Priest discussion and feedback

Discuss your favorite races, ask the questions you've always wondered about, or just follow along in the conversation. This is the place for everything that is Shattered Isles. Keep your debates civil. Trolls will be executed on sight.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Swamp Ape »

Nikolas Suyessod wrote:Priests should probably not be earning the same amount - by themselves - as any direct damage dealer.
Why shouldn't a priest have the same money making potential as any other class? Each class should have their own pro and cons but I do not think money making potential should be reduced for any class. I shouldn't have to suffer being poor just because I choose to play a priest and that goes for any class. I should have the same potential to make as much money as anyone else at the appropriately comparable levels.
Wonton
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 8:35 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Wonton »

Swamp Ape wrote:
Nikolas Suyessod wrote:Priests should probably not be earning the same amount - by themselves - as any direct damage dealer.
Why shouldn't a priest have the same money making potential as any other class? Each class should have their own pro and cons but I do not think money making potential should be reduced for any class. I shouldn't have to suffer being poor just because I choose to play a priest and that goes for any class. I should have the same potential to make as much money as anyone else at the appropriately comparable levels.
I don't think Nikolas meant
Nikolas Suyessod wrote:Priests should probably not be earning the same amount - by themselves - as any direct damage dealer.
to mean "priests shouldn't make as much money as DDers ever," but that they shouldn't be able to now because current mechanics limit their earnings. It was a continuation from a the discussion on classes and hunting earnings going on before, I believe (Nikolas, correct me if I'm wrong, please).

I think we'd all like to see the money gap crossed - even myself who doesn't see much mechanical need for it - so that Priests don't have to sacrifice coin for their class, though it might end up being something they have to live with for a while.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Swamp Ape wrote:
Nikolas Suyessod wrote:Priests should probably not be earning the same amount - by themselves - as any direct damage dealer.
Why shouldn't a priest have the same money making potential as any other class? Each class should have their own pro and cons but I do not think money making potential should be reduced for any class. I shouldn't have to suffer being poor just because I choose to play a priest and that goes for any class. I should have the same potential to make as much money as anyone else at the appropriately comparable levels.
Because each class must have a foil, a pitfall, pros, cons along with skills and abilities which complement not only one another but also all the other classes also in a game.

On a purely hypothetical: If a mage and a melee can earn 1000 an hour, why should a priest? Why should a priest earn 1000 an hour yet not have the same amount of down time, would not have to have the potion cost to ensure staying alive, and so on and so forth as a mage or melee? Why? The former two classes* are direct damage dealers, the primary role in which they serve. The latter, a priest, has a primary function of healing. This doesn't mean a priest should not be able to take in an agreeable, notable and profitable income. No one wants to make hunting (more) tedious than necessary. Yet hunting, for the sake of balance, must offer risk and balances to each individual class - whether by themselves or in various group compositions. Why should a priest have the luxury of healing - the most valuable ability in the game - in addition to being able to earn the same as or out earn - if we then remove costs and factor in downtime - classes which have the direct purpose and role of damage?

Why do you think that should be the case?

*mages must all be the same across each subclass in SI because they are bound to religions. They cannot function like other games where the archetypes were traditional in earth being primarily defence, fire being primarily offence, etc. It would tip the scales too much to specific religions and create an imbalance more than already exists. This has been discussed before, briefly, yet I wanted to note it for the sake of clarity.
Wonton
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 8:35 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Wonton »

Nikolas Suyessod wrote: Because each class must have a foil, a pitfall, pros, cons along with skills and abilities which complement not only one another but also all the other classes also in a game. . .[Mage and Melee] are direct damage dealers, the primary role in which they serve. The latter, a priest, has a primary function of healing. This doesn't mean a priest should not be able to take in an agreeable, notable and profitable income. No one wants to make hunting (more) tedious than necessary. Yet hunting, for the sake of balance, must offer risk and balances to each individual class - whether by themselves or in various group compositions. Why should a priest have the luxury of healing - the most valuable ability in the game - in addition to being able to earn the same as or out earn - if we then remove costs and factor in downtime - classes which have the direct purpose and role of damage?
Ah, so I was wrong in my initial understanding of your comment. I'm sorry for that, and thank you for clarifying.

This is a good point, though. I'm not sure which class is a foil for priests, so monetary earnings might be the way to balance the fact that (from what I've noticed) priests could likely fair well against any class that they are comparably leveled with. They can't likely kill any comparable class, but they couldn't be killed either.

