Blink wrote:Since you aren't accusing the marshals of treason, I have to assume they acting in a lawful manner.
What?! Theft is misconduct, but theft is not treason. Sleeping on the job is misconduct, but sleeping on the job is not treason. Murder is misconduct, but murder is not treason. There are many, many acts of misconduct that do not constitute treason.
Blink wrote:Call it throwing a tantrum, crying, complaining, whining, or just being tedious and repetitive, you are just repeating the same arguments over and over.
It's not going to get you anywhere.
The arguments are valid; because they have traction. If they didn't, you could safely ignore them an go about your business. But you CAN'T ignore them. You can't answer them sufficiently to undermine their traction, and you can't ignore them. So you are stuck with
ad hominem attacks. But please! Go ahead an ignore my arguments, responses, and my letters to the editor. See how that goes for a while.
It has been my experience that I can gauge the effectiveness of arguments against an injustice by measuring how much the perpetrators of-- and apologists for-- an injustice publicly announce how ineffective they are. If they are ineffective Blink-- if they are mere tantrums, crying, complaining, whining, tedious and repetitive-- wouldn't that be self-evident? Wouldn't it be unnecessary for you to point that out?
Blink wrote:And one who cries racism every post has little room to call ad hominem.
You don't seem to understand what
ad hominem means, Blink. An
ad hominem attack is when you contend someone's arguments should be ignored because of some personal attribute on their part; one that has nothing to do with the argument being debated. But that's not what I'm doing. If we were arguing whether a piece of cloth is red or green, and I said "if you think it is green your are an idiot" that would be an
ad hominem attack. But if I argued you were colorblind, and showed you another two slightly different shades of red and green and couldn't distinguish them, that would NOT be an
ad hominem attack.
I am describing behavior (lynching a random goblin in Three Bridges because a goblin in Pearl has committed a crime and couldn't be caught by the marshals) and claiming that is racism. It is the very definition of racism. The murdering of someone for no other reason than their race IS RACISM. That's not an ad hominem attack, Blink. And to have knowledge of such an attack, and refuse to try to stop it, or stop it happening again, to find every excuse imaginable to claim it isn't misconduct; that is racism too. Conclave has the power to condemn racism and it dithers and complains about bells instead. I find that despicable.
But thank you Blink, thanks for giving me yet another opportunity to make a clear, concise statement as to why Conclave is a despicable body.