Bad shield, BAD!

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Creon »

There was nothing about the fights that looked bad to me other than the high success rates of shield and parry in PvP.
I'm not level 1 shield block I have gotten up there seemed appropriate to me.
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Wren »

Blocking 80% or more of incoming attacks in PvP, in your case from a character that is higher leveled than you, does not strike me as appropriate. You may be up there in Shield Block, but you aren't even at the halfway mark yet, there's no reason it should be that effective against players. Same goes with Parry, and most likely Dodge as well, though I haven't witnessed the latter in PvP yet.

Thank you for looking into it, Snaek!
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Blink »

Blocking 80% or more of incoming attacks in PvP, in your case from a character that is higher leveled than you, does not strike me as appropriate. You may be up there in Shield Block, but you aren't even at the halfway mark yet, there's no reason it should be that effective against players. Same goes with Parry, and most likely Dodge as well, though I haven't witnessed the latter in PvP yet.
Yeah the fact that it works so well on someone high level like Morley so well is what bothers me. Actually I have a selfish motive to want shields to remain good against monsters. It's my only real defense against vampires. I've trained my dr very hard for a much, but it still seems to do nothing against even the lesser vampires. It's only slow spells and shields that keep vampires from snacking on me. My close combat and air shield spells just don't cut it there.
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Wren »

I'm hoping they'll find a way to fix it so that it isn't quite as crazy in PvP, without crippling its use in PvE where it's really needed. Maybe it isn't even the defensive skills that need to be tweaked, so much as the rate that players hit each other successfully, since they obviously don't proc nearly as much against monsters.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
User avatar
Morley Darkfire
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 97
Joined: Sat Nov 09, 2013 2:19 pm

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Morley Darkfire »

I parried 83 times(counting both parry and dual parry since unless I use different weapons I can't tell)
So I have a 45% defense rate with 2 skills. Of the 100 swings he got in he missed 50 times.

He had 88 blocks with his shield and 51 parries. For the block/parry bug overlap there were 12 so going to subtract the 12 from parry since it happens after.
So he has 46% with the Shield. and 20% with parry. Of the 64 swings I got in I only missed 13 times.

His one skill is more effective than both of mine combined.

I got in more swings because I would drink once then swing and not down a whole bottle.
So totals were Draven 183 swings, Me 191 swings

Using those numbers and when staff checks our respective levels they'll be able to make a decision.
User avatar
Morley Darkfire
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 97
Joined: Sat Nov 09, 2013 2:19 pm

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Morley Darkfire »

Also when I used the two-hander...up until the switch to dual parry.
We both had 9 swings.
He blocked 5 and parried 4.
I parried 2. He missed 3 times. and hit 4.
Anselm
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2012 12:46 am

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Anselm »

Numbers, much like language, have always fascinated me.

Morley vs Draven, Draven's blocks/parries and misses/hits against him only.
Draven parried Morley 45 times.
Draven blocked Morley 51 times.
Draven was hit or missed (as in the attack was not checked by a defence) 64 times.
Of the combined 96 parries/blocks by Draven against Morley, 12 of them were double messages (originally there were 51 parries, 57 blocks) - meaning the bug originally reported at the start of this thread. I do not know if this means the block was successful or the parry was the call, only that the block call comes first in the display. This is going to skew the numbers in some way, so I subtracted 6 from parry, and 6 from block, still leaving in the 12 total attacks which were defended in some way - simply not doubling them by keeping them at an additional 12 each.
28.1% parry.
31.8% block.
40.0% hits/misses that got through.
A total of 59.9% defence, with two defence calls.


*********************


In the Kaiah and Nikolas fight, the numbers were as follows:
Nikolas parried Kaiah 51.5 times.
Nikolas blocked Kaiah 77.5 times.
Nikolas was hit or missed (as in the attack was not checked by a defence) 101 times.

Of the combined 129 parries/blocks by Nikolas against Kaiah, 27 of them were double messages (originally there were 65 parries, 91 blocks) - meaning the bug originally reported at the start of this thread. I do not know if this means the block was successful or the parry was the call, only that the block call comes first in the display. This is going to skew the numbers in some way, so I subtracted 13.5 from parry, and 13.5 from block, still leaving in the 27 total attacks which were defended in some way - simply not doubling them by keeping them at an additional 27 each.

22.3% parry.
33.6% block.
43.9% hits/misses that got through.
A total of 55.9% defence, with two defence calls.


**************************************


In the Wren and Nikolas fight, the numbers were:
Nikolas parried Wren 64 times.
Nikolas blocked Wren 82 times.
Nikolas was hit or missed (as in the attack was not checked by a defence) 121 times.
Of the combined 146 parries/blocks by Nikolas against Wren, 14 of them were double messages (originally there were 71 parries, 89 blocks) - meaning the bug originally reported at the start of this thread. I do not know if this means the block was successful or the parry was the call, only that the block call comes first in the display. This is going to skew the numbers in some way, so I subtracted 7 from parry, and 7 from block, still leaving in the 14 total attacks which were defended in some way - simply not doubling them by keeping them at an additional 14 each.
23.9% parry.
30.7% block.
45.3% hits/misses that got through.
A total of 54.6% defence, with two defence calls.



