Revamp Speculate

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
User avatar
Xiija
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2014 6:55 pm
Contact:

Revamp Speculate

Post by Xiija »

The speculate skill seems useless as it is, as most people would have a higher gathering skill and just
dig, forage etc to see what is in a room. It's annoying to speculate and mebbe have it not proc, and
have to do it again, and the delay is ridiculous.

Would it be possible to have the speculate skill be like swimming and bundling, set at lvl 1 and not able to advance,
and change the delay to 5 seconds, and have it proc 100% of the time? This would allow people to move room to room
actually USING the skill, and when they find what they seek, they can forage,mine,dig etc ?

I don't see this as affecting crafting/gathering in any way that would hurt the game?

Can anyone share their thoughts on this idea please?
Thanx,
Image
Bocon L
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat May 31, 2014 5:04 pm

Re: Revamp Speculate

Post by Bocon L »

Maybe this will get a revamp with crafting skills? I dunno. The last time this was brought up, they said it wasn't going to change. There were a lot of different ideas on how to make the skill worth using and leveling, back in that thread too, but I just can't seem to find it. I always thought that using it successfully should put a buff on you while you're in that room, so you can gather more resources than normal from it, or it should lessen your gathering failure chance while you're in the room. At least this way, it would be worth using and leveling slowly still gives you a slim chance at a stat raise still.
CoralScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 122
Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm

Re: Revamp Speculate

Post by CoralScribe »

I'm relatively sure that the delay on speculate has actually been reduced before; you can go back and see my rant about how useless speculate is, and how its placement actively encourages cheating both intentional and unintentional. To be honest, speculate does have some use. Now that it is actually just as fast as gathering, there's not a lot of reason to not use it if you're looking for pretty much anything specific, even if 'specific' is a particular type of resource.

The purpose of speculate and its usefulness varies depending on what your plans are when gathering. If you're a stone carver, you use speculate to differentiate the stone from the other resources present - the same for most any of the mining skills. For the digging skills, you use it to figure out where the heck you can find sand, because sheesh, there are a lot of fish in my sand. And speculate's utterly invaluable for cooking, especially at lower levels, since cooking is recipe based. If you're just mining up everything, though, there's not much reason to use speculate, since you can, potentially, use all the resources you find (mining unlocking all of the ways of using whatever resource mining can find). It is annoying when speculate fails, but I don't see it as a major issue - even if you were gathering, you can still fail to find something, and if a different resource is in the area, you're going to continually fail anyway; speculate, at least, can succeed regardless of resource. I believe there's a post around here recently that says increases in gathering skill do increase chance of success... have to assume that would include speculate. So at least you can get better at it over time. Like all gathering skills, though, not really worth it to power train. It'll level if you use it, and you probably will.

The only things that actually need to be changed about speculate, in my opinion, is that players should start with or immediately unlock speculate so they get in the habit of using it early to lessen intentional or otherwise breeches of the CoC, and that it should be usable in combat - though the latter isn't as important any more due to most resource areas being safe from predation. The first is far more important given cooking's recipe-based system - I'd hate to try to forage for salt in a cave without it. Probably why my cooking's level 3.
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....

**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
User avatar
Illegal Activity
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 87
Joined: Wed Dec 11, 2013 11:17 pm

Re: Revamp Speculate

Post by Illegal Activity »

What if it could be used as a type of trade skill "tracking" ability? Speculate ebony would lead you to the room that held this type of wood. I realize this is a powerful suggestion and would allow people to "cherry pick" materials. It shouldn't be that big of a deal because quality is only for flavor and doesn't do anything mechanically. Personally I would rather go farm up the low end/common materials and use them to level crafting skills but what is good for the goose isn't always good for the gander. As it is now I don't bother with speculate because you can level your gathering skills faster when you don't find anything in the room. While I'm barely starting to dabble in tradeskills this opinion might change later when I'm more focused on the crafting part of tradeskills but until then I gotta level the gathering part to unlock the crafting parts!



Another opportunity to have a use for speculate would be to allow it to give more information. Right now it just gives you a chance to see what is spawned in the room. What if it had a chance to tell you all possible spawned materials as well as the one currently spawned? Most hardcore gatherers will already know this information for existing areas though so you could take it a step further and give high level speculate the ability to see what current material is spawned in the room by just typing "look".


If it were up to me I'd go with the idea Xiija had and make it a non leveling 5 second ability that tells you what is currently spawned in the room. The room spawn changes too often for the current setup of speculate to be of any use other than just another skill you can level for a chance at a stat raise.
CoralScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 122
Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm

Re: Revamp Speculate

Post by CoralScribe »

While I'd love for speculate to work more like tracking so that I can find the beautiful moonstone and what not, it may be a bit unbalancing. As it stands, type of material seems to have the biggest effect on end price, so I think Snaek's worries about it being used to constantly find the best stuff are at least somewhat justified.

Unlocking the crafting skills is itself a problem in some ways, because it does encourage people to not use speculate or even care about the resources they're digging up, especially since they can't even be sold to vendors now. Unfortunately, the only way I could think of solving that problem would be 'starter' crafts - that is, crafts that had a lower level limit (10? 25?) that unlock quickly so that you have a reason to use those skills. Those starter crafts would then go on to unlock the real skills (eg. stone carving > sculpting, metal working > blacksmithy/smelting/etc). Might be too much work for a problem they might not even care about anymore - I know I had devs descend from the heavens when I was training my gathering skills hard ;p After you unlock, though, resources are always far more important, so it's a non-issue.

