Announcement from the Lord Marshal

A short winding path, shaped by leaning stacks of paper, leads to the scribe's desk. On the desk lays piles of vellum and other sheets for writing upon. A sign rests on the desk indicating the prices for service and writing supplies.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Announcement from the Lord Marshal

Post by Blink »

You just did make an assumption about it. You DO understand that when you ASSUME, you are making an ASSUMPTION, right?

I'm not twisting your words, Blink. Why should I, when you are doing such a good job of it yourself?
I made an assumption that the villagers of Three Bridges are not citizens of Pearl. I made no assumptions about where the King's rule and will reaches. You are the only person who is conflating two very separate things. These are your beliefs only.

Yes, you are repeatedly and purposely twisting my words. It's the only simple tactic you seem to know and you use it extensively. You are in essence throwing repeat temper tantrums in public, over and over.

No one believes you that the marshals committed treason. Shouting it more or louder will not change anyone's mind.

Blink Thunderbird Walkabout
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: Announcement from the Lord Marshal

Post by ditchhook »

Kaiya wrote:... not one single person will want to listen to anything you say, regardless of how valid, because of your actions and words in this situation.
Oh? And yet you hang on-- and feel compelled to respond-- to almost every single word I post here.

And I understand why. Fear. I say the King is Just. You say He can murder who he wants when he wants-- as can his servants-- because he is The King-- and you are not only say he can, you are saying he DOES. You are saying-- in effect-- that he is a DESPOT.

And because he is a DESPOT, Conclave has no obligation to report misconduct to him. But The King Himself ordered Conclave to do so! If He believes misconduct can happen, and orders Conclave to report it, how can you argue "The Knight Marshals also do not have to explain their reasons"?

Your arguments are undermined by the King's own commands.

One is compelled to choose sides. One either believes the King is just, and the lynchings and cagings in Three Rivers are misconduct, or one believes the King to be a DESPOT, and thus the lynchings and cagings are business-as-usual; not misconduct; and of less importance than the volume of the bells in the clock tower.

I have made my choice, and I stick by it. I proudly proclaim it, and I will continue to do so. Again and again. The King is Just. Lynching is injustice.

There is no justification-- no Justice-- to hang someone without trial, without explaining why before the act is done, and then-- months later-- grasping for some excuse to justify it. Justice does not hang first, and come up with a reason weeks or months later. Justice obscured is Justice denied. The very appearance of injustice IS injustice, because Justice is conducted in the open. It deliberates before punishment, not after. Our King understands that. A despot would not. Our King is not a despot. Stop trying to make him out as one. The only way your arguments make any sense is if we begin with the assumption that our King is a Despot. I refuse to make such an assumption.

He WILL learn the truth of this matter, despite the foot-dragging and disobedience of Conclave, and woe to them when He does.

The great danger of an open rebellion in Three Bridges: the subsequent loss of trade not only with the Island's second largest city, but of trade routes through it to Ravenswood, to Rum Village, and to Outlast; all will eventually demand His attention despite Conclave's disobedience. They've only briefly delayed the inevitable, and by doing so risk bringing the King's justice down upon them.
Bihi
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: Announcement from the Lord Marshal

Post by ditchhook »

Blink wrote:
I made an assumption that the villagers of Three Bridges are not citizens of Pearl. I made no assumptions about where the King's rule and will reaches. You are the only person who is conflating two very separate things. These are your beliefs only.
Here's what you wrote to the Voice: "As a bare minimum, to vote to bring this matter to the attention of King Sauntere, I'd need to know for certain if these Goblins are Pearl citizens, who are the people we work for. From what I can gather, they are not and that area is not in Pearl's sphere of influence."

The King did NOT charge Conclave to report misconduct to him only if it concerned his subjects in Pearl. And even if you were to adopt that argument, misconduct in Three Bridges DOES potentially effect the subjects in Pearl, because the potential disruption of trade between Pearl and all the trade routes that go through Three Bridges. I'm conflating two things, indeed. But they are not "very separate things" Injustice in Three Bridges is still misconduct, and misconduct that can and probably will effect Pearl significantly.
Blink wrote:Yes, you are repeatedly and purposely twisting my words. It's the only simple tactic you seem to know and you use it extensively. You are in essence throwing repeat temper tantrums in public, over and over.
I have found that the ad hominem attack to be the last rhetorical refuge of the scoundrel. Can't you do better?
Blink wrote: No one believes you that the marshals committed treason. Shouting it more or louder will not change anyone's mind.
Not Treason, but gross misconduct. And YOU believe that, Blink. Or at least you strongly suspected it, as well as the rest of Conclave. If you didn't, you would have passed on the report of potential misconduct to the King as a routine matter, while trying to shift the responsibility for the report to the King onto me, and thus covered your collected bureaucratic asses. That was the sound political move. Obey the Kings order as a matter of course, and make sure your own hands are clean of it. (If you thought the King already was aware and approved of it, why not cover your asses and report it?) But you all looked for any excuse NOT to obey the King's order. Why? Maybe because you all reveled in your racism, and so decided to try and cover for the Marshals. Now, when the economic repercussions of a broad discontent become evident in the ATC ledgers, I suspect you will pay the price for letting your racism displace your political acumen.

