Miners and Thieves

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Miners and Thieves

Post by Blink »

If the material has a higher effect on the end profit, it will encourage crafters to team up with adventurers to attain those materials. The crafters collect resources to be turned into profit, the adventurers can protect them, and the two methods of wealth generation can be shared at the end.
Pulled this out of Coraleth's crafting thread. Yeah, I love this idea. I would also love something similar with thieves to be implemented once lockpicking is in. In addition to of course monster chest locks. Areas in hunting areas that can't be reached without some lokpick checks, and at the same time some powerful guardians so a lone thief can't really get at the treasure alive. And even better, places to rob in the cities that require not just a skilled locksmith but also some heavy backup to deal with guardians and guards. vaults, safes, storerooms, and the like. Very difficult to get at because the rich make it so, but well worth the effort. And yeah, traps of course. It'd be really cool if Baelric and Isvela were doing breakins in Pearl, perhaps with some Pearlians trying to stop them. (Yeah I know, they'd never work together)

You could even create areas that require thieves and warriors to get at the resources, then miners to collect them.
CoralScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 122
Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm

Re: Miners and Thieves

Post by CoralScribe »

Stealing from meh thread are ya?! Data mining the huge wall of text?! You'll never get my agates!!! ::swings mining pick at::

Joking aside, all great ideas. I second them heartily.
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....

**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Miners and Thieves

Post by Aumnren »

I would also love something similar with thieves to be implemented once lockpicking is in...It'd be really cool if Baelric and Isvela were doing breakins in Pearl, perhaps with some Pearlians trying to stop them. (Yeah I know, they'd never work together)
The only problem with this is that thieves are the only class to receive the lockpicking ability (unless assassins get it and haven't said anything), and the only religion that can be thieves is Itzal. So unless your character is friendly with the Itzalites, you're not going to get squat out of this. You can't go to your own religion, and you can't turn to another. So you're right in saying that Baelric and Isvela would never work together, there's a lot of characters that would never work together because of religious differences, and therefore would never be able to take advantage of this partnership.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Miners and Thieves

Post by Blink »

The only problem with this is that thieves are the only class to receive the lockpicking ability (unless assassins get it and haven't said anything), and the only religion that can be thieves is Itzal. So unless your character is friendly with the Itzalites, you're not going to get squat out of this. You can't go to your own religion, and you can't turn to another. So you're right in saying that Baelric and Isvela would never work together, there's a lot of characters that would never work together because of religious differences, and therefore would never be able to take advantage of this partnership.
(Before I respond, another idea. You could let the Speculation skill be used in an urban setting to find things, but only behind locked and possibly trapped doors, and with possible guard attacks. Or you could create a Looting skill very similar to Speculation and Foraging)

It is true only those of Itzal can be thieves. This gives them a monopoly on lockpicking, if they are organized enough to enforce one. That's going to be how it is with locked chests anyway and locked rooms in general. If your character hates all of Itzal and is open about it they will never get into a locked room, just as someone who hates all of Aerthane will probaly have trouble getting help up into the sky and high areas.

Now speaking of my character in particular, Blink. Itzal is a big big faith, like Aestrava, with a huge variance of personalities among the followers. Furthermore, greed is a huge thing for them. Pure bribery is probaly going to overcome many issues if you need locks opend yet hate those of Itzal....if you can lower yourself to hire one.

Lastly, how likely are people to go breaking into homes in Pearl? Blink is not likely to at all. He's a bit morally flexible like many Avardi, but he's not really a criminal and doesn't see the point in thefts. Now if there was a city he saw as pretty evil, or if he became convinced Pearl was completely a lost cause, he might do that as some kind of political point. He might free prisoners though if he had a way to do so. However, Blink isn't my only character, and so it's not like I'll be completely blocked from using this if it's implemented.

And yeah it's pretty specialized, but you could have like locked areas really high up where you must fly to get to them, or really deep in the ocean. So that thieves of Itzal needs to team up with air mages or water mages to get at the loot. (Same with flames and earth utility modes when those are impemented. A fire mage protecting a thief of Itzal and going into a volcanoe to rob some fire creature's vault. That kind of thing. And fire elementals attack)
Anselm
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2012 12:46 am

Re: Miners and Thieves

Post by Anselm »

Heya mates,

I'd like to ask that we not discuss another character's specific RP unless that character's player brings it up personally. That's a real fine line to walk and probably one we shouldn't approach on our own.

But interestin' discussion!

Cheers,
Anselm.
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Miners and Thieves

Post by Aumnren »

If your character hates all of Itzal and is open about it they will never get into a locked room, just as someone who hates all of Aerthane will probaly have trouble getting help up into the sky and high areas.
There are flying races. Without dragons and wyverns being implemented, gargoyles can be of any religion, and slyphs can be all but Itzal. In addition, however, fly does not provide nearly the same utility as lockpicking - or the same utility as pilfer, a potent disguise, or any of their other skills.

