Thieves help me out!

Discuss your favorite races, ask the questions you've always wondered about, or just follow along in the conversation. This is the place for everything that is Shattered Isles. Keep your debates civil. Trolls will be executed on sight.
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Thieves help me out!

Post by Snaek »

I may be a bit biased toward shady classes, but I don't claim to always know what's best for them. Maybe 98% of the time I do.

A lot of work has gone into getting disguise where it is. There's still work left to do, but one thing I want to make sure I get right is how your disguised presence is seen by the world in all situations. A recent issue that sprung up showed me that TELL and the Arrivals Channel are not consistent between displaying your disguised name and your real name.

So my question is, what do you all think is the best approach? I think logging in and out should show your disguised name when disguised, like the who list does now. Where I'm hung up on is the OOC Tell command. You can send a tell to the real name or the disguised name, so there's room for abuse there unfortunately. Easily identified and dealt with, but like the who lists and guild rankings of old, some people are going to use whatever is available to them to figure out which thief stole from them. My goal is to limit that as much as possible. I believe right now you receive tells from the disguised name. I'd have to double check on what is displayed when you send a tell to a disguised player.

Oh and in addition to fixing this issue, we are adding a filter for bad names to block options that obviously shouldn't be allowed, and others like staff members, unique names from movies/tv/novels, and names of historical characters. We'll also be adding the ability to disguise height and weight, but both need more work on setting racial limits. We don't need any 12 foot tall goblins terrorizing the city.

Lastly Assassins are getting a variation of disguised called Masking. We really want to make a push for assassins in SI to not be looked at in the same light as Thieves. They aren't deceitful. They are dedicated to their trade, respected for their discipline, and feared for obvious reasons. Disguise, in my opinion, is a deceptive skill. There's a thin line with these skills I know, but I've always viewed assassins as relying more on their ability to study their target and find the right opportunity to do the deed without being seen by others. The downside is death is not permanent and your target comes back knowing who killed them. So masking will give assassins the ability to disguise their name only. It's a tool used to get closer to their target more so than disguise their identity. A well trained assassin would be recognized as such and rely more on fear and instinct than deception.

Maybe I got carried away with assassins, but I know we don't always give you enough insight to better define your character's background and role play. Look forward to the feedback from thieves and assassins!
Krell
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 83
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 1:20 pm

Re: Thieves help me out!

Post by Krell »

Not too sure on the disguise thing. It makes most sense to me (so as to not abuse the mechanics behind it all and figure out who is who like you are saying) that once you go into your disguise your real name is taken out of the tell system and your fake name is put into it. So I cant send a tell to someone who isnt on the "who" list basically.

I like the idea with assassins being masked and was going to actually suggest that. Assassins don't need to necessarily look like someone else. they are not trying to commit a murder as another character, right? But an assassin also wouldnt necessarily want to take the fall for the murder either, so a feature that makes someone look like maybe say "A tall slender figure with face concealed behind a mask" might work out well. Although this does bring up the same issue with using tells / who list to determine the person. Maybe you would still log in and out as normal name, but when you go into masked mode a "XXX has logged out" message could send through and you could get removed from the tell list altogether. Can't send or receive.

Thanks for filling in some more thoughts on how you see the Assassin class too. By what you just said, I am thinking that you are seeing assassins as a publicly "accepted" role?
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Thieves help me out!

Post by Teef »

Actually I can totally see an Assassin disguising as someone else and murdering them so that person gets the blame. Makes perfect sense. Otherwise may as well roll a thief and get away and get rich to boot since as far as I can tell Assassins can't pick pockets
Krell
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 83
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 1:20 pm

Re: Thieves help me out!

Post by Krell »

I think it just depends on how the assassin class was intended to be.

Are they a class recognized by the world as an honored (or semi at least) and useful trade, or are they part of the underworld?
What happens when someone finds out you are an assassin?

