Forgive my ignorance on this topic. My experience with playing an assassin is limited and I do not intend for this to sound like sarcasm because that is not my intent.
If Assassins are so bad why does there seem to be so many of them? From my perspective assassins ruled the roost and now they are being brought more in line with how the staff envisioned them. This has wreaked havoc among those of you that were used to being the top dog. I could be completely off base here and if that is the case disregard this post.
Lock picking
Re: Lock picking
I think backstab should an assassin only skill, makes more sense, and then make it easier to level. As it is now it is near useless. Assassins need to have the ability to kill and quickly, but if they fail then they need to have severe consequences. Heavy damage upfront at a large fatigue cost, kind of the cheatah of the killing world, get caught in the first 200 yards and your dead, outlast that and the cheatah is spent.
Re: Lock picking
First and foremost because a lot of new players to games are immediately attracted to the 'dark' classes. It's only when you actually get farther along in training that you realize Assassins really aren't special in any way, and with them no longer having Dodge they're stuck with one defense that blocks one attack type until they get it to 30, we probably won't be seeing many new ones at all, as it's going to be that much harder to level them. The difficulty of working the class is not an issue for me at all, I enjoy the challenge, but I want the effort to amount to something.If Assassins are so bad why does there seem to be so many of them?
I've seen this 'in line' reasoning being thrown around a lot in any topic pertaining to Assassins, and I simply don't understand it. In line from what? When have Assassins been 'top dog' excluding the time before I joined when Backstab was way overpowered? More importantly, has anyone actually been killed by one yet?From my perspective assassins ruled the roost and now they are being brought more in line with how the staff envisioned them.
Yeah, this is why Aumnren's mention of reducing their offense is horrifying to me. As it stands, I don't think I could kill anyone in any decent amount of time unless they're low-levelled and in crappy armor.Assassins need to have the ability to kill and quickly, but if they fail then they need to have severe consequences.
While this has more to do with initial burst than unique skills as discussed earlier, I think it's an appropriate suggestion. This is how the class should be. High initial burst abilities. Get it done quickly or get the hell out kinda deal.Heavy damage upfront at a large fatigue cost, kind of the cheatah of the killing world, get caught in the first 200 yards and your dead, outlast that and the cheatah is spent.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
- Morley Darkfire
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 97
- Joined: Sat Nov 09, 2013 2:19 pm
Re: Lock picking
She said it all in a nicer way then I could have. That being said...
"IN LINE" is a cop out. Just because it's easier to nerf one class than to raise up the others doesn't mean it should be done that way. There really is no reason why other classes can't be improved to bring them up to this "perceived" notion about assassins. And that's all it is.
Soooo many of them. Besides me, Kaiah, Wren I don't see any long term assassins. Was sure seryth was a thief until i saw his OOC postings. Visyn went scout. Pretty sure Hrall quit the game for good. In fact I fully expected a bum rush to roll gavial and vuk warriors after the last fight since defense and HP ftw
"IN LINE" is a cop out. Just because it's easier to nerf one class than to raise up the others doesn't mean it should be done that way. There really is no reason why other classes can't be improved to bring them up to this "perceived" notion about assassins. And that's all it is.
Soooo many of them. Besides me, Kaiah, Wren I don't see any long term assassins. Was sure seryth was a thief until i saw his OOC postings. Visyn went scout. Pretty sure Hrall quit the game for good. In fact I fully expected a bum rush to roll gavial and vuk warriors after the last fight since defense and HP ftw
Re: Lock picking
You're misrepresenting what I said. My complete sentence was "in line with how the staff envisioned them". If my perception of assassins is incorrect then by all means educate me. I am fully aware my perception may be wrong.
Last edited by Swamp Ape on Fri Feb 21, 2014 4:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Doxx ~
- Morley Darkfire
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 97
- Joined: Sat Nov 09, 2013 2:19 pm
Re: Lock picking
Assassins reflect the darkest and most wicked side of the rogue. The dealing of death becomes a goal in itself, the epitome of evil. The assassin becomes so centered on this art that he begins to slow his pace, learning and contemplating each "mark" as the best method of killing them becomes clear. They also learn skills in keeping track of and tracking down their marks, as well as other means of making life for the targeted miserable, and short. The assassin can use any weapons, unlike the standard thief, though his armor is still restricted.
HMMMMMMM! points

HMMMMMMM! points

Re: Lock picking
Sorry, long post is long.
As well, as I suggested above, I don't think your offense should be reduced, just focused in the area of poisons and traps. I think assassins should be a very offensive class, but their offense should be different from a warrior's offense.
Also, what assassin vs. warrior fight are you referencing? Was this at the fight club?
However, that isn't what it has to be. It could be a blend of less burst, and utility.
Unfortunately, ifs are all we have right now. If traps and poisons are put in, then some of the defenses might have to go. If they're not, then the defenses will probably stay - although if they aren't I don't really know what the assassin class is except for a warrior with backstab.Morley wrote:I count a lot of "if"s in the above.
Those fights were were in a controlled environment with equally skilled opponents, where each attacker knew who their opponent was and when they would strike. As an assassin, using traps and poison, your defender wouldn't get this luxury.Morley wrote:If the tournaments have shown anything, it's that defense matters more than offense
This is because bite seems to be broken right now. It shouldn't be able to kill you at level 10 with, what I'm guessing, is your high level CC and therefore high AR/DR.Morley wrote:Draven could have probably bitten me to death with his level 10 bite.
