No melee attack should be FTG free, that's absurd. That's like me asking for my lower level spells to be free of cost, except worse.
PvP combat at these low levels is really out of whack and shouldn't really be taken too seriously. Armor absorbs too much damage at low levels, which is just 1 of the reasons you both were stale mated. The other, is that clerics do low damage, which is supposed to be that way and he was able to heal through your damage due to the armor and your low damage bonus.
I'd like to see pilfer removed from PvP completely until there's a perception stat or something. Level 1 pilfer was able to attempt pick my pocket 20 times before he got caught. I had over 300 on me and he was grabbing 66 of them at once, at level 1.......
Honestly, the only part of this post I can even agree with is:
" I know you'll all say this is a Role-Playing Game first and we don't need to powertrain to RP, but without mechanics and levels, we might as well not have a game at all and just play out all our interactions on the boards. Also, as someone who classically plays characters that frequently get into conflict with other players, I need to have skills to back up my actions and role play. Conflict is part of role playing; conflict resolution often requires a mechanical means of resolution. Standing around panting, while you beat on me because I'm so exhausted I can't defend myself, is just not fun for either of us. We don't all play heroes that work well with others to save the world! Some of us really enjoy the guile and intrigue of the underworld, making our way by more dasterdly and shady means! Someone's gotta be the villain!"
If you want something frustrating, go try crafting.
Stamina
Re: Stamina
I actually think there should be very low or even no ftg spells. At high level, you should be able to cast that novice-level spell in your sleep without even a second thought. It will have long out-lived it's usefulness, sure, and there will be vastly better things to use in it's place, but it should be second nature to you at very high levels. A high level weapons expert should be able to mow down goblins and orcs indefinitely with a small to medium sized weapon with minimal effort. As for pilfering, I've already sent reports to the staff about the disparity between NPC and PC picks, actually telling them to nerf my favorite skill because yes, picking players is actually easier right now than picking NPCs. I don't think that a level 1 picker should have free reign of other players' pockets.
High stamina costs severely hinder the levelling process. The entire genre of role-playing games is built around the notion that your character grows and improves over time. With practice and experience and work, come great rewards. If the idea is to completely stifle the levelling process, there might as well be a level 20 level cap to all skills, because getting much beyond will be excruciatingly painful. The fact that I can only swing my sword 25-30 times before I'm completely gassed is unreasonable. Asking me to spend thousands of (insert appropriate currency here) to level my skills because of some silly requirement to use consumables to keep myself energized is a barrier to enjoyment in any game. Games that are completely skill driven, without an overall character level, need to have a means of actually levelling those skills effectively.
This is why we're here: to give good feedback and discussion regarding different issues on a game still in progress. I like levelling up, and I don't like being hindered significantly by extra checks and balances that really don't serve much purpose. Perhaps feedback on the crafting skills needs discussion too; I personally havent spent any time working them yet, so am unable to comment in that regard.
High stamina costs severely hinder the levelling process. The entire genre of role-playing games is built around the notion that your character grows and improves over time. With practice and experience and work, come great rewards. If the idea is to completely stifle the levelling process, there might as well be a level 20 level cap to all skills, because getting much beyond will be excruciatingly painful. The fact that I can only swing my sword 25-30 times before I'm completely gassed is unreasonable. Asking me to spend thousands of (insert appropriate currency here) to level my skills because of some silly requirement to use consumables to keep myself energized is a barrier to enjoyment in any game. Games that are completely skill driven, without an overall character level, need to have a means of actually levelling those skills effectively.
This is why we're here: to give good feedback and discussion regarding different issues on a game still in progress. I like levelling up, and I don't like being hindered significantly by extra checks and balances that really don't serve much purpose. Perhaps feedback on the crafting skills needs discussion too; I personally havent spent any time working them yet, so am unable to comment in that regard.
- SilverShade
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 197
- Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm
Re: Stamina
As someone getting into the crafting aspect of the game to balance out the othe r skills, I can say it IS frustrating. If it weren't for the fact we're still getting uses on failures, we wouldn't be leveling anything up. I got to level four or five in digging just on failures.
Whenever that is "fixed," you'd be lucky several times over to be a legitimate player merchant without the benefits of being one of the admins. :/ Time and effort put in to it at that point wouldn't be worth it at all, we'd all be adventurers just because leveling THOSE skills would be less frustrating and more rewarding.
I understand the creators are looking into the success-fail rates and considering giving uses per successful tick, and I think that's a good place to start. From there, it'll be easier to see what else needs attention. I can accept the fact that adventuring skills will level faster than the crafting ones, as they should. It should take real effort to become a player merchant who crafts his own products. But there is a point where the rewards aren't worth the time and effort. Kudos to anyone maining professions this early in the game.
