Actually, assassins don't have two separate defensive skills. They have one defensive skill, and a second check of the same defense. So really, it's just one. Pretty sure that's been said several times. You, however, actually DO have two defensive skills.
Of course parry works on only a few mobs. It works on the ones using actual weapons. You having shield is a huge advantage over that, because it blocks ranged and naturals as well. I really don't see what the issue is here.
Shield, Parry, ETC
- SilverShade
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 197
- Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm
Re: Shield, Parry, ETC
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
~Xercien
Re: Shield, Parry, ETC
Parry only works on a few of the mobs
We have two defense 'checks' against a single type of attack, which after the nerf barely procs at all. Not sure why you're throwin' Assassins out there like we're somehow in a better position, especially since you just highlighted the very issue we face being stuck with Parry/Dual Parry and it only working on a few of the mobsAdditionally Assassins are a offensive class yet they have two defense skills.
You have Parry for weapons, and Shield Block for weapons and everything else. Tanks are typically defensive in nature, and so you are, while still having the same AR progression as the to-be top melee fighters.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Re: Shield, Parry, ETC
don't forget flailed weapons! parry works against those! now if only there were some available to buy... or some on mobs... or some in a peddle
Re: Shield, Parry, ETC
No they are two separate defensive rolls, shield block mistakenly had multi rolls per round now it works just like all the other defensive skills they all have the same set % value if I'm not mistaken. I thought it was 33% but apparently it's even lower.
- SilverShade
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 197
- Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm
Re: Shield, Parry, ETC
They show up as two dfferent things on the skill list, but they both protect against only one thing.
Shield block was way overpowered when it was blocking multiple strikes in a round. You, as a warrior, can block ranged attacks, natural attacks, and weapon attacks. (And flailing attacks.) You can defend against two weapon uses, two ranged attack users, two natural attack users, or a pair consisting of a combination of them.
Assassins can only block weapon attacks. And flail type attacks, apparently. Off-hand parry is a second check for the same defense type. It gets the chance to try to defend if the normal parry doesn't make the check. Sometimes, if we're really lucky and have performed our daily sacrificial ritual to the RNG gods, it'll help us defend against two attackers. As long as they're using weapons. Or flails.
You, as a warrior, can defend against more attack types than any assassin can.
I'm still not seeing what the issue is.
Shield block was way overpowered when it was blocking multiple strikes in a round. You, as a warrior, can block ranged attacks, natural attacks, and weapon attacks. (And flailing attacks.) You can defend against two weapon uses, two ranged attack users, two natural attack users, or a pair consisting of a combination of them.
Assassins can only block weapon attacks. And flail type attacks, apparently. Off-hand parry is a second check for the same defense type. It gets the chance to try to defend if the normal parry doesn't make the check. Sometimes, if we're really lucky and have performed our daily sacrificial ritual to the RNG gods, it'll help us defend against two attackers. As long as they're using weapons. Or flails.
You, as a warrior, can defend against more attack types than any assassin can.
I'm still not seeing what the issue is.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
~Xercien
Re: Shield, Parry, ETC
Shield block has not been able to block multiple attacks per round since January 1st.
Edit: Allow me to clarify, before someone tries to make a tiny error in roundtime that'll never be able to be fixed as if it's a big deal. Shield block has not been able to block multiple attacks per round since January 1st. There is a small roundtime issue for all defence skills (block, dodge, parry, dual parry) that sometimes you will block multiples in the same round time. It is very rare.
As for flail weapons, yes, they were made so parry could defend against them. We can certainly put them in, if you'd like. I was withholding so every melee wouldn't use flail weapons to slaughter assassins before this change went in, but next time I'll remember not to.
Concerning parry and dual parry, it is a second defence-check, and yes, it is a second defence. Is it a second TYPE of defence? No, but it is a second defence. Unless you don't consider the additional percentage to defend a second defence, but I'm sure every class that actually only has one defence would disagree with you quite quickly.
If your defences are barely proccing, it's because you're low level. I'm not particularly sure what exactly is wanted: previously it was complained defences fire too much, the levels have been adjusted to more appropriately reflect when they should be hitting for specific percentages.
