Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback (SPOILERS)

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback (SPOILERS)

Post by Blink »

Some feedback on the new area, specific to hunting and skinning. The foragers look happy!

There's some good animals there, but it's difficult for me to hunt there regular yet. The main reason is the low number of badgers, which are the creature I'd mainly want to hunt. I did notice I can get by, with using centipedes. (which provide 20 doubloons worth of chitin) However, if I'm in an area like that, I'd rather focus on bone or other material I can carve, not get half coin, half bone. It looked like I'd make around 700 doubloons an hour, selling chitin, hide, and bone to my usual seller. Not very exciting really, especially if I can't get all bone.

Now, the warthogs. Obviously, they are the toughest thing in the game now, at least for most people, due to the high armor. The only people that seem able to really hunt them effectively are high strength races and those with pulse spells. I get a minor hit for every bolt I cast. (this issue may go away when magic damage is overhauled and/or a magic damage modifier is added) I think in the long run warthogs will be a great creature, but in the short run they make this area not quite work for me, as they are about a third of the creatures there and I can't hunt them effectively. (Other issue is low price of ivory, but that is being fixed in the trade update)

So yeah, quick fix would be to put in more badgers or some small to medium animal to fill in the spots between badgers. Once I can hunt Warthogs though the area will be great I think.

I did just think of one thing I can try. I will attempt to mix badgers with timber wolves, since they are nearby.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback

Post by Shadowbane »

I like the idea of a tough warthog. I've seen boars and warthogs in action IRL and those things are beastly. As someone who's had a rough run for most high level hunting areas until recently (thank god for trogs), I think it's reasonable to introduce something else that's equally challenging.

Looking forward to checking the new area out!
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback (SPOILERS)

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Blink's feedback on warthogs is accurate. If after the trade update there is a significant gap between ivory and other bone, then they are likely set right. For now, it takes over two minutes for one to be killed, which is more than twice the time it takes to kill a greater vampire. They do drop a number of resources, yes, but if you are speaking in terms of efficiency and overall payout (not in doubloons, but in terms of resources) it'd make more sense for a skinner - and please correct me if I am wrong, Blink's player - to visit some of the other areas. Ravenswood or Tallwood Forest animals don't drop as much per, but the time in which they die is significantly lower and it adds up. Not to mention the gophers which will kill themselves for you a good percentage of the time.

I like the new area (though wish there were a few more resource additions, unless they are extremely rare which is entirely possible and will keep looking) and the other creatures, and it's actually rather fun to hunt the warthogs; but, as I said before, Blink's feedback on them is accurate in terms of balance at this moment.

As for troglodytes, they should probably be revisited. I'm under the impression they're supposed to be similar to vampires but with an option for parry users, which I'm sure everyone agrees was needed. They pay similar in doubloons, or more in some cases, to vampires. However, unless vampires have been recently adjusted (didn't have time to go compare today, will another), then troglodytes are a far superior hunting ground in terms of ease and profit. They do not hit as hard as vampires, they do not hit as often as vampires, they are easier to hit than vampires, they die faster than vampires, when you combine the payment of the poles and spears of troglodytes the pay is bumped even higher. In a forty minute hunt (and previous hunts which weren't timed but noticed), 500 more doubloons were earned than is generally done in an hour hunt at vampires. There is significantly less downtime. They should probably be looked over again or vampires adjusted (if they were not already, will test another day).

I do like the troglodyte area and MOBs in general, though.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback (SPOILERS)

Post by Blink »

I think the difference in trogs and vamps is due to how strong priests are on undead. It's astounding how fast we kill them with priests, especially when we have two. I saw a massive increase in group hutning profits after the changes, and that was even with turning being tweaked down., since I hunt with priests often.

I'd guess that timber wolves have the best materials output right now in the game, but no one has the skinning skill to take advantage. You can't afford to waste materials there from failed skinning attempts, as you invest so much time killing just one, but they have lots of material.