I didn't think about the fact that healing is, perhaps, one of the most valuable skills. While there are additional ways to heal (as there should be) for non-priest classes, that having both a stamina heal and a health heal makes for a valuable toolbox that cuts out a lot of the downtime and extra costs of potions. Though I think your point that a priest should still earn "an agreeable, notable and profitable income" is important. After all, crafting earnings are universal, and takes just as much time for a priest as any other class, and not to mention it earns you more, so technically priests aren't really handicapped economically now as it is, just when it comes to hunting earnings. And for priests who don't want crafting RP, the "agreeable, notable and profitable income" level in context for what it will be for DD classes is likely still in the air with the casting changes and melee damage updates coming up.
User avatar
Xiija
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2014 6:55 pm
Contact:

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Xiija »

priests may have heals/vig that others have to pay for, but priests will not have
the weapons/combat skills , so they will take longer to kill their target, thus making less money,
or an equal amount per time spent as those with potion costs?

I'm fine with priest solo hunting being confined to undead, and would like to see areas
like a haunted forest, with MOBs that SWARM, making it almost impossible for Anyone to solo...

and making it almost Imperative to bring a healer :P

As for armor:
most games like WOW etc use "cloth cannons" any spellcaster who doesn't go toe to toe should
have an armor limit, but again, this pre supposes AOE, DOT, and distance spells :P
Image
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Swamp Ape »

As a priest I believe I do have the same amount of downtime and perhaps in some cases even more downtime. I have virtually no DR and I have one defensive skill. I get hit by everything on a consistent basis. Unless I am hunting below my level I need to heal after every encounter and I am unable to take on more than one critter at a time.

Please keep in mind I am not complaining nor am I making the case for an upgrade to priests. I am only stating my experience with hunting and the downtime required as a priest.
Wonton
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 8:35 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Wonton »

Swamp Ape wrote:As a priest I believe I do have the same amount of downtime and perhaps in some cases even more downtime.
I think an important thing to remember here is that a priest's 'downtime' spent healing might prevent us from hunting more, but the prayers we use to replenish our health and stamina are our core class abilities. Mend is for everyone, but isn't a class skill for any, and likely won't unlock anything. Healing Touch, however, does unlock new prayers. So we save the money in potions, and any 'downtime' not hunting for money is spent improving our class' skills. To me, downtime is when you're not improving class skills, earning doubloons, or roleplaying - say when a non-healing class has to stop to drink potions, sit and mend, or wait for their stamina to recover after a fight*. For me, then, downtime for priests is fairly low. But this is, of course, based on my personal definition of downtime.

*Of course, on group hunts, the entire experience ends up being somewhat roleplay, so even the time spent healing with potions or mend kinda wouldn't fall under my definition of 'downtime' then, but that's neither here nor there.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Swamp Ape »

In the parameters of moneymaking potential; downtime is anything that is preventing me from making money. If i'm healing, i'm not killing. Also mend and healing prayers are the same in my opinion because they are both a skill that is being advanced by being used.
Wonton
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 8:35 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Wonton »

Swamp Ape wrote:In the parameters of moneymaking potential; downtime is anything that is preventing me from making money. If i'm healing, i'm not killing. Also mend and healing prayers are the same in my opinion because they are both a skill that is being advanced by being used.
I'm sorry, SwampApe, but I just don't agree. At least, not in the way you're explaining it, and not in the context of a Support class. Saying that "mend and healing prayers are the same. . .because they are both a skill that is being advanced by being used" is like saying that mend and Close combat for warriors are the same because they are advanced by being used. They're not equal in their importance for the class. Advancing close combat makes a warrior better at being a warrior. Advancing healing prayers make priests better priests.

If your goal is to maximize your money making potential as a priest, then you should really just craft. As it has been noted, crafting returns dwarf hunting earnings without the need to heal or repair armor. And if you aren't worried about raising your class skills (and it sounds like you're not because your goal is just to make money), then crafting seems to be the perfect fit for your needs.

That being said, the only grounds where priests can come close to matching DD hunting effectiveness are places with undead MOBs. So, perhaps an undead hunting ground with a difficulty in between Crypts and Vampires is needed to give priests a more gradual hunting curve for those who wish to hunt.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Swamp Ape »

I get a sense that we are either misunderstanding each other or we are debating about two separate things that only sound similar on the surface. I'll bow out for now and observe.
Post Reply