Snaek wrote:Our system isn't capable of one skill that can set all the weapon/armor stats based on the material, so our approach to armor is a workaround that meshes well with the world. If it goes well, I am sure we'll give weapon crafting a shot.
Let me make sure I understand this correctly.... what this means is that the quality of the material (other than some minor resale effect) currently and might not ever have any effect on the type of quality of the weapon/armor/whatever? But the level of the skill, or rather, the specific item crafted, can have an effect on the quality of the item?
If both of these are true, then does that mean your work around for armor (and why it is separate from blacksmithy) is to approach it like cooking? A recipe-based system, which asks for specific metals or items, in which the higher level items lead to higher quality armor?
If so, that makes fine sense to me. I might also suggest, if it is possible, to have the recipe items for armor require something made with blacksmithy (for instance, a piece of armor might call for a filigree), and this might have some effect on the armor?
Example: recipe X requires Steel, filigree and creates a breastplate. The material used for the filigree changes the description, but the real 'level of quality' is the specific metal used. The final product might look like a 'steel breastplate with gold filigree', or a 'steel breastplate with copper filigree', depending on what the filigree is actually made of.