As well, I don't think wind mages even have a fly spell yet, and even if they do, I don't think they can use it on other PCs.

This is not about my character, but an odd and seemingly arbitrary restriction that has baffled me from the start. If Cora, Geel, Visyn, Faran - any of them had things stolen from them, their items would be lost forever unless someone of Itzal would work for him. This goes for EVERY character not an Itzalite. As well locked rooms and their treasures would only be available to those of Itzal. Which means anything special inside is restricted to one class, which wouldn't be so bad if it were not also restricted to one religion.
And yeah it's pretty specialized, but you could have like locked areas really high up where you must fly to get to them, or really deep in the ocean. So that thieves of Itzal needs to team up with air mages or water mages to get at the loot.
Or Religions could team up with a thief of it's own kind, or allied religion to do it as well. But that still leaves all the locked doors on land that is reserved only to Itzal and their thieves - the number of chests and locked doors hidden on the main land would probably outnumber any of the underwater, volcano, or sky rooms.

Again, the current RP of my character is not the point here, but an overarching monopoly on skills that are reserved to a very specific class and religion combination, which also involves a style of RP. Yes, those of Itzal are suppose to be selfish and only out for themselves, but the current Itzal group is very tight-knit. No one can force them to split apart and start working for all sides, and I don't think they should. Frankly, I think restricting all the Itzal players to one outlook on life stifles the RP possibilities of the shadow religion. And the honor system won't work here to force Itzal players to simply disregard their fellow temple mates; as has been posted on these boards before, the honor system is not a viable form of enforcing rules in this game - or in any game, really, and as I said before, such a restriction would be a terrible idea.

Plenty of other religions have justifications for being thieves. An Avardi's dismissal of rules and lays lends well to this philosophy of a 'thief', so while some Avardi IG may not be the thieving type, others could. The same goes with Nydine players who want to play into the 'Kaleith pirates'. Pyrous PCs that use their thieving to crumble their opponents while building themselves up - it goes on and on.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Miners and Thieves

Post by Blink »

Snaek seemed quite clear that there just aren't going to be thieves not of Itzal any time in the near future, probaly never. It may have something to do with some of their abilities it sounded like, such as the higher level functions of disguise. Probaly it takes some kind of Itzal magic to do the really wild things like change your race.

True some of the playerbase may be blocked from locked areas, but it doesn't have to be a ton of them, at least right off the bat. I think it would add to the variety of in game experiences and encourage me to play other characters than my main more. I would certainly agree that the bulk of the staff's work should go toward areas all can enjoy, in particular standard hunting areas.

There is no fly spell in yet. It's likely coming in the next big update. It may or may not let air mages go all the way up in the sky though. I hope it does.

Sylphs can't be of Itzal. You could have a Gargoyle of it though I believe.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Miners and Thieves

Post by Blink »

Yeah so, here's an explanation why we can't play Avardi thieves, based on what little we've been told. I just figured it out.

Now it made no sense to me that there's no person in the entire world who can pilfer or pick locks that isn't of Itzal. That probaly isn't the case. What is going on is we are not allowed at character creation to really make base classes that are inferior. Even people that later become crafters start out with a fairly superior type of class, such as mage. I'm not allowed to make a cook class, but I could be a warrior then learn cooking. There are probaly locksmiths and petty thieves out there with lockpicking. There's the honest crafstmen that actually make the locks for those locked doors. Ernest probaly has one working for him. There are probaly urchins and outlaws with pilfer. We just aren't allowed to play them. Perhaps one day it'll be an option.

The only type of thief we are allowed to play is the best of the best, the thieves of Itzal. Why are the superior? The biggest reason seems to be the magic of Itzal that grants them the higher level functions of disguise, such as race. No one else in the world can do this, it's something near a true transformation or the like, or it's a powerful illusion. Second, Itzal is a huge and powerful religion. They ruthlessly keep control of all the best thieve's guilds. They may even kill or buy out practicing thieves of a certain ability, in order to maintain a monopoly on theft on all the Isles.
User avatar
SilverShade
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 197
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm

Re: Miners and Thieves

Post by SilverShade »

Under the Itzal page, camaraderie is listed as something many Itzalites value and rely on. To suggest they shouldn't be tight-knit doesn't seem to be accurate. Given the blatant distrust and even hostility shown to them, of course they would stick close together. Who else could they truly rely on to have their backs?

Also, the Itzalite group isn't as close to one another as you might think.

However, I do not think camaraderie with fellow worshippers is the only type they'd value. If one could truly gain the cooperation and even friendship of an Itzalite, it could provide a way in to all sorts of things.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
Gir the Minotaur
Posts: 21
Joined: Sun Apr 29, 2012 10:26 am

Re: Miners and Thieves

Post by Gir the Minotaur »

You could even create areas that require thieves and warriors to get at the resources, then miners to collect them.
there some areas already out that are similar to this..though i have crazy plans...crazy crazy plans
Post Reply