After reading the latest "Voice of Pearl" about I have some concerns about how we describe objects in the game. I'm no metallurgist, but I do know that electrum is an ally of gold and silver. Gold and silver are relatively rare, but they are also extremely ductile and malleable (bendable). They are great for making jewelry, but really, really lousy for making edged weapons. Hard, brittle metals-- like steel, or maybe to a lesser extent bronze or iron-- are appropriate for edged weapons.
We are a game conducted in English, so I have to assume-- unless I get some kind of warning that a word used in the game has a different meaning-- that I should rely on standard English definitions as found in dictionaries/Wikipedia/etc.
So my first IC reaction is "what fool would buy an edged weapon made of electrum!?" And my OOC reaction is "should I be assuming electrum has extra-normal/magical qualities?"
I ask staff to either (a) make sure they research words/terms they are not absolutely sure of, and try to support a "common sense" understanding of words whenever possible, then use made up/fictional words when they want to give something an air of mystery or supernatural attribute, or (b) give us all a list of what "any resident of Achari should know" where staff redefines words like "electrum" to mean something that would not be normally expected.
I have the same issue with bows. You can understand how good a wood is for bow-making by using these two sites:
http://www.wood-database.com/wood-articles/bow-woods/
http://www.csudh.edu/oliver/chemdata/woods.htm
Consulting them would show that ebony is a VERY bad wood for making a bow. But in the game we can use the compare command to see which bow is codedly better, and I find that an ebony bow is codedly better than Bihi's yew bow.
When attributes like these don't follow 'common sense' the problem arises where this kind of knowledge becomes a precious commodity that staff can easily and even inadvertently end up distributing to players in ways that could be perceived as favoritism.
Accurate Descriptions
Re: Accurate Descriptions
This is a made up world with made up things in it. To assume that everything IC is as it is OOC is just silly. To have your -character- assume something IC because of your OOC knowledge is wrong, especially when that thing you're assuming can be tested and you've just never done it. That is not staff's fault, that is the player's for not playing their character correctly. If your character has never used an ebony bow IC, nor ever heard anyone IC say that ebony is a bad wood for a bow, there really is no reason for them to believe IC that ebony is bad wood for a bow, just because you know so OOCly.
I do agree that there should be a list about things that are supposed to be common knowledge, because many of us new players know next to nothing about what types of materials are better than others. I realize Snaek posted a link to a list, but also stated it was outdated. So I'm still pretty much in the dark.
I also had no idea there was even a compare command until this post! So that common knowledge list would really be helpful.
I do agree that there should be a list about things that are supposed to be common knowledge, because many of us new players know next to nothing about what types of materials are better than others. I realize Snaek posted a link to a list, but also stated it was outdated. So I'm still pretty much in the dark.
I also had no idea there was even a compare command until this post! So that common knowledge list would really be helpful.
Re: Accurate Descriptions
Which word? Ebony, or Electrum? Either are available at dictionary.com.Kaiya wrote:This is a made up world with made up things in it.
Bihi
Re: Accurate Descriptions
I was not referencing either. But my point remains. This is not a real world. It is fantasy. So expecting things in it to relate exactly to their real world definitions is your issue, not staff's.
Re: Accurate Descriptions
There's a balance to be struck between being stuck in real-life verisimilitude and becoming the fantasy equivalent of a e.e. cummings poem. The concern should not be dismissed out of hand.
If "electrum" means something other than "electrum" it should be explained, nothing more or less. Just the same as if air was suddenly a solid, we'd expect some sort of distinction vis a vis reality to be made.
If "electrum" means something other than "electrum" it should be explained, nothing more or less. Just the same as if air was suddenly a solid, we'd expect some sort of distinction vis a vis reality to be made.
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Accurate Descriptions
Maybe SI's rules of reality are very different, and electrum has crazy magic properties that make it ridiculously overpowered.
Maybe staff just wanted something fancier than steel, and electrum sounds cooler. I think it does.
I didn't play a fantasy game expecting people to follow basic reality laws. I expect to see people flying around without wings and golden weapons to be on a silly level of strong. I can't expect people to follow the norms of what's realistic in terms of materials or physics when they can't even stick to what would be considered social norms of a similar time period, or to refuse to consider people specialized in killing other people to be nonthreatening simply because the game mechanics are broke. It is what it is.
While it's a poor excuse, if you accept it, it's less stressful. If you keep fighting what others have established as 'okay' in this game, it'll quickly get old and tiring and not fun.
Maybe staff just wanted something fancier than steel, and electrum sounds cooler. I think it does.
I didn't play a fantasy game expecting people to follow basic reality laws. I expect to see people flying around without wings and golden weapons to be on a silly level of strong. I can't expect people to follow the norms of what's realistic in terms of materials or physics when they can't even stick to what would be considered social norms of a similar time period, or to refuse to consider people specialized in killing other people to be nonthreatening simply because the game mechanics are broke. It is what it is.
While it's a poor excuse, if you accept it, it's less stressful. If you keep fighting what others have established as 'okay' in this game, it'll quickly get old and tiring and not fun.
