Realistically we don't know how things will balance out later on, and obviously things are subject to change, but Ghrex brings up some good points. For a melee fighter to be combat effective, they need to level close combat, defensive skills (which should level while working CC), and they need to have good gear.
For a mage to be combat effective, they need to level their DD spell (after leveling the first several up and then abandoning them to restart at level 1), their defensive spells, their close combat, defensive skills (similar to the melee fighter they should naturally level while working CC), and any utility spells they need to rely on. As Ghrex said, level 15 ftg spells seem to fail 4 out of every 5 times, and the utility spells are no better. This means that the mage also has to level all combat-related utility spells to a reasonable degree in order for them to not constantly fail on casts. So that's at least 4-5 skills the mage MUST level up (DD spell, shield spell, ftg spell, utility spell (haste/slow?), close combat) compared to the 1 skill a melee must focus on (CC).
I understand this is based on my/our limited knowledge about the game so far, but it does seem like mages are required to be much more diverse than a straight melee fighter. I do understand that there are other abilities a melee must level (rage, etc.), but as far as I know, they don't fail to work the same way low level spells do, so a melee fighter would be much more successful leveling just CC than a mage would be just leveling their DD.
Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Solutions
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
Yes, there is that! I think that might just be more of a consequence of the newness of the game. I think I read elsewhere on the forums plans or ideas for more tactical maneuvering (so us wizards could stand behind the warriors)Ghrex wrote: Never stated I wanted to be a front line fighter. The game is forcing us to be one in it's current state. I want the ability to tactically outwit my opponent, not see who can throw out the most damage the fastest. Because right now, as thing s stand, whoever can take the most damage, while being able to deal the most will always win any PvE or PvP battle. There is nothing more to it. I 100% agree that mages should not stand a chance in a 1 on 1 facetank brawl. But that's the only option I have been given at this time.