Whenever that is "fixed," you'd be lucky several times over to be a legitimate player merchant without the benefits of being one of the admins. :/ Time and effort put in to it at that point wouldn't be worth it at all, we'd all be adventurers just because leveling THOSE skills would be less frustrating and more rewarding.
I understand the creators are looking into the success-fail rates and considering giving uses per successful tick, and I think that's a good place to start. From there, it'll be easier to see what else needs attention. I can accept the fact that adventuring skills will level faster than the crafting ones, as they should. It should take real effort to become a player merchant who crafts his own products. But there is a point where the rewards aren't worth the time and effort. Kudos to anyone maining professions this early in the game.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
~Xercien
Re: Stamina
There's definitely a balance to be struck with consumables. If they were too good, mages would be using them instead of their vigor spell.
I'm not at all familiar with the current vigor vials. It might be that they are already fine and people are just too poor in the academy to buy them for all hunting. It might be different when Pearl opens. If that is the case, then it is the academy that needs work, not the vigor vials.
I'm not at all familiar with the current vigor vials. It might be that they are already fine and people are just too poor in the academy to buy them for all hunting. It might be different when Pearl opens. If that is the case, then it is the academy that needs work, not the vigor vials.
Re: Stamina
I posted this on the IDEA command, but I'd like to see an increase in stamina as I level up combat skills. Not every level. Maybe one point every two or three levels.
Re: Stamina
Also, I use two-handers exclusively right now, and have 85 stamina. I do well enough. I am spending a bunch of bottle of blue stuff though. It maybe rough for somebody starting from zero. So yeah, keep the costs the same, but give us the ability to gain more stamina as we level.
- SilverShade
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 197
- Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm
Re: Stamina
I like that idea. It would make sense, really. The more used to a movement you get, and the more conditioned you become, the longer you can keep doing the thing. Doesn't mean you never tire, it just means it takes longer to hit the point of exhaustion.
Even boxers tire out, matches only last a few minutes at most for a reason. They're unarmed (after a fashion). Add a short sword or a big knife, and you can't keep it up indefinitely. I think adding a point or so every other level could help with the stamina issue. Have it based on your highest combat skill or something. A point every other level is an extra 50 at level cap, and that's the generous end. Even an extra 33 points, one every three levels, could help take a bit of the sting out.
Even boxers tire out, matches only last a few minutes at most for a reason. They're unarmed (after a fashion). Add a short sword or a big knife, and you can't keep it up indefinitely. I think adding a point or so every other level could help with the stamina issue. Have it based on your highest combat skill or something. A point every other level is an extra 50 at level cap, and that's the generous end. Even an extra 33 points, one every three levels, could help take a bit of the sting out.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
~Xercien
Re: Stamina
Good stuff here. A lot of it is being factored into the stamina patch we've been working on the past week. I like to think we'll have something ready to go by the weekend, but that's a best guess and dependent on time available this week.
Re: Stamina
I tried to wait a few days before replying to this post in an attempt not to be overly critical with the recent stamina changes. I've only played around with the thief class so far so this is coming solely from that perspective. It is currently "F---ing" impossible to hunt, hide, pilfer, or sneak at a rate that would allow you to not go insane with boredom. This is way beyond the usual monotony of the training regime. Having to gulp potions, sleep, or hide in the shadows to regain stamina every 5 min is abit much. I'm about as big of a gaming addict as there is, but even I cannot stand to train for more than 15 minutes in this game without getting frustrated to the point of logging off. Good luck getting a newbie to stick around.
Now to try and be constructive. While frustrating, the current stamina use is far better than the no stamina cost prior to the changes for one reason. I could envision characters leveling so fast that the power balance would be thrown out of whack so quickly that a character wipe would be required relatively quickly. At least the way it is now, power training is out.
I think there have been some good suggestions so far and hope they are not only taken under consideration but put into effect. My personal take would be for combat; 1 handers should take only slighter higher than natural regeneration rates of stamina, perhaps 0.5 per swing, 1 handers 1 per swing and 2 handers 1.5 per swing. Hiding and sneaking 1 per attempt/ move. Pilfering should be 1 per attempt and a successful pilfer should be tied to level, not to how much a person is carrying. Disguise I think should be removed altogether, just to powerful. If you train enough with hide and sneak you can get dastardly deeds done efficiently enough. Don't have much experience with blindside and shadowstrike but they seem like they will be difficult to level even when changes occur.
I think the gaming footprint thats been created so far is awesome, good luck moving forward.
Now to try and be constructive. While frustrating, the current stamina use is far better than the no stamina cost prior to the changes for one reason. I could envision characters leveling so fast that the power balance would be thrown out of whack so quickly that a character wipe would be required relatively quickly. At least the way it is now, power training is out.
