I'd put 600 as top end, with 500 an hour being more of the average. I'd consider Bocon's levels to be above average as well. This is also considering you have max armor.
And I think we all know, that crafting makes you far beyond that. It's not even remotely close.
I'd love to see some feedback from melee and mage classes, as to what they earn per hour on average.
If we get the spell that links our targets damage intake to our own HP, having a huge set of armor won't really be that needed. I am also really hoping for ablative and absorb shields as well, so I guess we'll see.
Priest discussion and feedback
Re: Priest discussion and feedback
And I think we all know, that crafting makes you far beyond that. It's not even remotely close.
Trystan’s script time is in a pursuit to see if anything opens up from cure disease prayer, so I have no experience with crafting or the earnings range if you wouldn’t mind sharing?
Trystan’s script time is in a pursuit to see if anything opens up from cure disease prayer, so I have no experience with crafting or the earnings range if you wouldn’t mind sharing?
Re: Priest discussion and feedback
It's hard to say where priests should be set, due to the coming changes being so huge. In particular, the damage changes for both weapons and magic.
I can make 1200 an hour as a mage. This is with death risk and lessened uses due to healing, however. I can make 1000 at a place like statues, with less risk and more uses. Keep in mind though, this is only due to my DR and Close Combat being pretty high for a mage. After you get to a certain point with your 3 rank attack spell, DR starts to matter much more for solo hunting. My good shields skill and decent first aid probaly help a lot too. Skill with slow spells is important too, as failed slows will really cost you some hits when you are solo.
Mages actually do really well in groups, because the vast majority of mages won't have high defenses, and a warrior or the like can do the leading and blocking, freeing up the mage to release high amounts of damage uninterrupted. Mages only get 3/3 progression with Close Combat, and the dr gains from shield spell are even slower to come. (every two levels after the base of around 30).
The only combo that seems to earn higher amounts is high level large race Warrior types. I haven't tested this personally, but I've observed it quite a bit in groups. I see the dramatic result in the group coin payouts. Like high dr mages, high level large race combos are almost non existent right now. The vast majority of mid to high level weapon wielders are Humans and elves.
Oh and Trystan, I'm pretty sure you saw the drop in pay rate when you hunted just with Blink back before the turning change last month or so. You were doing really good solo before that. (Undead used to get damaged on turn results more, heavily) I'm pretty sure now if you hunted alone with Blink, he'd actually raise your usual rate.
Until the new damage changes go in, this is a fairly low damage, high monster hp system.
I remember a while back I was at 900-1000/hr at vampires. I got frustrated with seeing few gains from lightning, so I went on an extensive Close Combat training spree. And that managed to drag me up to 1200, but it was a very long process. I could probaly do similar again and get myself higher, but the Close Combat uses are much higher, so it'd take much longer.
The dr/defenses thing applies to priests as well, just not to the same degree, because of your increased healing ability. Still if you get really ripped up, it does eat up a good chunk of time to heal.
Also, most of the mid level mages in the game have a regular partner. So you are probaly not going to get a lot more feedback about solo mage earning of established mages.
I can make 1200 an hour as a mage. This is with death risk and lessened uses due to healing, however. I can make 1000 at a place like statues, with less risk and more uses. Keep in mind though, this is only due to my DR and Close Combat being pretty high for a mage. After you get to a certain point with your 3 rank attack spell, DR starts to matter much more for solo hunting. My good shields skill and decent first aid probaly help a lot too. Skill with slow spells is important too, as failed slows will really cost you some hits when you are solo.
Mages actually do really well in groups, because the vast majority of mages won't have high defenses, and a warrior or the like can do the leading and blocking, freeing up the mage to release high amounts of damage uninterrupted. Mages only get 3/3 progression with Close Combat, and the dr gains from shield spell are even slower to come. (every two levels after the base of around 30).