Re: Accurate Descriptions
I completely agree that things should be explained, thus my agreement of a list of 'common knowledge' items, commands, etc. My post mainly focused on the fact that the OP was expecting things to be exactly as they are OOC IC. He even gave the example of his character assuming something based on his OOC knowledge. This is what I have a problem with, and I consider it terrible roleplaying. Most answers to our questions can be discovered IC. I had no idea what type of bow was up for auction, even though I knew about type of wood it was made from. So I asked questions IC. Is this wood good? Is that a good bow? Etc. I didn't just assume it was good/bad because in the real world it would have been a good/bad bow wood.Conskill wrote:There's a balance to be struck between being stuck in real-life verisimilitude and becoming the fantasy equivalent of a e.e. cummings poem. The concern should not be dismissed out of hand.
If "electrum" means something other than "electrum" it should be explained, nothing more or less. Just the same as if air was suddenly a solid, we'd expect some sort of distinction vis a vis reality to be made.
Re: Accurate Descriptions **SPOILERS**
The game is still in alpha/beta so I'm sure things will get sorted out eventually, it's up to players to
give feedback to staff about things they notice to help make the game world better all the time
in RL Electrum and Orichalcum can be mined, but in our world, they are made by smelting, perhaps the smelting
process can be said to make them 'stronger' ?
Anyhoo, i've noticed some things i found strange with metals and their AR boost, im not sure if they will change
in the future, but here is what i have found by comparing my stats with different metal weapons equipped .
right now a dagger and a 2 hander have the same AR i think? ... daggers use less ftg tho.
( i'd Really like staff to post a ranked list of metals and woods, they can make the items, and they must have the numbers?)
Spoiler Below?
weapons: AR boost
iron & nickle +24 ( weaker than ... bone?)
bone +43
tin +45
copper +56
bronze +57
steel +63
orichalcum
blacksteel
arcsilver
electrum
niello
Bows -
wooden + 15
balsa
pine
birch +18
oak
osage +30
yew
ebony
give feedback to staff about things they notice to help make the game world better all the time
in RL Electrum and Orichalcum can be mined, but in our world, they are made by smelting, perhaps the smelting
process can be said to make them 'stronger' ?
Anyhoo, i've noticed some things i found strange with metals and their AR boost, im not sure if they will change
in the future, but here is what i have found by comparing my stats with different metal weapons equipped .
right now a dagger and a 2 hander have the same AR i think? ... daggers use less ftg tho.
( i'd Really like staff to post a ranked list of metals and woods, they can make the items, and they must have the numbers?)
Spoiler Below?
weapons: AR boost
iron & nickle +24 ( weaker than ... bone?)
bone +43
tin +45
copper +56
bronze +57
steel +63
orichalcum
blacksteel
arcsilver
electrum
niello
Bows -
wooden + 15
balsa
pine
birch +18
oak
osage +30
yew
ebony

Re: Accurate Descriptions
I'm thinking the AR boost must differ for each race, as my steel kris boosts my AR 91, not 63.
Go ahead and add redwood to the bow for +174 (at least for me!)
Go ahead and add redwood to the bow for +174 (at least for me!)
Re: Accurate Descriptions
The ebony bow referred to above is described in game as an ebony flatbow. I agree that ebony is an odd material to use for a bow. My IC assumption is that the bow is really made of some other material, with ebony used for decorative purposes. Some research reveals that the flatbow design is superior to the longbow design, which accounts for its superior performance in game.
There are a lot of oddities in any fantasy world. My suggestion when one encounters an oddity is to come up with some fun or interesting explanation for it that doesn't break with the overall fantasy world. For instance, the ogres near the mines will jump out of shadows at you, but then don't attack. Why don't they follow up on their ambush with an attack? Out of character, I'm guessing this is some sort of failure by whoever coded ogre behavior. IC, my explanation is that these are very young and so very stupid ogres, and they haven't yet learned how to carry out an ambush attack. From there, I've gone on to suppose that the ogres we encounter are the ogre equivalent of Academy students, and we adventurers are the equivalent of, say, fire trolls. Eventually, the successful ogres will graduate from their academy to join the ogre shaman and her group of experienced and semi-intelligent ogres. It's a fanciful explanation, but I find it entertaining, and it keeps me engaged in the fantasy world.
--Aruskin
There are a lot of oddities in any fantasy world. My suggestion when one encounters an oddity is to come up with some fun or interesting explanation for it that doesn't break with the overall fantasy world. For instance, the ogres near the mines will jump out of shadows at you, but then don't attack. Why don't they follow up on their ambush with an attack? Out of character, I'm guessing this is some sort of failure by whoever coded ogre behavior. IC, my explanation is that these are very young and so very stupid ogres, and they haven't yet learned how to carry out an ambush attack. From there, I've gone on to suppose that the ogres we encounter are the ogre equivalent of Academy students, and we adventurers are the equivalent of, say, fire trolls. Eventually, the successful ogres will graduate from their academy to join the ogre shaman and her group of experienced and semi-intelligent ogres. It's a fanciful explanation, but I find it entertaining, and it keeps me engaged in the fantasy world.
--Aruskin