A Letter to the Shattered Isles Community

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Post Reply
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

A Letter to the Shattered Isles Community

Post by Aumnren »

I will be bowing out of the game going forward. I am sad to say that, over recent months, the game has become less and less enjoyable for me to play, and this derives from one very big reason.

In Shattered Isles, racism (concerning races in SI) and religious bigotry are lore-founded ways to engage in RP conflict. However, I have constantly seen, been witness to, or have heard of through other characters and players, misogynistic and sexist remarks in both an IC and OOC setting.

Some of you might stop reading at this point because I have the 'audacity' to mention sexism. If you have lost interest by now, consider that the reason why I've brought misogyny up.

I understand that the allure of RP is creating a character to do as one pleases, but the world of SI is based off of very specific manners of conflict (race and religion) that fuel the little lore we have been made aware of. These lore-based conflicts are either ignored or punished in the game by the player base - and rarely rewarded or encouraged by staff. You will see those of conflicting religions running around with each other and pretending as if their ideals or deities have no qualms. Should one express dislike for another of a religion or race, in which it is scripted in their lore page for them to have very difficult feelings towards, such interactions are usually looked down upon by other players as being unreasonable or 'mean'.

The only manner of RP conflict I have seen the player base widely accept seems to be that of demonizing and turning against female characters, using their gender as means of devaluing them to simply their bodies, or to suspect treachery, deceit, or any manner of 'evils' from them - instead of engaging with (or hating, even) a female character based off of racial or religious tension.

This is exhausting. Let me repeat that. This is exhausting. Role-playing in this manner is not only frustrating, but it is infuriating to see the consistency in which this manner of conflict has taken hold and propagated throughout the game. I understand that characters are their own, and that neither staff nor other PCs can dictate a character's motives to you, but conflict, suspicion, and rumor mongering specifically and unilaterally based on gender - a conflict motive, as I have said, that has no basis in game lore - is not, and should not be acceptable to the staff or the player community.

These issues have been blatantly expressed OOC, in addition to IC, in the way some players chastise and mock how others choose to express their female character's sexuality. A woman, either real or as a character, is neither a whore nor a hooker for engaging, exploring, or expressing her sexuality. They are not manipulative, evil, or suddenly reduced only to the way in which they use their body. I am sick of seeing the IC and OOC opinions on female characters orbit around how other players or PCs believe the women spend their time naked, and how they use sex to get ahead - as if a female character does not have the wide breadth of skills, abilities, and intelligence to succeed through the sheer force of her will, cunning use of magic, or the swiftness of her blade.

Before the words "but women do use sexuality to manipulate others" come out of your mouths, let me make something fantastically clear. The idea that women manipulate others primarily through the use of sexual allure is a common trope used in fiction, and is an idea that has leaked its way into how we culturally view women through it's overuse in mainstream media. A femme fatale, the woman who uses her sexuality to manipulate and gain the upperhand, has been a stock archetype of a female character since ancient times. The trope became more recently defined and popularized in 20th century noir film and fiction, where the femme fatale's main goal was to seduce, manipulate, and ultimately betray the main character (almost always a male detective) as the detective unwittingly played into the femme fatale's hands. The name in French literally means 'disastrous woman'.

But the femme fatale archetype is simply that: a stock mold - an easy tool in fiction to present a mystical, unnerving, and ultimately flat and predicable character. It reduces a female character to one side only - her sexuality - instead of encompassing the cornucopia of details that it takes to make a good and engaging character. The femme fatale trope strips the female character of her agency, resigning her goals, motives, and talents to a singular aspect of herself.

While SI is based in a fictitious universe, the characters who live within, male or female, should not be so easily defined by such tropes, and what is infuriating is that this trope is often forced onto female characters in the game against their will, and spread through rumors until the idea solidifies.

I am tired of this. It is a cheap, pathetic tool, and robs the character of her complexity. I will no longer support a game whose player base so eagerly gorges themselves on the putrid carcass of such pathetic RP, and will no longer support a staff who who say and do nothing about it.

Let me be clear. While Shattered Isles has barely crawled forward the past seven months, both in IC world events and OOC game mechanics, I played the game understanding that SI was a growing project. Although I have become bored with stagnant game progression, I want both the staff and the player base to understand that my boredom has only played a minor part in my farewell, and should not be used in any manner to demean or distract from the real reason I have decided to leave the game.