Now, you damned yourself either way: If the King is Just, as I contend, he would have thanked you for bringing the misconduct to his attention, and will damn you for not doing so. If the King is as despot, as some others might contend, Conclave has set itself up to be the perfect scapegoat. He can blame it for the disruptions of trade. Refusing to report the potential misconduct was-- politically-- so profoundly stupid that only someone blinded by prejudice could have thought it a good idea.
Bihi
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Announcement from the Lord Marshal

Post by Blink »

Not Treason, but gross misconduct
If you aren't accusing them of treason, then we have even less basis to bother the King with this, which I scarcely thought possible. Your argument is that you can run the Knight Marshal's office better than the Lord Marshal. You've given no evidence of anything, just your opinions basically saying that his policies are going to lead us to ruin.

Your opinion is noted. Since you aren't accusing the marshals of treason, I have to assume they acting in a lawful manner under the authority extended to them by the Crown. It is not my place to advise the Knight Marshal's office on tactics, nor is it yours.

Call it throwing a tantrum, crying, complaining, whining, or just being tedious and repetitive, you are just repeating the same arguments over and over. It's not going to get you anywhere. The Conclave has rejected your petition. Your route forward is to go through the marshals, the same people you are calling incompetent. If this is so vital, I'd ask them for an audience and be more polite.

And one who cries racism every post has little room to call ad hominem.

Blink Thunderbird Walkabout
Last edited by Blink on Fri Aug 21, 2015 5:25 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Announcement from the Lord Marshal

Post by Blink »

The King did NOT charge Conclave to report misconduct to him only if it concerned his subjects in Pearl.
I already responded to this idiocy in previous posts, If you don't remember and are too lazy to go back and look at my reply, too bad. I'm not going keep addressing the same things over and over. This is exactly what I mean by tedious repetition.

Blink Thunderbird Walkabout
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: Announcement from the Lord Marshal

Post by ditchhook »

Blink wrote:Since you aren't accusing the marshals of treason, I have to assume they acting in a lawful manner.
What?! Theft is misconduct, but theft is not treason. Sleeping on the job is misconduct, but sleeping on the job is not treason. Murder is misconduct, but murder is not treason. There are many, many acts of misconduct that do not constitute treason.
Blink wrote:Call it throwing a tantrum, crying, complaining, whining, or just being tedious and repetitive, you are just repeating the same arguments over and over.

It's not going to get you anywhere.
The arguments are valid; because they have traction. If they didn't, you could safely ignore them an go about your business. But you CAN'T ignore them. You can't answer them sufficiently to undermine their traction, and you can't ignore them. So you are stuck with ad hominem attacks. But please! Go ahead an ignore my arguments, responses, and my letters to the editor. See how that goes for a while.

It has been my experience that I can gauge the effectiveness of arguments against an injustice by measuring how much the perpetrators of-- and apologists for-- an injustice publicly announce how ineffective they are. If they are ineffective Blink-- if they are mere tantrums, crying, complaining, whining, tedious and repetitive-- wouldn't that be self-evident? Wouldn't it be unnecessary for you to point that out?
Blink wrote:And one who cries racism every post has little room to call ad hominem.
You don't seem to understand what ad hominem means, Blink. An ad hominem attack is when you contend someone's arguments should be ignored because of some personal attribute on their part; one that has nothing to do with the argument being debated. But that's not what I'm doing. If we were arguing whether a piece of cloth is red or green, and I said "if you think it is green your are an idiot" that would be an ad hominem attack. But if I argued you were colorblind, and showed you another two slightly different shades of red and green and couldn't distinguish them, that would NOT be an ad hominem attack.

I am describing behavior (lynching a random goblin in Three Bridges because a goblin in Pearl has committed a crime and couldn't be caught by the marshals) and claiming that is racism. It is the very definition of racism. The murdering of someone for no other reason than their race IS RACISM. That's not an ad hominem attack, Blink. And to have knowledge of such an attack, and refuse to try to stop it, or stop it happening again, to find every excuse imaginable to claim it isn't misconduct; that is racism too. Conclave has the power to condemn racism and it dithers and complains about bells instead. I find that despicable.

But thank you Blink, thanks for giving me yet another opportunity to make a clear, concise statement as to why Conclave is a despicable body.
Last edited by ditchhook on Fri Aug 21, 2015 12:41 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Bihi
Kaiya
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 66
Joined: Thu May 07, 2015 5:48 pm
Location: Seattle, WA

Re: Announcement from the Lord Marshal

Post by Kaiya »

ditchhook wrote:
Kaiya wrote:... not one single person will want to listen to anything you say, regardless of how valid, because of your actions and words in this situation.
Oh? And yet you hang on-- and feel compelled to respond-- to almost every single word I post here.