I think there have been some good suggestions so far and hope they are not only taken under consideration but put into effect. My personal take would be for combat; 1 handers should take only slighter higher than natural regeneration rates of stamina, perhaps 0.5 per swing, 1 handers 1 per swing and 2 handers 1.5 per swing. Hiding and sneaking 1 per attempt/ move. Pilfering should be 1 per attempt and a successful pilfer should be tied to level, not to how much a person is carrying. Disguise I think should be removed altogether, just to powerful. If you train enough with hide and sneak you can get dastardly deeds done efficiently enough. Don't have much experience with blindside and shadowstrike but they seem like they will be difficult to level even when changes occur.
I think the gaming footprint thats been created so far is awesome, good luck moving forward.
Re: Stamina
Yeah I've just recently been thinking about this a lot too. The balance between having to work to level up and having some sort of fun while leveling up seems to be a bit off.
I think maybe a lot of the problem I see with it is that a lot of skills have to be worked on alone (I mean that you are working one skill at a time, and also that you cant really socialize while you are doing it).
For example, to get hiding from 13 to 14 i figure will take me somewhere around 4-5 hours..that would not really be a big deal if hiding was something that i naturally worked on while I was say hunting or telling stories with other stealthy types in our den (this part of it is just a population base thing which I'm sure will change with time). But I cant really do that...I have to set up triggers to hide and reveal myself, and then every couple of minutes spend a minute and a half asleep. I also have to be present for this so I dont run the risk of AFK scripting. So, essentially, I have to spend 4 to 5 hours staring at my screen while triggers run and i can have little to no interaction...and that number will only increase.
What about when it gets to 8 hours? That's a work day..who would realistically spend an entire work day just watching a script run? More over, what is the point? I care about hiding, because my character needs to be able to hide (and hopefully at some point it will unlock other skills), but if i spend all my time trying to get good enough at hiding to get other skills and/or be able to hide(which again my character has to be able to do), then I'm not really spending any time interacting with the game world. I guess what I'm thinking is that it would be nice to have a way to train non-combat skills while interacting a little more, but I don't really have any good suggestions on how to do that. I'm helpful, I know.
Also, to be completely fair, I really don't know how high I need these skills to be. Maybe 13 levels of hiding is more than enough to hide from other players...in truth I dont really even know how hiding plays into things yet...or sneaking, or etc etc. So this may all be a moot point anyway because it may not be necessary to have skills as high as I seem to think I need them to be.
and I really don't want to come off as criticizing or complaining. The game has been open for what..? a little over a month. I definitely don't expect everything to be worked out right off the bat. I think that an amazing amount of work must have gone into getting this going and I'm definitely thankful that people have taken their free time to build something that I can do in my free time, for free. Free (sorry).
I think maybe a lot of the problem I see with it is that a lot of skills have to be worked on alone (I mean that you are working one skill at a time, and also that you cant really socialize while you are doing it).
For example, to get hiding from 13 to 14 i figure will take me somewhere around 4-5 hours..that would not really be a big deal if hiding was something that i naturally worked on while I was say hunting or telling stories with other stealthy types in our den (this part of it is just a population base thing which I'm sure will change with time). But I cant really do that...I have to set up triggers to hide and reveal myself, and then every couple of minutes spend a minute and a half asleep. I also have to be present for this so I dont run the risk of AFK scripting. So, essentially, I have to spend 4 to 5 hours staring at my screen while triggers run and i can have little to no interaction...and that number will only increase.
What about when it gets to 8 hours? That's a work day..who would realistically spend an entire work day just watching a script run? More over, what is the point? I care about hiding, because my character needs to be able to hide (and hopefully at some point it will unlock other skills), but if i spend all my time trying to get good enough at hiding to get other skills and/or be able to hide(which again my character has to be able to do), then I'm not really spending any time interacting with the game world. I guess what I'm thinking is that it would be nice to have a way to train non-combat skills while interacting a little more, but I don't really have any good suggestions on how to do that. I'm helpful, I know.
Also, to be completely fair, I really don't know how high I need these skills to be. Maybe 13 levels of hiding is more than enough to hide from other players...in truth I dont really even know how hiding plays into things yet...or sneaking, or etc etc. So this may all be a moot point anyway because it may not be necessary to have skills as high as I seem to think I need them to be.
and I really don't want to come off as criticizing or complaining. The game has been open for what..? a little over a month. I definitely don't expect everything to be worked out right off the bat. I think that an amazing amount of work must have gone into getting this going and I'm definitely thankful that people have taken their free time to build something that I can do in my free time, for free. Free (sorry).