[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author" [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author" [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author" [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author" [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author" [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author" [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author" [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author" [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author" [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author" Tell me again how weak mages are. - Page 2 - http://www.shatteredisles.com
Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
My comments were pretty specific on magic damage. And my worries tend to be more on monster hunting than PVP. I've yet to be in a real PVP fight as Blink doesn't use magic at Fight Club.
One, I was reporting that there appeared to be no gains over 17 levels of lightning bolt gaining, using lesser vampires as test subjects. You can believe mages overpowered and still see that this is a problem. There should be a gain. If it makes mages even more overpowered, then perhaps they need tweaked.
Two, I was saying there should be magic damage bonuses for the elemental elves. Once again, if this makes mages more overpowered in your view, perhaps they need tweaked again after. I'm sure the Creators are closely watching these matches. But that does not mean an Avardi air mage should be the exact same in damage as a Human Air Mage. Unless you believe the large races should lose their damage bonuses. (Which I don't. It makes the game more interesting to have some extreme examples like that)
While Teef's post is more than a little rough, it does bring up a couple good points.
First, there is a huge difference between melee and mages in a PvP fight. I doubt the differences between random PvP and the controlled instances of the fight club are really that big. It doesn't seem to take more than several seconds to put up a shield and throw out a slow or two, assuming RNG doesn't suddenly decide to leave you hanging out to dry.
Second, magic shields. As mentioned previously, the DR gained may be pretty negligible but combined with a physical shield and some of the best armor available, it's apparently a huge advantage, even after the recent changes to defense abilities. Against a mage, melee has zero defense (and obviously, resisting spells doesn't actually do anything) while mages have not only TWO ways to actively defend, but their spell damage doesn't suffer from a 'successful resist.'
Third, assuming balance off abilities and skills that aren't implemented. Yes, I understand that the end game is the goal. However, there won't be an end game balance if people get frustrated and leave. Balance is a never ending battle for most games, and it is especially aggravating for a game that, technically, isn't in beta status as far as the rest of the gaming community is concerned. Beta means finished classes, completed game zones, fleshed-out game lore, things we still lack. I would do a sales pitch for a game that was truly in beta status, you can sell that. I couldn't do the same for SI, as much as I'd love to, because I would be laughed right out of the room. These things have to also be considered when it comes to game balance, because if people get fed up and leave, the help necessary to achieve that balance won't be available. Don't waste such valuable resources like that.
Fourth -- and please don't take this the wrong way --, negative posts. A decent search of the forums over the past few months will show several legitimate, genuine posts with concerns or ideas that went mostly without dev comment for days or weeks, or even seemingly ignored completely. However, posts that are silly, insubstantial, or outright sarcastic and negative usually get a reply within a couple days, if not a couple hours. This teaches players old and new, that the latter will get attention far quicker than the former. It creates a negative, almost poisonous atmosphere, and everyone gets some blame here. Even I'm guilty of it, and Anselm has been the recipient of it. While I regret how I did it, at the time, I felt it was the only way I could get my concerns on a particular matter acknowledged. This should never, ever be the case, and I believe the devs need to make an effort to acknowledge those sincere posts before they ever chime in on something that's obviously sarcastic or looking to get a reaction. If people see that, they're less likely to be intentionally looking to get a reaction.
As for the topic here, I do believe that some things need to be addressed. Obviously we can't get anything accurate due to missing skills and lack of information being passed down, but I hope once all these missing skills are finally added, we can achieve some real balance. I, for one, will continue to try and be patient. With the game so young, it can't afford to lose what players there are that are willing to continue to offer feedback.
SilverShade wrote:
Fourth -- and please don't take this the wrong way --, negative posts. A decent search of the forums over the past few months will show several legitimate, genuine posts with concerns or ideas that went mostly without dev comment for days or weeks, or even seemingly ignored completely. However, posts that are silly, insubstantial, or outright sarcastic and negative usually get a reply within a couple days, if not a couple hours. This teaches players old and new, that the latter will get attention far quicker than the former. It creates a negative, almost poisonous atmosphere, and everyone gets some blame here. Even I'm guilty of it, and Anselm has been the recipient of it. While I regret how I did it, at the time, I felt it was the only way I could get my concerns on a particular matter acknowledged. This should never, ever be the case, and I believe the devs need to make an effort to acknowledge those sincere posts before they ever chime in on something that's obviously sarcastic or looking to get a reaction. If people see that, they're less likely to be intentionally looking to get a reaction.
Sometimes there's no response for legitimate concerns or ideas, or they've already been posted via the IDEA command in game. This isn't meant they're not read (I read everything), it means sometimes it probably seems a little redundant to send off a cheers!. Or it'll take a while to get the proper information to respond, because it isn't my area originally.
Yes, negative posts do sometimes get a faster reaction. It isn't because they're silly or sarcastic, however, it's because they're often littered with harmful misinformation, tiresome histrionics and/or outright lies in an attempt to get other classes nerfed or their own class buffed and this needs to be quickly addressed. It's not something anyone looks forward to, it isn't fun, it isn't enjoyable, it's wasteful to tie up resources purposefully like this and in fact it's a mite exhausting.
If you've felt you've posted an idea that hasn't been brought up before, or if you've specific questions pertaining to your suggestions that you'd like addressed and discussed, I'd highly encourage you to mail support@shatteredisles.com. Even if it's something you've posted and can't find, or can't remember the specifics of what you've said, I'm likely to remember it and we can discuss it (that goes for anyone).
Sometimes even something as simple as 'we will look into it' or 'it's on our list, thank you' is enough acknowledgment. Simply knowing and seeing that would do wonders in improving the forum environment.
I think a lot of issues for mages could be worked out by Implementing a few of the following:
Slow change it to 1 sec delay level 1-49 2 sec delay 50-99 3 sec delay 100.
Increase the RT of damaging spells by 1 second mathematically I think this could bring the average in significantly more although with there damage consistency they should have a lot more output .
Restrict armor to lighter less protecting versions.
Remove the use of shield skill and increase the effectiveness of the shield spell.
Lowering the length of the slow spell / giving a pulse stamina cost (as the spell goes on in intervals it takes 5 stam away or whatever staff deems appropriate)
this is slightly separate but healing prayers should possibly take a slight penalty if the player is being attacked. I don't know if the penalty is how effective it will be or if it will go off but the priest could literally outheal 2 players damage. Maybe this would change when the RNG of weapons gets tightened up but I thought it might be worth mentioning.
I don't necessarily think all these ideas should be implemented I would mix and match it would help bring balance to the class. I had the highest racial modifier and I couldn't get Faran less than 30% of her health with a two hander before she could get me down over 200HP. It's not bad that the mage can do that much damage it's that there is no real check against it.
Creon wrote:I don't know if the penalty is how effective it will be or if it will go off but the priest could literally outheal 2 players damage. Maybe this would change when the RNG of weapons gets tightened up but I thought it might be worth mentioning.
Is this you speculating or is this a fact that has been demonstrated?
Creon wrote:I don't know if the penalty is how effective it will be or if it will go off but the priest could literally outheal 2 players damage. Maybe this would change when the RNG of weapons gets tightened up but I thought it might be worth mentioning.
Is this you speculating or is this a fact that has been demonstrated?
It was slightly demonstrated. I out-healed Requiem and Blink as they were attacking me, but Blink wasn't using his spells, just his weapon; had Blink been throwing thunder, I would have died, no questions asked.
So the answer is, yes, I out-healed two characters, but it was not two characters using their best attacks.