Same thing goes with the ravenswood wolves, to a lesser degree. I'm almost to the point where I'll gain more material from those wolves than gophers per hour, but it took an enormous amount of skinning work to get there. I have to do similar to get up to the big wolves.

Fire trolls and moose elk in the ravenswood (combined with ravenswood wolves) also have some good potential, but you need enormous skill to try it. Even though I got faster on the trolls, the skinning time still hurts my numbers too much to go there often. And I never did get faster on the huge moose elks.

There not being enough wolves in ravenswood hurts you somewhat, much like the lack of badgers in Stirling Heart. But it's easier to overcome with skinning skill than the lack of badgers is.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback (SPOILERS)

Post by Shadowbane »

I actually don't make a lot of money at trogs at all, since I'm a solo hunter and have limited carry space. The weapons they carry weigh 6 pounds, 12 pounds, or more, and that adds up fast. I would probably do better elsewhere, especially coupled with the amount of time I spend managing health, and especially when there are other hunters there.

Like vampires and statues, trogs have a spawning pattern that is based off player movement. That means when people repeatedly pass through a room someone else is fighting in, they can spawn one or more additional mobs. Given how the area is set up, though, you'd think that'd be a once or twice accidental thing.

I find damage to be comparable between trogs and vampires, though I take less at trogs because I can actually defend against something for a change. It'd be nicer if the weapons weighed less so more could be carried, or if they were worth more at the pawn.

I stand by my statement of harder animals being a good thing. Characters in general have had an easy ride so far.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback (SPOILERS)

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Shadowbane wrote:I actually don't make a lot of money at trogs at all, since I'm a solo hunter and have limited carry space. The weapons they carry weigh 6 pounds, 12 pounds, or more, and that adds up fast. I would probably do better elsewhere, especially coupled with the amount of time I spend managing health, and especially when there are other hunters there.
Yes, the weapons add up fast. I think it's a nice touch and something I wish the other MOBs had, such as the statues. They also sell for a pretty nice amount, though one might want to calculate the overall efficiency of leaving poles and spears behind in favour of gems, coats or other one pound items which sell for more but don't drop as frequently. As it is, it isn't too difficult to walk back to sell and then run back. I think a person would still make more than they would at other hunting grounds. For weight issues, there is always the option to deposit gear beforehand to gain extra capacity. The bank system is unfortunate in this regard, but can be eased by those with houses.
Shadowbane wrote:Like vampires and statues, trogs have a spawning pattern that is based off player movement. That means when people repeatedly pass through a room someone else is fighting in, they can spawn one or more additional mobs. Given how the area is set up, though, you'd think that'd be a once or twice accidental thing.
Statues aren't set up like either of those, actually, because a person can see where the spawns have the chance of happening due to the physical item in the room (which can also make looking at a statue for its health a little tricky for those who don't have it on a prompt, but is a really cool idea that I'm happy is in the game). The area is actually one of the more linear in the game, actually, and is hard to avoid people. It's not that much bigger than statues. However, I don't think we want to talk about repeatedly passing through a room.
Shadowbane wrote:I find damage to be comparable between trogs and vampires, though I take less at trogs because I can actually defend against something for a change. It'd be nicer if the weapons weighed less so more could be carried, or if they were worth more at the pawn.
I just now looked through my log of today and I was only hit at my highest for 18 and only four times I believe in forty minutes. A few 17s thrown in there. I have been hit by lesser vampires for more, and of course by masters and greaters as well. When one considers the payout from doubloons alone, then adds in the payout of the drops, being hit less and being able to hit them more frequently than vampires (unless the area has changed), then I think how the area is set in terms of difficulty versus reward is in question and might need to be reviewed.
Shadowbane wrote:I stand by my statement of harder animals being a good thing. Characters in general have had an easy ride so far.
That's an interesting take considering your previous stances.
Blink wrote:I think the difference in trogs and vamps is due to how strong priests are on undead. It's astounding how fast we kill them with priests, especially when we have two. I saw a massive increase in group hutning profits after the changes, and that was even with turning being tweaked down., since I hunt with priests often.
I've no doubt the vampire payout is increased by a pretty significant margin, which is perfectly fine since there's so few places that are undead and priests can thrive in that role. I question the raise in damage when all other classes have to wait for the combat overhaul (simply for balance purposes), but that's another topic entirely and it isn't really too big of a concern (except when Bocon tries to create his own pandemic in games). But in this case I'm talking about a hunting experience without a priest, and the drop in difficulty versus reward increase isn't balance, I don't think. Being hit less also decreases repair costs which boosts increase in profit.