And I understand why. Fear. I say the King is Just. You say He can murder who he wants when he wants-- as can his servants-- because he is The King-- and you are not only say he can, you are saying he DOES. You are saying-- in effect-- that he is a DESPOT.

And because he is a DESPOT, Conclave has no obligation to report misconduct to him. But The King Himself ordered Conclave to do so! If He believes misconduct can happen, and orders Conclave to report it, how can you argue "The Knight Marshals also do not have to explain their reasons"?

Your arguments are undermined by the King's own commands.

One is compelled to choose sides. One either believes the King is just, and the lynchings and cagings in Three Rivers are misconduct, or one believes the King to be a DESPOT, and thus the lynchings and cagings are business-as-usual; not misconduct; and of less importance than the volume of the bells in the clock tower.

I have made my choice, and I stick by it. I proudly proclaim it, and I will continue to do so. Again and again. The King is Just. Lynching is injustice.

There is no justification-- no Justice-- to hang someone without trial, without explaining why before the act is done, and then-- months later-- grasping for some excuse to justify it. Justice does not hang first, and come up with a reason weeks or months later. Justice obscured is Justice denied. The very appearance of injustice IS injustice, because Justice is conducted in the open. It deliberates before punishment, not after. Our King understands that. A despot would not. Our King is not a despot. Stop trying to make him out as one. The only way your arguments make any sense is if we begin with the assumption that our King is a Despot. I refuse to make such an assumption.

He WILL learn the truth of this matter, despite the foot-dragging and disobedience of Conclave, and woe to them when He does.

The great danger of an open rebellion in Three Bridges: the subsequent loss of trade not only with the Island's second largest city, but of trade routes through it to Ravenswood, to Rum Village, and to Outlast; all will eventually demand His attention despite Conclave's disobedience. They've only briefly delayed the inevitable, and by doing so risk bringing the King's justice down upon them.
I have absolutely no idea how you can infer all you have in the writings above based on the things I have said. As you have with other people's opinions, you have completely misunderstood and intentionally misstated mine. It just leads me to believe that you are losing rationality by the day. You quite frankly come off as a bit insane. I'm sorry for your deterioration, and I hope you seek help. In the mean time, I will refrain from speaking with you regarding this, or really any, issue in the hopes to not antagonize the mental health issues you are quite clearly suffering from.
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: Announcement from the Lord Marshal

Post by ditchhook »

Kaiya wrote:
I have absolutely no idea how you can infer all you have in the writings above based on the things I have said.
I don't claim to.

I simply use your statements as a starting point, to bring my readers closer to the ideas I wish them to consider. I have learned that racism is so illogical a philosophy-- so riddled with contradictions and falsehoods, so driven by hate and fear-- that it is of little use to engage the racist directly in hopes of changing his or her mind. Instead, I garner selected statements from a racist rant-- the more ridiculous the better-- and use them in hopes of showing the third-party observer how contradictory, how false, how hateful and fearful they are. I don't hope to persuade a racist. I hope to isolate a racist.

Your statements have been especially fruitful in that regard. :: The bottom portion of this post has been torn off.::
Bihi
KM Scribe
Knight Marshal
Posts: 42
Joined: Sun May 04, 2014 7:00 pm

Re: Announcement from the Lord Marshal

Post by KM Scribe »

The knight marshals act with the full authority of King Sauntere, eighth of his name. Continued questioning of his knights will be considered as questioning the King's judgement, which is beyond contestation.

Furthermore, we have perfectly good gallows in Pearl. If a goblin was hanged in Three Bridges by someone else, that's just one less we have to execute.
~ From the office of the Lord Marshal.

In service of King Sauntere, eighth of his name. High Protector of Pearl, Supreme Commander of the Royal Fleet, and Governing Ruler of the Archai Trading Company.
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: Announcement from the Lord Marshal

Post by ditchhook »

KM Scribe wrote:The knight marshals act with the full authority of King Sauntere, eighth of his name. Continued questioning of his knights will be considered as questioning the King's judgement, which is beyond contestation.

Furthermore, we have perfectly good gallows in Pearl. If a goblin was hanged in Three Bridges by someone else, that's just one less we have to execute.
The Knights Marshal DO NOT act with the full authority of the KING. If they did, the KING would have no need to charge Conclave to report their misconduct to him. If the KING recognizes that the Knights Marshal do not always act with the full authority of the King, so do I. I stand with the King.

I, Bihi the Cartographer, continue-- and plan to continue-- questioning the conduct of the Knights Marshal.

I do have on confession to make, however. I wear a disguise. I am not a Bolinau. I am HUMAN. When you find you are unable to catch me, you'll have to start hanging random humans in my stead.

I also wish to explain to this KM scribe that an adjective is still an adjective, even when it comes after a noun. A professional scribe should know better.
Last edited by ditchhook on Fri Aug 21, 2015 2:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Post Reply