So, since digging was removed the skill tree for (new) characters, and it's reasonable to assume that when we go live some skills will get shuffled around or removed entirely, I've been working on foraging instead of digging. Now, it's not high by any stretch of the imagination, but it's over level ten.
I have just spent 15 minutes or more trying and failing to forage for coal in a swamp. You can't mine in a swamp, so I can't fall back on that gathering skill. You would think that, in 15 minutes, I could get at LEAST one piece of coal.
Is there a disconnect somewhere between digging and foraging for items that were previously dug for? Did something get broken when the skills were adjusted? Because I have a hard time believing that in more than ten levels of scrounging, my character can't manage to pull one piece of coal out of the ground. It's difficult enough, given the swamp has aggressive mobs in it that regularly interrupt gatherers. It would be beyond frustrating to know I have wasted over a quarter of an hour trying to gather something with a skill, given the skill I used previously isn't technically supported anymore.
Foraging instead of digging
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Foraging instead of digging
So, an update. About a half hour of foraging attempts non stop, with one interruption due to combat. Zero coal. In fact, the coal cycled out and now I'm easily pulling up clay.
I do think there's something broken when it comes to gathering coal, because in a half hour of steady foraging, I should be able to come up with SOMETHING. If staff intend for it to be just mined, it needs to be removed from the swamp at the academy. If it's intended to also be found in swamps, we need to be able to forage for it. I'm not asking to mine in a swamp, cause it's kinda silly to be swinging a pick around like that in the muck and slime.
I do think there's something broken when it comes to gathering coal, because in a half hour of steady foraging, I should be able to come up with SOMETHING. If staff intend for it to be just mined, it needs to be removed from the swamp at the academy. If it's intended to also be found in swamps, we need to be able to forage for it. I'm not asking to mine in a swamp, cause it's kinda silly to be swinging a pick around like that in the muck and slime.

Hierophant of Itzal
Re: Foraging instead of digging
Maybe let folks forage in the swamp for peat?
Could even just be coal by another name, like some of the types of meat.
P.S. I wish they kept there flavor descriptions when you pull them out of a bundle, or would change the end result when cooking.
Could even just be coal by another name, like some of the types of meat.
P.S. I wish they kept there flavor descriptions when you pull them out of a bundle, or would change the end result when cooking.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Re: Foraging instead of digging
Coal has to be mined. Even when you do mine it, it seems to be harder to get than most everything else for some reason. It's also pretty rare.
Re: Foraging instead of digging
Be sure if you find a resource that you can not forage/mine (after giving it a reasonable chance) to bug report it. The more reports, the more likely it will be noticed. I know staff is working hard and they use those reports to help prioritize (sp?) their tasks.
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Foraging instead of digging
I did send in a bug report. I could previously dig coal up in the swamp, so assumed that foraging should work as well, since it works for sand and clay now.
I had no problem mining it when I found it in places I could actually mine.
I had no problem mining it when I found it in places I could actually mine.

Hierophant of Itzal