The only combo that seems to earn higher amounts is high level large race Warrior types. I haven't tested this personally, but I've observed it quite a bit in groups. I see the dramatic result in the group coin payouts. Like high dr mages, high level large race combos are almost non existent right now. The vast majority of mid to high level weapon wielders are Humans and elves.
Oh and Trystan, I'm pretty sure you saw the drop in pay rate when you hunted just with Blink back before the turning change last month or so. You were doing really good solo before that. (Undead used to get damaged on turn results more, heavily) I'm pretty sure now if you hunted alone with Blink, he'd actually raise your usual rate.
Until the new damage changes go in, this is a fairly low damage, high monster hp system.
I remember a while back I was at 900-1000/hr at vampires. I got frustrated with seeing few gains from lightning, so I went on an extensive Close Combat training spree. And that managed to drag me up to 1200, but it was a very long process. I could probaly do similar again and get myself higher, but the Close Combat uses are much higher, so it'd take much longer.
The dr/defenses thing applies to priests as well, just not to the same degree, because of your increased healing ability. Still if you get really ripped up, it does eat up a good chunk of time to heal.
Also, most of the mid level mages in the game have a regular partner. So you are probaly not going to get a lot more feedback about solo mage earning of established mages.
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Priest discussion and feedback
You have to take several things into consideration in regards to the income from craft skills. There's the time it takes to craft the item, and then the time it takes to gather the appropriate materials. It probably isn't as high as you may think it is. As I'm not in a crafting mode, it'll be a while before I have results to post.
As for the heavy vs light armor, I'm a big fan of the idea. I'm a firm believer in that warriors and barbs and templar types should prefer heavy armor, while casters and stealth types should lean towards lighter materials. A thief or assassin or scout isn't going to work in heavy metal armor, and very few warriors are going to be ok with being in front in only leather. If you want to be mobile and nimble, dress light. If you want to be front and center and taking the brunt of the damage, you wear metal. You can tank or you can dance, it would be silly to do both. However, before any of that can be realized, there are several things that need fixing in regards to combat in general. I do look forward to seeing it happen, though. (However, if you're a priest, I don't believe you need to be in the front ranks anyway. No one puts their healer directly in harm's way. If you're using the defend skill, you better be ready to either heal yourself like crazy or have heavy equipment on you for those 'just in case' moments. And then pray your prayers don't fizzle too much.)
I don't know right off the top of my head what my toon can make in an hour, but I'll test it over the weekend and post my results here. I'll average it, since obviously having a mage or priest or gavial strength will affect things.
As for the heavy vs light armor, I'm a big fan of the idea. I'm a firm believer in that warriors and barbs and templar types should prefer heavy armor, while casters and stealth types should lean towards lighter materials. A thief or assassin or scout isn't going to work in heavy metal armor, and very few warriors are going to be ok with being in front in only leather. If you want to be mobile and nimble, dress light. If you want to be front and center and taking the brunt of the damage, you wear metal. You can tank or you can dance, it would be silly to do both. However, before any of that can be realized, there are several things that need fixing in regards to combat in general. I do look forward to seeing it happen, though. (However, if you're a priest, I don't believe you need to be in the front ranks anyway. No one puts their healer directly in harm's way. If you're using the defend skill, you better be ready to either heal yourself like crazy or have heavy equipment on you for those 'just in case' moments. And then pray your prayers don't fizzle too much.)
I don't know right off the top of my head what my toon can make in an hour, but I'll test it over the weekend and post my results here. I'll average it, since obviously having a mage or priest or gavial strength will affect things.

Hierophant of Itzal
-
Nikolas Suyessod
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 184
- Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am
Re: Priest discussion and feedback
Priests should probably not be earning the same amount - by themselves - as any direct damage dealer.
Mages can earn between 800-1200 depending on their level in casting and defence, yes.