Here is the fight from the side of those with parry and dual parry:

Morley versus Draven:
In the 9 times Draven attacked Morley whilst Morley was using a two-handed weapon, Morley parried 2 of them.
After Morley switched to dual parry (which I cannot differentiate from as he used the same weapon), these were the numbers:

Morley parried Draven 81 times.
Morley was hit or missed (as in the attack was not checked by a defence) 93 times.

46.5% parry/dual parry combo.
53.4% hits/misses that got through.

Kaiah versus Nikolas:
Kaiah parried Nikolas 40 times with her off-hand (though she started the fight with two of the same weapon, and I cannot differentiate between them. I can only say she parried twice with the same weapon name until she pulled out a different main-hand).
Kaiah parried Nikolas 85 times with her main-hand.
Kaiah was hit or missed (as in the attack was not checked by a defence) 132 times.
15.5% dual parry.
33.0% parry.
51.3% hits/misses that got through.
A total of 48.5% defence, with two defence calls.


Wren versus Nikolas:
Wren parried Nikolas 29 times with her off-hand.
Wren parried Nikolas 73 times with her main-hand.
Wren was hit or missed (as in the attack was not checked by a defence) 149 times.
11.5% dual parry.
29.1% parry.
59.3% hits/misses that got through.
A total of 40.6% defence, with two defence calls.

So no, not 80%. The RNG did poor Wren in, though, on that last fight.


I think an issue here is maybe many of you don’t realise another bug, which I believe I pointed out earlier in the thread. There is a bug in PVP, and it only occurs with shield block, where if a person swings at another sometimes the game will display a successful shield block. It is not always the case. After you see that display, you’ll notice the attack still goes through - sometimes it hits, sometimes it misses, and that is a matter of AR/DR and the RNG.

Let me give an example:
Draven blocks Morley's attack with a small mahogany shield!
Morley swings an ivory-pommeled steel falchion at Draven.
The attack is a grazing cut.
This is the same attack. It isn’t a separate one. It is the game displaying a faulty success message, despite the shield not actually blocking the attack. Draven still took that damage from Morley. Draven was still hit.

Another example is this:

In the Nikolas versus Kaiah fight, there were 131 shield block success messages shown. In actuality, Nikolas only blocked Kaiah 91 times (that is including the double messages, but not the faulty success display message described above).

Against Wren, it looks like Nikolas blocked her 133 times. In reality, he only blocked her 89 times (the same display bug mentioned with Kaiah, and described above).

Those attacks are still successful. To try to count them as shield block working, when the attack still went through (and either hit or missed, which is based on the DR system), is an overlook or disingenuous.

Another thing to consider is this: Dual parry is not supposed to be as successful as parry or shield block (you will notice the numbers on shield block and parry are similar.). Dual parry is used in conjunction with dual wield, which gives the player another attack. It would not be fair to have equal defence to someone using a one-hander whilst you are using two one-handers. I do not know if the difference is supposed to be that much, but it is supposed to be lower overall.

If for some reason a person does not think it is fair to not receive the full benefits of a second defence check whilst also receiving (once implemented) a second attack, then I welcome your thoughts on the matter with open arms.

Draven and Nikolas have higher shield block percentage than their parry because their shield block is higher than their parry - I will not say how much, because permission was not given for that fact, only the shield block being higher). Warriors start out with shield block, but unlock parry at level ten CC. It is higher not because it outperforms parry percentage wise, but rather because they start with it earlier, and because there are some hunting grounds where one cannot parry an attack.


Cheers!
Anselm
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2012 12:46 am

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Anselm »

I forgot to add:

Those are the exact same numbers one gets in PVE for parry and block. I do not know in regards to dual parry.
User avatar
Morley Darkfire
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 97
Joined: Sat Nov 09, 2013 2:19 pm

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Morley Darkfire »

Well in my logs they don't look like a single action. So I missed that.

Draven blocks your attack with a small mahogany shield!


You swing an ivory-pommeled steel falchion at Draven.
The attack is a decent slice.
[Delay: 4.0 sec.]
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Wren »

Wow, thanks for all that info, Anselm!
So no, not 80%. The RNG did poor Wren in, though, on that last fight.
Bah, typical. RNG and I have never been very good friends.
I think an issue here is maybe many of you don’t realise another bug, which I believe I pointed out earlier in the thread. There is a bug in PVP, and it only occurs with shield block, where if a person swings at another sometimes the game will display a successful shield block. It is not always the case. After you see that display, you’ll notice the attack still goes through - sometimes it hits, sometimes it misses, and that is a matter of AR/DR and the RNG.
I definitely missed it, but then it would have been difficult to pick out in all that combat spam. Does this mean defensive skills in PvP will be left alone, or are they in fact still in need of tweaking?
Against Wren, it looks like Nikolas blocked her 133 times. In reality, he only blocked her 89 times (the same display bug mentioned with Kaiah, and described above).
That explains why he stopped to mend a couple times. I honestly didn't think Wren got many hits in at all.
If for some reason a person does not think it is fair to not receive the full benefits of a second defence check whilst also receiving (once implemented) a second attack, then I welcome your thoughts on the matter with open arms.
I don't mind Dual Parry as it is right now, being less successful than its counterpart. Assuming things change with it once Dual Wield is attained though, I'd be happy to give some input.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Post Reply