The impression i get from the way Snaek talks about them and the class description is that they are a recognized trade...more like a branch of warriors that use more evasive tactics.
Theres a good chance im wrong about that...I usually am so...yeah.

Honestly I havn't had a real clear picture of what exactly I'm doing with my assassin and have just been kind of waiting for more skills to unlock / get implemented to figure out where to go with it.
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Thieves help me out!

Post by Teef »

More importantly. Do I get wrist blades?
Calanor
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 50
Joined: Tue Sep 24, 2013 9:29 pm

Re: Thieves help me out!

Post by Calanor »

I don't play a thief, but ill give my opinion. I think disguise should work across IC/OOC barriers. What if a thief has a long running disguise but needs to contact someone OOCly for whatever reason? Forcing the character to go through an auto reveal seems bad. There might be issues with some people absusing the mechanics of it, but in my experience the staff has been on top of those things quickly. With a relatively low playerbase and such a good staff, I can't imagine continual issues with harassment.

For assassins, I personally prefer no disguise skill. Disguise is such a crazy powerful tool and assassins are PK heavy in nature that I see a ton of issues with that. Yes, assassins could theoretically wear masks to cover themselves, but then why can't every other class as well? Why can't my mage snag a disguising mask for 2 doubloons at the corner store? Its a very powerful tool to have, and I simply don't think its required for the assassin class in this game. How would an assassin specifically benefit from a mask ability? I feel like they would benefit in much the same way every class would.
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Thieves help me out!

Post by Teef »

well the whole PK heavy in nature really makes no sense. as a thief you pretty much sign up for PvP. Remember dgate and the "PvP off" choice? And let's face it people who played fighters like Vincentiv could have easily passed as an assassin. But at least Vincentiv would RP it out with you. He liked to banter back and forth during fights. anyways, I'm a huge fan of Assassin's Creed... the actual gameplay not that whole pretense of using DNA to "re-live" memories. So unless Assassin's have a real standing in the community and it's seen as a "normal" thing to just hire one for the day I would see them being just as elusive as thieves. Otherwise I'll hang a sign in the post office "Have Dagger, Will Travel"

I haven't seen any OR/DR progression charts or comparisons by class so I have no idea if they classes are really any different other than the lack of pilfering and disguise. you still need a dagger for shadowstrike and backstab so it's not like them being able to use other weapons makes a difference. I don't see any kind of "shorts bonus" for thieves.
Last edited by Austere on Wed Oct 30, 2013 4:49 am, edited 3 times in total.
Reason: Please see staff post further in this thread for explanation.
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Thieves help me out!

Post by Teef »

But yes, Disguise should work across IC/OOC in the off chance we get any psionics and want to use esp
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Thieves help me out!

Post by Aumnren »

I don't play shadowy class either, but I do have a soft spot for them.

Concerning assassins, I partially agree with Calanor. Having a combat heavy class with the ability to disguise is incredibly powerful, but at the same time, I think assassins need to be able to do some recon without giving away who they are.

Then again, that goes back to what Krell just brought up. Is the assassin profession widely accepted? Or is it an underworld profession. That will probably guide you on how to make masking work. At any rate, if masking is implemented it should be temporary, fading when attacking or doing anything offensive. That way, the assassin can only use the masking ability for recon.

Besides, since you don't give away classes, we have to guess who the assassins are; cue the fear factor there. You don't know who to watch out for, and who not to piss off.

However, you might just want to let the assassins alone with hide and a sneak ability so they can move from room to room in the shadows. Instead of a disguise, arm them with tracking abilities so they can track down their prey, and then rely on stealth to set an ambush. This way, you make a distinction between thieves and assassins. Thieves deceive with disguise, assassins hunt with track.

Just some thoughts.
Krell
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 83
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 1:20 pm

Re: Thieves help me out!

Post by Krell »

The track thing was another skill idea I had on assassins.

A track that works only on other PCs, or maybe only on humanoid targets.
Post Reply