Melee earning capabilities are interesting. Higher damage mod helps, obviously (as well as the extra health), but percentage hit for melee with weapons is really iffy. We can earn close to what a mage does if we underhunt. If someone is using ever unbalanced naturals, however, that's a completely different scenario in which they will outearn a weapon user not necessarily because of damage mod, but because natural's damage range is tighter (along the lines of mages but a little higher) and its AR has always been wonky in the calculation, allowing for overhunting of the corresponding level.
Group situations vary because it depends on who your partner is. A priest and a mage probably wont make the same individually once split as a mage makes by themselves because you now have two people. The mage cannot make up the damage needed - since the priest is lacking - by themselves. However, this probably isn't the case for groups with two mages and a priest, or an area where a priest doesn't have to heal as much. The same cannot be said for a priest with melee weapon users (please see the aforementioned commentary about unbalanced naturals, they're two completely different scenarios for feedback here), because a melee weapon user is always going to have weird hit rates even at the appropriate levels for the hunting ground.
This doesn't mean someone shouldn't take a priest, however, or that someone making as an example 1000 by themselves per hour but only 800 per individual per hour with a priest hunting partner is a bad result. It makes hunting less tedious, requires less downtime, less potions bought, an extra person to carry, company if you like that sort of thing, and so on.
I've never been a big fan of limiting caster armour, especially not in a system like the one we're in right now or possibly even in the future, depending on all which is implemented. Metal can be light, and light - as in weight - armour doesn't necessarily mean it wont protect for as much. It's a fantasy game, after all. If casters are going to try to be limited due to healing and spells, then the same should apply to templars and they should not wear heavy armours.
Mages can earn between 800-1200 depending on their level in casting and defence, yes.
Melee earning capabilities are interesting. Higher damage mod helps, obviously (as well as the extra health), but percentage hit for melee with weapons is really iffy. We can earn close to what a mage does if we underhunt. If someone is using ever unbalanced naturals, however, that's a completely different scenario in which they will outearn a weapon user not necessarily because of damage mod, but because natural's damage range is tighter (along the lines of mages but a little higher) and its AR has always been wonky in the calculation, allowing for overhunting of the corresponding level.
Group situations vary because it depends on who your partner is. A priest and a mage probably wont make the same individually once split as a mage makes by themselves because you now have two people. The mage cannot make up the damage needed - since the priest is lacking - by themselves. However, this probably isn't the case for groups with two mages and a priest, or an area where a priest doesn't have to heal as much. The same cannot be said for a priest with melee weapon users (please see the aforementioned commentary about unbalanced naturals, they're two completely different scenarios for feedback here), because a melee weapon user is always going to have weird hit rates even at the appropriate levels for the hunting ground.
This doesn't mean someone shouldn't take a priest, however, or that someone making as an example 1000 by themselves per hour but only 800 per individual per hour with a priest hunting partner is a bad result. It makes hunting less tedious, requires less downtime, less potions bought, an extra person to carry, company if you like that sort of thing, and so on.
I've never been a big fan of limiting caster armour, especially not in a system like the one we're in right now or possibly even in the future, depending on all which is implemented. Metal can be light, and light - as in weight - armour doesn't necessarily mean it wont protect for as much. It's a fantasy game, after all. If casters are going to try to be limited due to healing and spells, then the same should apply to templars and they should not wear heavy armours.
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Priest discussion and feedback
Tested quick this morning. In an hour, my PC made just under 1000 coins off statues (including coins earned selling trash drops). Used mending, vigor bottles, steel daggers, and no company.

Hierophant of Itzal
Re: Priest discussion and feedback
I’d like to see the priest class as a support class that increases overall group output from 30 to 50 percent to make up the lack of a DD class being added to the group. This would encourage bringing a priest along to all hunting areas without giving them any advantage in a solo situation.
Re: Priest discussion and feedback
Good idea Trystan 
if(IsGrouped == TRUE && hasPriest == TRUE)
{ arBonus += 10; drBonus += 10;
}
::cackles::
if(IsGrouped == TRUE && hasPriest == TRUE)
{ arBonus += 10; drBonus += 10;
}
::cackles::

Re: Priest discussion and feedback
I'd love to see a prayer that does this for the group, kind of like how Holy Shield does this for a single target!Xiija wrote:Good idea Trystan
if(IsGrouped == TRUE && hasPriest == TRUE)
{ arBonus += 10; drBonus += 10;
}
::cackles::
(also, coding jokes FTW!)
