has been updated, but it's not a change we'd make lightly. There's a lot of weapons in the game that would need adjusting, so we will weigh other options first. On a slightly unrelated note, you will soon see short hammers that act like daggers, and throwing weapons that work with your ranged combat skill. (No boomerangs)
On a more overall topic, we're not ever going to explain the exact mechanics of how things work. I know some players will always devote their time to trying to figure these things out, but we aren't that kind of game. We strive to create multiple ways to approach the world with no right or wrong answer. There's no single defining way to master combat. We try to find balance between the different races and classes while making each one feel unique. Even within the same class there should be many different ways to approach combat. And while we do try to give every playing type a home here, like every game out there, our larger focus is on group settings. The largest voices in this thread do not group hunt. I'm pleased you are able to find ways to enjoy yourself, but we are a social game at our core and we're always going to focus are efforts there first. What impresses me is that while doing that, we've still provided an environment where the casual player can solo hunt or craft and still be able to contribute to group hunts or events when they want.
We are working on another round of skill updates to be implemented before the OOC games coming up. Thank you all for the continued feedback that goes into making these changes.
P.S. Support classes are always first target in pvp games. This is not a new concept. If you are helping your team survive, you gots to die.
P.S.S. As I've stated before, we are not going to weight skills differently as they apply toward your overall religious level. You decide which skills are important to you. Yes mages and priests have more skills currently and can reach level 50 faster than a warrior or barbarian, but that does not automatically make them better. Yes, religious level is heavily factored into combat, but it is not the only factor. Your individual skills, your race, your class progression, your gear, and your stats all matter, and it's only going to get better as we move forward.
I know that combat needed to be fixed and worked on first. The last time I asked about healing updates, it was basically non-existent on the list. Maybe that changed, maybe it didn't, I dunno. Because I know that warriors and barbs and such need their new skills so they can raise their RL easier. It would be nice to hear your thoughts on where you see an actual place for high level healing specializations in the game's future. Cause I'm having a hard time seeing it atm.
With such a small playerbase, I agree that group settings are fine, though it really leaves no room for real conflict. Let's say the game grows larger and you now have 2 priests who have specialized in healing in the same group. 1 of them is going to be 100% completely useless as it stands right now, if both of them want to heal. Offensive priests can add to dps, especially with turn. Much like a normal MMORPG, a group only needs 1 healer and 1 tank. DPS scales, the others do not.
I know why we are targeted first, but it doesn't change the fact that it sucks. Maybe people will go for Xiija first, now that they know that she's far ahead of me in player level, lol.
"You decide which skills are important to you." I think that people can make that decision now, though my decision was based off of having to guess on what would be important, with no imformation on the NCS. If I had foresight, I'd have stopped leveling everything past 50 and thrown them into skills that would raise my RL and ones that actually have meaningful uses in a group setting. That's what's important to me and I'm sure everyone has their own version of what's important. Much like Creon said, I feel like I'm being punished for my choices, which feels really bad.
The other thing is we really need to cement some OOC games some characters from dgate Only came on when the games were going. A lot of the fun is just in employing strategy, but also rewards made a big impact as well. I think we are lacking in the rewards department. Skill uses are great but it is extremely restricted and it took me 2 years to actually use the tokens I collected because we didnt have a set turn in schedule. I love the idea of skill uses as a reward but its not a reward if it takes that long to collect, so that is something I would recommend addressing. Also I think we have a very solid opportunity here that we all have overlooked. We generally have a large and varied skill/lvl comp of classes all gathered together. We have a opportunity to have competative PvE in this setting. Meaning killing the enemy team does not grant you the win instead you have to capture a flag or kill the enemies NPC 'king'. I would recommend revive timers in a game like this were players get resserected at set intervals. This makes.engauging in PvP more tactical than just kill the enemy mage and healer! You could also do PvE 'waves where NPCs come in large waves and become invreasingly more difficult each round. The team to survive the longest or have the most players alive at the end of say 3 rounds wins. If its a tie have the teams meet in the middle for deathmatch. Just a multitude of examples of vaired play that would I think increase the fun involved and also give more data to the staff on what may need tuning
-
Bocon Lampor
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 51
- Joined: Tue Jul 19, 2016 4:09 am
Re: New Combat System vs Healing
I have to second this, as I found it to be severly unrewarding to have worked my skills up now. The design choices lately are confusing as hell to me, so maybe someone could shed some insight on them... Before the NCS, the game was very mechanical as well as RP heavy. With the NCS, it seems to have shifted to being far more RP inspired and way less mechanical. Yet the entire world runs off of mechanics (Hunting, PvP, Money, Merchants, etc), minus the town things like the conclave and some special events here and there. It's causing a huge clash in design philosophy. As it stands now, I could just roll a mage and have it max player level in 1/4th of the time it took me to get Bocon his levels. This kind of design isn't promoting people to stick around on 1 character, at least from a mechanics POV. People who want the super heavy RP won't really care about this, as they really made out with this new system. So I have to assume that's what they want.Creon wrote:The speed at which one class over the other reaches lvl 50 only is an issue if it is extremely dispoportionate. Which it is. It reward more for doing less. Reaching level 10 in 10 different spells is not the equivilent to reaching level 100 close combat. I think functionally we are a lot closer in terms of effectiveness for what we do. But when you say well rounded that. I dont think thats what you mean. What you is you havent leveled equally a lot of other skills. Which circles back to my original point. If you don't want to weight skills for certain classes I would at the very least bump up the contribution that leveling up a skill very high makes. If achieving level 3 presents the same religious level contribution that achieving level 100 is than I would say you do have a issue, and it will turn players off because it makes them feel unrewarded for devoting there time into their character.