That said, some of these ideas for improving speculate do sound pretty cool. I'd love to be able to just look and see what resources are there, or get some sort of a buff for using it (gathering speed? yesplz). Another option would be to give the room a chance to reroll - change the resource to get something maybe better, maybe worse. Might lead to gatherer obesity over time though. Lazy gatherers sitting in one room all day ;p
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....

**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
Bocon L
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat May 31, 2014 5:04 pm

Re: Revamp Speculate

Post by Bocon L »

I know you've been gone a long time, so let me fill you in on the fact that it's okay to dig or mine, see what resource is there, then move on if you don't like it. This is because it's really, really OOC for someone's character to be forced to gather something they would never want IC. Now, speculate IS fairly decent for rooms that have multiple different gathering resources in it. But that's it. There's no reason to use it in say, the Silverford mines, where only 1 gathering skill is used. Speculate is useful in very rare situations and could be changed a bit to make it useful, without having to mechanically change the entire resource system.
User avatar
Kody_Oakborne
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 209
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2014 1:35 am

Re: Revamp Speculate

Post by Kody_Oakborne »

From my experience, there are loot tables for each room, yet only one gathering "loot" can be active at a time. So for the most part, even using speculate as a "tracking-like" ability would only find the item when it's the active loot in the room. Sometimes you want to gather stone without gathering 500 pounds of garnet, obsidian, salt, etc. I grab them all because if I don't it's going to take me forever to find more stone, when I can just mine through the loot table until I hit stone again, and leaving hundreds of pounds of valuable materials on the floor is not to be expected of anyone. It would probably take a coding change to make it happen, but ultimately I feel like a huge boon to the gathering skills would be for their to be multiple materials available at one time, and then you can speculate, see what all is available, and mine or forage more specifically.
May the trees guard you, and house you, and guide you.
Kody
User avatar
Xiija
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2014 6:55 pm
Contact:

Re: Revamp Speculate

Post by Xiija »

Snaek says, "Each room can only spawn one type of resource at a time, including nothing. A forest room may be ready for foraging, digging, or chopping."

My idea was based on ease of coding for the staff.
1. There are already skills set to lvl 1 and non advance-able.
2. Delay is just a number, and can easily be changed.
3. Proc % is a number and can easily be changed.

If one is looking for say, wolfsbane, you can look in Ravenswood (26 rooms) or Stirling (15 rooms)
... so using the current speculate skill one would speculate (15 seconds if it fails, 25 seconds if it hits)
for 17 minutes MINIMUM ( no failures) and wolfsbane might still be NOT IN GAME. ( i've done this)

if Speculate was only 5 seconds and 100% proc, one would not need to waste a half hour of RP or PT time
searching for resources not in game and could then cover the same 41 rooms in 4 minutes. If a resource is
found, the normal gathering delay is more than enuff to keep people from any mechanical advantage?

If you are just gathering wood or metals etc, you wouldn't even use speculate, just gather what ever you can find
but typing "chop" in a room 3 times (15 sec each) or speculate 2 times or more just to find that the room has corn and no wood?

It seems the trade update will go in this weekend, it would be nice if enuff people agreed with this idea that staff might
try it out for a few weeks to see how it works?

Anyhoo, they ask us for feedback, this was mine :)
Image
User avatar
Kody_Oakborne
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 209
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2014 1:35 am

Re: Revamp Speculate

Post by Kody_Oakborne »

Xiija wrote:
Snaek says, "Each room can only spawn one type of resource at a time, including nothing. A forest room may be ready for foraging, digging, or chopping."

My idea was based on ease of coding for the staff.
1. There are already skills set to lvl 1 and non advance-able.
2. Delay is just a number, and can easily be changed.
3. Proc % is a number and can easily be changed.

If one is looking for say, wolfsbane, you can look in Ravenswood (26 rooms) or Stirling (15 rooms)
... so using the current speculate skill one would speculate (15 seconds if it fails, 25 seconds if it hits)
for 17 minutes MINIMUM ( no failures) and wolfsbane might still be NOT IN GAME. ( i've done this)

if Speculate was only 5 seconds and 100% proc, one would not need to waste a half hour of RP or PT time
searching for resources not in game and could then cover the same 41 rooms in 4 minutes. If a resource is
found, the normal gathering delay is more than enuff to keep people from any mechanical advantage?

If you are just gathering wood or metals etc, you wouldn't even use speculate, just gather what ever you can find
but typing "chop" in a room 3 times (15 sec each) or speculate 2 times or more just to find that the room has corn and no wood?

It seems the trade update will go in this weekend, it would be nice if enuff people agreed with this idea that staff might
try it out for a few weeks to see how it works?

Anyhoo, they ask us for feedback, this was mine :)
I'll admit I'd use it a lot more if it wasn't prone to failure.
May the trees guard you, and house you, and guide you.
Kody
Bocon L
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat May 31, 2014 5:04 pm

Re: Revamp Speculate

Post by Bocon L »

Yeah, it would be at least a lot more useful if the delay was really low and didn't fail. I'd probably use it every time too if it was like that.
Post Reply