I think this should be the general target for the class. What we lack in damage, we should make up for in buffs (or debuffs). Frankly, I've always drifted towards support classes because I've liked a) their utility, and b) their eclectic skill set. That, and I've never been one to participate in the continual arms race that inevitably follows the DPS focused classes.Trystan wrote:I’d like to see the priest class as a support class that increases overall group output from 30 to 50 percent to make up the lack of a DD class being added to the group. This would encourage bringing a priest along to all hunting areas without giving them any advantage in a solo situation.
I think this is true, and will have to be something the Priest, as a class, will just have to get use to. We should certainly have our moments, sure, but simply by doing less damage, we are apt to earn less. As I've kind of explored before though, Priests don't entirely have a mechanical money sink. Although, more items like the tabard I was gifted (thanks Nikolas!Nikolas Suyessod wrote:Priests should probably not be earning the same amount - by themselves - as any direct damage dealer.
And this is the primary reason I think Priests should become the support class. Low damage output not only hampers our own hunting, but also drags down the hunting of others. As Nikolas said, however, Priests help to make hunting more enjoyable, and removes a lot of the downtime, thus making them a valuable member of a hunt, but it'd still be nice to see priests equipped with the skills to pull their own weight on the battlefield.Nikolas Suyessod wrote:Group situations vary because it depends on who your partner is. A priest and a mage probably wont make the same individually once split as a mage makes by themselves because you now have two people. The mage cannot make up the damage needed - since the priest is lacking - by themselves...This doesn't mean someone shouldn't take a priest, however, or that someone making as an example 1000 by themselves per hour but only 800 per individual per hour with a priest hunting partner is a bad result. It makes hunting less tedious, requires less downtime, less potions bought, an extra person to carry, company if you like that sort of thing, and so on.
This is why I brought up the "Skyrim" example. I have never seen another game handle casters and armor as well as Skyrim has. Granted, Skyrim to SI isn't an apples to apples comparison, as mechanics differ drastically. Nikolas brings up good points, though, about casters and armor, in that they can't be stripped of it simply because it's canonically accepted to do so. Points which I think should be considered going forward when building out caster dynamics.Nikolas Suyessod wrote:I've never been a big fan of limiting caster armour, especially not in a system like the one we're in right now or possibly even in the future, depending on all which is implemented. Metal can be light, and light - as in weight - armour doesn't necessarily mean it wont protect for as much. It's a fantasy game, after all. If casters are going to try to be limited due to healing and spells, then the same should apply to templars and they should not wear heavy armours.
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Priest discussion and feedback
I doubt be stripped of it. I think wearing heavy armor would just cause interference with spells. I think that's perfectly reasonable. If you want to be a bombass healer, wear the light armor and crank those prayers out all day long. If you want to be a tank, wear the heavy armor and realize your heals won't be as efficient. You want to melt someone's face with fire, well, you may as well wear the equipment that encourages that. If you just want to take more hits, that's your choice.
Same for rogue-types, even warriors. Wanna be quick? Lighten the load. You wear the heavy stuff and you're not going to be quite as nimble, but you'll make a decent meat-shield (especially as a warrior).
Given the classes I've played across games spans the spectrum, I think it's a fair trade. There's just other parts of the game that need adjusting to ensure it works for everyone.
Same for rogue-types, even warriors. Wanna be quick? Lighten the load. You wear the heavy stuff and you're not going to be quite as nimble, but you'll make a decent meat-shield (especially as a warrior).
Given the classes I've played across games spans the spectrum, I think it's a fair trade. There's just other parts of the game that need adjusting to ensure it works for everyone.

Hierophant of Itzal