This is probably because there isn't any effective way, besides magic, to cut through a defense. CC vs passive defense will take a while because the two are geared to oppose each other. Traps and poison, when implemented, should help assassins get past someone's thick defenses. To clarify my comment from my previous post, I think assassins should be offensive in nature, but offensive using guile, planning, and surprise rather than straight "kill it" combat.Morley wrote:So a class geared for offense is actually weaker than one that can't be hit.
To me, it was more surprising how much damage I did to Nikolas. I was landing grazing hits, yes, but decent strikes as well. My CC is terribly low, and yet I was actually able to some decent damage to him per strike, which should actually prove how effective CC actually is as a skill in general. Would Loriel have ever been able to kill Nikolas in a duel? No, because priests' AR is 2 and my CC isn't very high, and even at level 100 I'd have 200, maybe 250 max. The RNG might be cruel, but it's not priest eviscerates warrior cruel.Morley wrote:Also the RNG is pretty effective at rendering levels and AR/DR useless too, since you were able to hit Nikolas.
That's why I maintain that poison should remain an assassin only skill. And they should have some traps that only they can make if another class were to get the skill. Thieves, because they have so much already, shouldn't be given poison.Wren wrote:Assassins don't currently excel in anything, there's nothing about the class to make it exciting or worthwhile to put effort into if you can roll a Thief for example and have Disguise, which is infinitely better than Masking, and still have access to SS/BS/Poisons/Sneak, or go Warrior and still get Dual Wield/Dual Parry and be able to swap to a shield for Shield Block to fight against natural users.
Assassins get the same AR / DR as warriors, and two defenses as well. Your damage output should be exactly the same as any other CC class.Wren wrote:I honestly don't know how an Assassin's damage compares to that of other classes, and maybe things will change once class stats are implemented and racials don't count for as much, but given that an Assassin in better armor with 10-15 more CC levels couldn't take down a Warrior and was getting hit pretty hard in return, the idea of our offense being reduced is kinda scary.
As well, as I suggested above, I don't think your offense should be reduced, just focused in the area of poisons and traps. I think assassins should be a very offensive class, but their offense should be different from a warrior's offense.
Also, what assassin vs. warrior fight are you referencing? Was this at the fight club?
This is what the class of assassin suggests. The cost for that incredible burst will probably come from an assassins defenses though, wether that's removing duel parry, lower DR, both, or something else entirely.Wren wrote:This is how the class should be. High initial burst abilities. Get it done quickly or get the hell out kinda deal.
However, that isn't what it has to be. It could be a blend of less burst, and utility.
I don't even know how accurate the site information is any more to the staff's direction. A lot of things have changed since that site has been put up.Morley wrote:Assassins reflect the darkest and most wicked side of the rogue. The dealing of death becomes a goal in itself, the epitome of evil. The assassin becomes so centered on this art that he begins to slow his pace, learning and contemplating each "mark" as the best method of killing them becomes clear. They also learn skills in keeping track of and tracking down their marks, as well as other means of making life for the targeted miserable, and short. The assassin can use any weapons, unlike the standard thief, though his armor is still restricted.
Last edited by Aumnren on Fri Feb 21, 2014 5:14 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Re: Lock picking
Of the 4 regular Assassins I know of (Me, Morley, Wren, and Kaiah), 3 of us are Human, and Devalin doesn't really get any special racial perks for being an Assassin (as far as I know). So if we all wanted to be "top dog" mechanically speaking, we'd likely all have rolled Vuks. And as Wren said, I'm not sure when we WERE top dogs? Was it when backstab was insane? Because I'm not sure anyone abused that (especially in PvP) and it was pretty quickly fixed.Swamp Ape wrote:Forgive my ignorance on this topic. My experience with playing an assassin is limited and I do not intend for this to sound like sarcasm because that is not my intent.
If Assassins are so bad why does there seem to be so many of them? From my perspective assassins ruled the roost and now they are being brought more in line with how the staff envisioned them. This has wreaked havoc among those of you that were used to being the top dog. I could be completely off base here and if that is the case disregard this post.
I personally rolled an Assassin because I played Dgate for 9 years and always wanted a high level melee class. Assassins were said to be the "offensive" melee class, so I rolled one. I'm certain none of the current Assassins (who seem to be some of the more regular players) chose the class because it was "the OP class".
Last edited by Seryth on Fri Feb 21, 2014 5:27 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Morley Darkfire
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 97
- Joined: Sat Nov 09, 2013 2:19 pm
Re: Lock picking
Fine. I'll admit it. Draven actually had me beat. I had filled vigor bottles with healing. 
Stick that in your "over-powered" pipe and smoke it.
Stick that in your "over-powered" pipe and smoke it.
- Morley Darkfire
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 97
- Joined: Sat Nov 09, 2013 2:19 pm
Re: Lock picking
Not only that... when new players come from other games via topmusites, that's the description they see. and it's an awesome description and makes you want to roll one. To roll an assassin and not be able to kill anyone is just bad advertising and disappointing to say the least. That's why you see so many of them... it's also why you don't see many outside the academy. I never wanted to play an assassin. I wanted to be an arcanist. and put off trying the game before the open Beta because of that