I still maintain that warthogs, fun as they are just from the sheer hilarity of it (for me personally), are likely too armoured for the payout. I think the heavy increase in damage is appropriate, they hit a little harder than timberwolves that I can see and that makes sense - tusks hurt, a lot. If the key is to get higher level players out of lower level areas for more difficult mobs to engage, then it has to be considered the efficiency. The options are to decrease the payouts of lower areas, increase the payout of newly introduced and more difficult areas, or keep everything the same and deal with the fact that many players will probably end up going back to those areas which they can gather more resources per hour without affecting their payout. It's just a matter of finding the right balance. I like the area, I like the MOBS, and I'd like to think at least the majority of people don't mind difficulty. It's about finding the right amount of difficulty, though.

Blink's player - have you noticed your decrease in skinning times come with levels or weight of creatures? Or both? You said you haven't become faster with the moose elk, and that's interesting to me and I'm wondering if it's because of their weight. For example, I cannot pummel moose elk because they weigh too much so I never bothered with them whilst in Ravenswood.

It'd be nice if the peacocks dropped meat, too (unless I overlooked it), as an additional review. Either that or we should all set aside a day to spam Visyn's screen with feather gifts as payback for the arrow pull out event.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback (SPOILERS)

Post by Blink »

Blink's player - have you noticed your decrease in skinning times come with levels or weight of creatures? Or both? You said you haven't become faster with the moose elk, and that's interesting to me and I'm wondering if it's because of their weight. For example, I cannot pummel moose elk because they weigh too much so I never bothered with them whilst in Ravenswood.
Both. Weight definitely matters. And when you gain certain levels, you seem to get faster. It's rare and I've only done it once so far. And it didn't apply across the board either. small things like gophers didn't change at all. I couldn't tell if ravenswood wolves did. Moose elk certainly did not. The first ones I noticed that were faster were tapir and trolls. It was fairly obvious beause there was now less messages while skinning. I believe timber wolves got faster too, but I can't fully tell since I didn't hunt them before I got that level. So, it appears the first time you get faster on things that are around a few hundred pounds, don't know how high that goes. Just that it didn't hit elk moose, which are huge, like over 1,000 pounds.

Before when skinning a troll, I'd get get the usual skinning start message, a midway message, an almost finished message, then finally done. After I'd get the start message, an almost finished message, and it'd complete right after.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback (SPOILERS)

Post by Shadowbane »

The tower is pretty much broken up into three areas; the north hold, the south hold, and the corridor section between the two (not counting the hall above that leads to bats and the roof). One could say the north and south holds are one area, thanks to that nifty little passage they have, though avoiding the passage is a lot like avoiding a door (as in it can be done). So it's actually not hard to avoid other people if hunting parties are mutually mindful of each other.

The reason I compare the spawn pattern to statues is because more movement means more spawning. Yes, the statues spawn from actual room items (there are one or two super sneaky ones in there though) but the statues also move around the area once animated. The longer you're there, the more active they are, and the more challenging it is to appropriately leveled characters. The challenge increases with another party there, because movement makes them spawn faster than if you just stand there and wait. Eventually, a group will congregate in a different room and that is when another party passing through multiple times will raise the risk levels of the ones already there.

In regards to damage, I don't have a mage or priest follow me around and provide constant defense or stamina with a spell. On average, I take similar amounts of damage between trogs and vampires in a given amount of time under similar circumstances. I'm ahead with trogs because my defenses allow me to hunt there with an appropriate amount of challenge, even with having to make a run to sell in less than 45 minutes. My experiences are clearly not anyone else's, because my class is very different from the others. If I wanted a warrior's experience, I would have made another gargoyle or gone with a vukasin or gavial and played a warrior again.

