New Combat System vs Healing

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Post by Creon »

Capping out melee even with a 10+ religious level difference the melee would win in a blow for blow mechanicly against a melee combatant with half the skill level but higher religious level. The biggest thing affected by religous level as far as melee combat is concerned is crit chance. The gap has to be fairly substantial and you are unlikely to notice too much of a difference in a short PvP bout. It plays out much stronger in PvE though. The player with lower skill will find it very difficult to kill enemies, however the crits will be less frequent. Whereas it is the opposite with the high skill level player will have little trouble hitting his opponent and dealing dmg but his chances of being critically hit are higher
Bocon Lampor
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Jul 19, 2016 4:09 am

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Post by Bocon Lampor »

Creon wrote: ↑Thu May 04, 2017 11:37 pm Capping out melee even with a 10+ religious level difference the melee would win in a blow for blow mechanicly against a melee combatant with half the skill level but higher religious level. The biggest thing affected by religous level as far as melee combat is concerned is crit chance. The gap has to be fairly substantial and you are unlikely to notice too much of a difference in a short PvP bout. It plays out much stronger in PvE though. The player with lower skill will find it very difficult to kill enemies, however the crits will be less frequent. Whereas it is the opposite with the high skill level player will have little trouble hitting his opponent and dealing dmg but his chances of being critically hit are higher
I'd love to see some numbers or testing on that theory TBH. Becuase this has not been my observation while on hunts with people of lower skill level, but higher PL/RL. Interesting observations.
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Post by Creon »

Data analysis isnt difficult. When I was recreated my religious level was substantially lower while my CC skill hasnt progressed much. I can gauge my analysis from my experience with my own characters and others that I have hunted with higher religious levels but much lower skill level.

Now if you are asking for raw logs or something your request wont be sated. However if you are asking my opinion gauged off my substantial experience than I can discuss it more in depth.
Bocon Lampor
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Jul 19, 2016 4:09 am

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Post by Bocon Lampor »

That's fine. I believe you. I just thought it was interesting that we saw different things. But honestly, things could have changed since then, since we never really know what's being done with the NCS. I still don't understand the philosophy behind melee and spells being able to crit, but prayers cannot.
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Post by Creon »

The system has been in a large flux since NCS has been released. It isnt surprising that you have different experiences. I can not speak for Snaek on prayers, however much further down the line I imagine prayers will crit or have critical effects. Right now they are trying to roll out a new class and two new races. Which I imagine is quite a feat considering wyrvens essentially have Psyionics and Dragons are dependent on natural attacks ie bite which is still in a bit of a flux. While priest are in a decent spot overall IMO. I would guess that a priest tuneup wont happen untill these things roll out.
Bocon Lampor
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Jul 19, 2016 4:09 am

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Post by Bocon Lampor »

When the critical system came out, I specifically asked if prayers were going to crit, and he said "no". There was no reason why attatched to it. Spells and prayers are mechanically the same exact thing, but renamed. Even IG the engery comes from your god for both. It makes no sense in both a coding sense and an IG sense that prayers cannot crit and it would not be hard to make them crit.

Other than turn still being OP, Priests have seen nothing but nerfs since they were the first class to get a passover a long time ago. I had to bitch and complain constantly just to have high level healing be different than level 40 and below healing (It barely is now, but something is better than nothing). Plague is still busted and fails an incredible amount for no reason, along with it sticking on resists or failing to stick on normal hits. This has been BUG reported and brought up EVERY SINGLE CWC since the spell was made public. I even made a thread about it with examples. Yet here it is, still broken, people pretending that it's some surprise and never been reported before.

Every class right now is getting a passover and skill-up's so to say, at least that's what came out of this recent CWC. I guess if your vision of a "decent spot" is priests can heal a group okay, vig, and turn, then I guess that's your own opinion. It's like me saying warriors are fine cause you can swing a sword and pummel.
Meanwhile, Mages continue to get amazing utility spells and more damage, blindside is getting buffed to match pummel (which is really good for a class that already has huge CC with poisons), and other classes are being brought up from the depths of being potatoes (Templars). So I'm not exactly seeing how these issues cannot be addressed while a major, game-wide passover is being done. Though just having dragons as a playable race will probably gain the game a few new people anyways, which seems to be the major pushing point right now.

Wyverns will be coming out far after Dragons do, at least according to the CWC that was held before this recent one. I didn't see anything about a new class coming out aytime soon though, but maybe I missed it in the log. Pretty sure Wyverns also use naturals as well.
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Post by Creon »

I said priest are in a OK spot meaning they function well. They power spike extremely early game and you can hunt vampires under level 20 solo if you have sound gameplay mechanics. No other class has that much of a power spike. Nothing priest have is inheriently broken, while there is room for improvement ie crit healing etc. Your skills as a whole are robust and functioning.

Warriors up untill a few weeks ago had pummel which isnt a exclusive skill but did not work properly. Add to the mix the other skill we have grappeling serves no purpose as it essentially does the same thing as pummel but less dmg.

Staff has come out in OOC logs in the past and said they were not doing something but change their minds further down the line. I feel confident some type of prayer scaling will happen down the line. My guess is criticals or critical effects.
Bocon Lampor
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Jul 19, 2016 4:09 am

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Post by Bocon Lampor »

I don't know how you could effecitvely solo vamps at level 20 without having to stop to heal an insane amount. Unless you're specifically talking about turn at level 20, which I agree that it's still OP and not working right with the NCS. But most of us aren't abusing this skill atm, at least afaik. Saying our skills are robust is true though, too bad there's literally no use for a lot of them right now other than to spam PT in a corner to raise your RL/PL, which is just sad. I find that nothing changes unless people speak up about it, which is why I'm very involved in my class. I don't think anyone likes to put in thousands and thousands of hours into their characters, just to see them badly designed and left behind.
Post Reply