Finally, yes, shield block when it was blocking multiple times in a round (and, again, it hasn't since January 1st) was incredibly overpowered. If we'd known about it, it'd have been fixed sooner, but sadly it was only reported by one person far, far down the line.
Edit: Allow me to clarify, before someone tries to make a tiny error in roundtime that'll never be able to be fixed as if it's a big deal. Shield block has not been able to block multiple attacks per round since January 1st. There is a small roundtime issue for all defence skills (block, dodge, parry, dual parry) that sometimes you will block multiples in the same round time. It is very rare.
As for flail weapons, yes, they were made so parry could defend against them. We can certainly put them in, if you'd like. I was withholding so every melee wouldn't use flail weapons to slaughter assassins before this change went in, but next time I'll remember not to.
Concerning parry and dual parry, it is a second defence-check, and yes, it is a second defence. Is it a second TYPE of defence? No, but it is a second defence. Unless you don't consider the additional percentage to defend a second defence, but I'm sure every class that actually only has one defence would disagree with you quite quickly.
If your defences are barely proccing, it's because you're low level. I'm not particularly sure what exactly is wanted: previously it was complained defences fire too much, the levels have been adjusted to more appropriately reflect when they should be hitting for specific percentages.
Finally, yes, shield block when it was blocking multiple times in a round (and, again, it hasn't since January 1st) was incredibly overpowered. If we'd known about it, it'd have been fixed sooner, but sadly it was only reported by one person far, far down the line.
- SilverShade
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 197
- Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm
Re: Shield, Parry, ETC
I can't really consider an 'additional percentage to defend' with what is really just the same defense skill a second defense. It's just a greater chance to parry, or even parry twice in the same round, I'll give you that. We're still exposed completely to every single type of attack left out there, and it actually limits us in what we can effectively hunt or train with.
People, in this case warriors, and their shields have the ability to defend against a greater variety of attacks. They have options. They're flexible. I would actually give up off-hand parry to be flexible and have options, but we gave up that fight (especially since it's been confirmed that parry won't defend against natural attacks, ever.)
We've accepted our limitations. I think those with options don't realize how much we wish we were in their shoes.
I still don't see what the issue is.
People, in this case warriors, and their shields have the ability to defend against a greater variety of attacks. They have options. They're flexible. I would actually give up off-hand parry to be flexible and have options, but we gave up that fight (especially since it's been confirmed that parry won't defend against natural attacks, ever.)
We've accepted our limitations. I think those with options don't realize how much we wish we were in their shoes.
I still don't see what the issue is.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
~Xercien
Re: Shield, Parry, ETC
I thought it was suppose to work like that but in my defense I'm stupid. LMAO My point is that warriors should have a overall higher defense % it doesn't need to be crazy but we are a defense driven class and to make up for a increase in defense you could lower our hit rate, or take away off hand parry and dual wield there are many options on the table. This is all under the idea that warriors are a primary tank class if I am wrong please correct me.Finally, yes, shield block when it was blocking multiple times in a round (and, again, it hasn't since January 1st) was incredibly overpowered. If we'd known about it, it'd have been fixed sooner, but sadly it was only reported by one person far, far down the line.
Very Respectfully,
Draven's Character
- SilverShade
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 197
- Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm
Re: Shield, Parry, ETC
That's the thing, warriors cover a range of types. You're not JUST a defensive fighter. You have options. You can dual wield and be offensive like an assassin. You can equip a shield and be defensive.
Why cry about having options? Seriously, we'd trade you in a heartbeat.
Why cry about having options? Seriously, we'd trade you in a heartbeat.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
~Xercien
Re: Shield, Parry, ETC
Creon,
I feel ya! the nerf bat hits hard, but its all in the master plan. I have no doubts your toon will do just fine. Your not just a defensive tank your an offensive one also, well atleast against none priests and mages (currently). And I don't think assassins have much to complain about based on what is planed down the line with poison and duel wield.
I feel ya! the nerf bat hits hard, but its all in the master plan. I have no doubts your toon will do just fine. Your not just a defensive tank your an offensive one also, well atleast against none priests and mages (currently). And I don't think assassins have much to complain about based on what is planed down the line with poison and duel wield.