I think one of the big things that I have pushed since the begining is their has been such a emphasis on seperating combat and crafting. Which has made interaction between players less rewarding. We have a opportunity to add excitement here and even more importantly interaction. Ie the gnome mines has Parisum. Making that mine filled with creatures that are difficult to kill and have low pay, but making the most rare and valuable material available to mine but only for skilled miners. It is only an example their are still going to be plenty of no risk gathering areas available. I am merely suggesting that the option to get some of the better materials have some risk to encourage interaction in the community and one that wouldnt require staff involvment. Also, by adding a level check to your mining makes the ability scale outside of output and effectiveness. Just some food for thought.
From what I understand, all of the higher level metals are smelted and not mined. Though I like the idea. It would give me an actual reason to join a hunt that already has a priest in it.
Re: New Combat System vs Healing
It may seem that way but the player base has increased and the game has become more robust mechanically. Interaction falls onto the playerbase ultimately however. The game design does push one way or another but lBocon Lampor wrote:I have to second this, as I found it to be severly unrewarding to have worked my skills up now. The design choices lately are confusing as hell to me, so maybe someone could shed some insight on them... Before the NCS, the game was very mechanical as well as RP heavy. With the NCS, it seems to have shifted to being far more RP inspired and way less mechanical. Yet the entire world runs off of mechanics (Hunting, PvP, Money, Merchants, etc), minus the town things like the conclave and some special events here and there. It's causing a huge clash in design philosophy. As it stands now, I could just roll a mage and have it max player level in 1/4th of the time it took me to get Bocon his levels. This kind of design isn't promoting people to stick around on 1 character, at least from a mechanics POV. People who want the super heavy RP won't really care about this, as they really made out with this new system. So I have to assume that's what they want.Creon wrote:The speed at which one class over the other reaches lvl 50 only is an issue if it is extremely dispoportionate. Which it is. It reward more for doing less. Reaching level 10 in 10 different spells is not the equivilent to reaching level 100 close combat. I think functionally we are a lot closer in terms of effectiveness for what we do. But when you say well rounded that. I dont think thats what you mean. What you is you havent leveled equally a lot of other skills. Which circles back to my original point. If you don't want to weight skills for certain classes I would at the very least bump up the contribution that leveling up a skill very high makes. If achieving level 3 presents the same religious level contribution that achieving level 100 is than I would say you do have a issue, and it will turn players off because it makes them feel unrewarded for devoting there time into their character.
I think one of the big things that I have pushed since the begining is their has been such a emphasis on seperating combat and crafting. Which has made interaction between players less rewarding. We have a opportunity to add excitement here and even more importantly interaction. Ie the gnome mines has Parisum. Making that mine filled with creatures that are difficult to kill and have low pay, but making the most rare and valuable material available to mine but only for skilled miners. It is only an example their are still going to be plenty of no risk gathering areas available. I am merely suggesting that the option to get some of the better materials have some risk to encourage interaction in the community and one that wouldnt require staff involvment. Also, by adding a level check to your mining makes the ability scale outside of output and effectiveness. Just some food for thought.
From what I understand, all of the higher level metals are smelted and not mined. Though I like the idea. It would give me an actual reason to join a hunt that already has a priest in it.
Its up to the players to make it happen.
I have a feeling Snaek intends to address the issue revolving around higher levels contributing more to your religious level progression. I spoke with him about personally in game and while I won't quote or put words in his mouth about his intetion to address this. He does agree that a scale being in place to increase level prgression for higher skill levels is a good idea.
-
Bocon Lampor
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 51
- Joined: Tue Jul 19, 2016 4:09 am
Re: New Combat System vs Healing
That's really opposite to what has been said lately though. It's been brought up many times now that there will be no scaling on skills. I feel that it would have been something he would have brought up in this thread during his last response if that design had changed. Maybe he changed his mind, I dunno. The player base only gets an inside look at what is being designed every few months during the CwC sessions, so I can only go off of that.