It will be hard to believe I wish you all luck for the future of SI, but I do. Shattered Isles shows promise, and was enjoyable to play for a time, but until this game tackles and learns to focus RP in lore-based manners, and steer clear of the pitiful excuse for RP that derives from gender-based motives, it will continue to be a festering pit of uninteresting, worthless, and ultimately exhausting roleplay.

Farewell,

Loriel's Player
Visyn
Conclave Representative
Posts: 115
Joined: Sun Dec 01, 2013 4:25 pm
Location: Illinois

Re: A Letter to the Shattered Isles Community

Post by Visyn »

I really hate to see you go. I very much enjoyed your character and what he/you brought to the game. Best of luck in your next venture.

Visyn's Player
User avatar
Kiriath
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 79
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2014 2:35 am

Re: A Letter to the Shattered Isles Community

Post by Kiriath »

I haven't gotten to know you well, but any loss to a gaming community (except for trolls and munchkins) truly is a loss.

For what it is worth, I am a woman who plays a female character and have yet to experience any sexism ic or ooc. I'm sorry your experience has been different.
Kiriath Windrose, Chatelaine of the Temple of Aerthane
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: A Letter to the Shattered Isles Community

Post by Wren »

It is a loss. I'm honestly heartbroken to see such a great player and character go.

This whole situation involving misogyny has me a bit bewildered, however. I know there have been a lot of accusations and suspicions involving one or two particular characters, but beyond that I don't actually know where this issue is. Both Kaiah's player and myself are women who play female characters, and neither of us have personally experienced much if any sexism, certainly not to the point of becoming genuinely offended.

As said, racism and religious bigotry are lore-encouraged issues in this game, while misogyny is not, but I'm sure for some people the former hits home more than the latter, so where do you draw the line when it's all meant to be in character? I can't know all of what is being said IC or OOC when I or my character are not around, and if the matter has gotten to this point then I have to believe there's a reason for it - I just hate that it has caused so much frustration for others, and driven someone I loved RPing with away, when I know next to nothing about it.

There are a lot of women in power in the Shattered Isles world. Some of which are, in fact, villainous and cruel in nature. Personally? I love seeing that, but speaking ill of them and potentially others who's motives may seem questionable (and not everyone's character is in the 'loop' to know who's doing what) is to be expected. If a character has been slandering them to the point that it has created this mess, shouldn't they be pulled aside OOC and spoken to? They may not even realize the harm they're causing.

On the topic of conflicting religions being ignored, I agree - to a point. While religious conflict is an enticing atmosphere, we also have to consider that SI currently has a very small player base. In the case of my own character and her partner, they would have had NO ONE to hang around with because there were virtually no Itzalites besides ourselves, and there are still very few. Aerthane and Pyrous seem to be the most populated of the religions, and are said to be closely associated with each other. I've seen characters of both religions running around a lot together, so I'm not sure where the groups of conflicting religions are, with the exception of Wren who sees most people as sources of entertainment and curiosity regardless of their faith because that's just how the character is. Maybe it should be better rewarded and encouraged by staff, I would definitely like to see more religion-heavy RP events and the like, but the players have to do their part too of course.

All this to say, I'm sorry that the matter has chased you off, and would like to see it tended to. I would not want this to be goodbye forever, or to have it cause any further damage to a community I've become very fond of.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: A Letter to the Shattered Isles Community

Post by Swamp Ape »

I have not witnessed what you're referring to and it is unfortunate to see a player/character as widely known and entrenched in the game as yours leave.
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: A Letter to the Shattered Isles Community

Post by Snaek »

This has been a topic of much debate at a staff level over the last month. I'll be the first to admit that many of these stereotypes had to be pointed out to me as being more than just “of that time period." As I've become more aware, I've taken it upon myself to be more mindful of what goes into creating a character (pc or npc), lore, and the environment.

I'm very sad to see someone of your talent for roleplay leave us. Truly. You are exactly the type of player a game creator strives for. You can create something out of nothing, you bring others together, and you try to improve the world.

I do however think you lay wide blame when those in question are very much in the minority on this position. It's certainly not an atmosphere supported by the staff or the game. That doesn't excuse us from not dealing with it more appropriately, but we do put a lot of thought into creating a world that doesn't encourage this kind of behavior. We expect players to deal with things as their character would, and if the situation becomes harassing, report it to staff immediately.

You're not wrong about your minor reasons for leaving .We are small but we devote what time we can and learn from our mistakes as we go forward. There's much to be learned from your departure as well that will hopefully make for a better game in the future.

Thank you for all that you contributed to the world.
Post Reply