As for my stance, it obviously wasn't completely understood and it needs to be explained more clearly. I have always been in favor of challenging areas, but there is a difference between being challenged and being restricted. 'Characters in general' applies to those who have the means to hunt in areas others can't (and that's actually most classes). They've had hunting options where others didn't because of restrictions. Eventually, those others severely out leveled the only places they could hunt and also had it easy. I want challenges, but I don't want to be excluded from a hunting area because of my mechanics, which is what we dealt with for a while. So my opinion is the same. I'm glad for the tougher areas not just for parry-only users but for those with shield and consistent damage. If you want something easy and lucrative, stick with what works. Not everyone finds it rewarding to just succeed in managing themselves in tougher areas . Some just want the money, and that is perfectly fine. But let's face it, people are usually either quick to bore with no challenge or they get conditioned to something easy and balk when they encounter something hard (note that hard is different from 'not supposed to work'). I'm glad we're closer to an even blend that accommodates everyone a bit easier.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback (SPOILERS)

Post by Blink »

I have always been in favor of challenging areas, but there is a difference between being challenged and being restricted
I'm more lamenting the fact that the ivory I've been looking forward to is here, but I can't realistically hunt it at this time, at least solo. It would be fun to me is all, and that is why we're here. And I enjoy a challenge, as do most players. Hitting something with lightning bolts over 60 times may be fun at first, but eventually you will want a profit, if you are spending as much time in game as the more active players, which includes both of us. You wouldn't be bidding so much at peddles if you didn't care about profits at all, as it takes much time and dedication to build up a large fortune. Quite simply, if you hunted warthogs full time, you'd be poorer than someone hunting even something simple like statues. And that would be the case even if ivory prices went up as, as they are going to.

And I am restricted, although you may have little sympathy for mages. My choices are to hunt warthogs as is, and take a huge loss in earning, reroll as a large race warrior class, or not hunt ivory. I'm not willing to reroll right now or take a huge earning loss. So I can't hunt ivory and will go back to bone. There is no race combination of mage that will do anything but minor wounds to warthogs, no matter how high level. I enjoy this "challenge" about as much as you enjoy the "challenge" of melee weapon damage being so variable.

I did hunt warthogs successfully in a group the other day, with two mages and a large warrior. So perhaps they are meant to be a group creature. If this is the case I hope someday there is a realistic way solo to get ivory, as my hunting partners are not available all the times of day I may be playing and hunting. I think what is more likely is that this area was implemented with the long game in mind and after the damage changes mages will be able to hunt warthogs reasonably well, especially skilled ones like myself. I can be patient and wait to hunt ivory, but I wanted to give feedback to the Creators to let them know how they best keep me interested and playing the game more.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback (SPOILERS)

Post by Shadowbane »

I imagine ivory will be worth hunting sometime between the craft fix and combat fix. You'd think it would sell better, so it may actually be worth something sooner than the combat update. I get wanting to stay interested in a game, but you're right. I don't have a lot of sympathy for most other classes. I've trudged through a game I don't find fun as much as I should because of the very small number of players I actually have fun with, and because I keep getting promises of "soon" for my class. I've sucked it up and worked through incomplete skills and mechanics, mostly solo, for something that isn't even guaranteed. I like that they're putting out new stuff at the higher end of the skill spectrum, because we shouldn't be rolling over everything in the game like it didn't even phase us. Despite the adjustments needed, I feel it's been a good addition.

I don't think higher end materials should be easy to get solo, personally, and I think ivory should fall into that category. They're high end for a reason. The second they're easy to get (and flood the market) is the second they lose value. To be worth more than bone, it should require a group, or careful tactics and a ridiculous amount of potions. I think you'll be up to the challenge once the necessary updates are in.
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
Post Reply