Alright, so I just started playing last night, I have maybe a couple of hours in at the Academy and thankfully ran into another newbie who was fun for a time.
I think you have the bones of a good game here, but I feel that the uses thing is going to make it very WoWish. Having to grind through skeletons/orcs/whatever through 1k uses (random number) to get access to other things and to become.. LIVEABLE seems very grindy.
I have the impression that RP is the core point of the game, making this an RPI, so the question then exists as to how one is supposed to advance to spell/skill X through pure roleplay without grinding the huge number of uses?
I personally could simply code a script/trigger to bash through all the skeletons etc to gain level 15 or whatever is recommended to leave the academy, but I honestly don't want to stare at the screen as my guy spams spells, mends wounds and rinses as repeats for four hours, whether I'm typing it or the script is.
So question I guess is this. Is it possible to bypass all the grinding and to roleplay a character without it? If so, how do you go about quantifying rp into "uses" and who does it?
I want to be clear, I'm not asking for an easy button, I just don't wanna claw my eyes out with an icepick from all the grind.
First Impressions Tied with questions.
-
EliteJarod
- Academy Student
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Tue Jun 07, 2016 9:12 pm
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: First Impressions Tied with questions.
I'll be the first to admit that the grind can get old. For those of us that play characters with a combative nature, that grind ends up being pretty necessary in order to back up our words. A person can look pretty silly if they talk a big game and turn out to be a wuss, and our combat system (it's still being worked on) definitely hasn't helped that. Unless, of course, the intent was for the character to be all talk. But few people are ok with getting pushed around, even during RP.
If you are creative enough, you could very well get your character advanced socially on just roleplay, with very minimal skill gain. You could be a storyteller, an aspiring historian, maybe even a con artist if you're slick enough. There is a crafting system in game where you can learn a variety of craft skills, and players can become merchants. If you're a savvy business type, you could even make money trading (though applying to the merchant positions definitely helps that, and that would require some craft skill work).
As intimidating as the grind is, it actually isn't as bad as it is in some other games. Your first ten levels actually fly by pretty quick, and with some creative trigger and timer work (cause I can't write scripts to save my life) you can take some of the sting out of leveling up a skill here and there. Staff are usually fairly lenient when it comes to scripts and triggers. As long as you're paying attention on the occasion someone script checks you, and as long as you don't bumble into other players and negatively affect their play time, they're cool with it. Only thing that's a serious no-no is taking advantage of bugs or incomplete mechanics to get an edge in levels.
I've found the skill grind to be soothing, most days. Since I'm currently unemployed with a kid on the way, and school is on hold till I can return next year, I can set my character to work on one skill or another and then carry the laptop around to keep an eye on it while I do whatever chore needs doing for the day. Works especially well for most crafting skills, because that can get tedious.
If you have a regular RP partner, they could even be a hunting/training buddy and you can RP while you level skills. Group hunts can be fun, and depending on which crowd you get into, even pretty effective in terms of money and skill gain.
TL;DR: While SI does have quite a few skills that can be combat or trade oriented, the real magic is in the roleplay and stories that go on in game. Get out into the world and meet some of the characters, and get to know the ones in your temple especially (you'll often deal with them the most, and the members of each temple ideally act as a sort of support network for their members, both new and old). The grind isn't so bad, especially for those days where you just need a minor distraction while you do school or house work. Build up your character's personality and figure out their history, and maybe you can even hit it big without leveling anything past ten! All it takes is creativity and a little commitment to the character.
If you are creative enough, you could very well get your character advanced socially on just roleplay, with very minimal skill gain. You could be a storyteller, an aspiring historian, maybe even a con artist if you're slick enough. There is a crafting system in game where you can learn a variety of craft skills, and players can become merchants. If you're a savvy business type, you could even make money trading (though applying to the merchant positions definitely helps that, and that would require some craft skill work).
As intimidating as the grind is, it actually isn't as bad as it is in some other games. Your first ten levels actually fly by pretty quick, and with some creative trigger and timer work (cause I can't write scripts to save my life) you can take some of the sting out of leveling up a skill here and there. Staff are usually fairly lenient when it comes to scripts and triggers. As long as you're paying attention on the occasion someone script checks you, and as long as you don't bumble into other players and negatively affect their play time, they're cool with it. Only thing that's a serious no-no is taking advantage of bugs or incomplete mechanics to get an edge in levels.
I've found the skill grind to be soothing, most days. Since I'm currently unemployed with a kid on the way, and school is on hold till I can return next year, I can set my character to work on one skill or another and then carry the laptop around to keep an eye on it while I do whatever chore needs doing for the day. Works especially well for most crafting skills, because that can get tedious.
If you have a regular RP partner, they could even be a hunting/training buddy and you can RP while you level skills. Group hunts can be fun, and depending on which crowd you get into, even pretty effective in terms of money and skill gain.
TL;DR: While SI does have quite a few skills that can be combat or trade oriented, the real magic is in the roleplay and stories that go on in game. Get out into the world and meet some of the characters, and get to know the ones in your temple especially (you'll often deal with them the most, and the members of each temple ideally act as a sort of support network for their members, both new and old). The grind isn't so bad, especially for those days where you just need a minor distraction while you do school or house work. Build up your character's personality and figure out their history, and maybe you can even hit it big without leveling anything past ten! All it takes is creativity and a little commitment to the character.

Hierophant of Itzal
Re: First Impressions Tied with questions.
Here, here.
However, the grind/time sink is indented, to promote skill diversity between characters by forcing people to specialize.
Unfortunately, it seems near impossible to avoid.
And staff is understandably hesitant to make grand sweeping changes not of their own design.
My grand beef is the premise that we are completely ignorant about everything at commencement.
As least as it pertains to personal competency with coded abilities.
Which only makes the grind that much more frustrating from an OOC perspective, having to start from ground zero when we are presumably adults already.
Even children have more skills than newbies.
However, the grind/time sink is indented, to promote skill diversity between characters by forcing people to specialize.
Unfortunately, it seems near impossible to avoid.
And staff is understandably hesitant to make grand sweeping changes not of their own design.
My grand beef is the premise that we are completely ignorant about everything at commencement.
As least as it pertains to personal competency with coded abilities.
Which only makes the grind that much more frustrating from an OOC perspective, having to start from ground zero when we are presumably adults already.
Even children have more skills than newbies.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Re: First Impressions Tied with questions.
I can forgive the starting at 0 skill points thing, even if annoying. It'd be nice if there was an "allocate 15-25 or so skill levels, amongst whatever skills are available to you." What I would really like to see is the web page contain a list of what abilities are unlocked by what skill at what level. As a result, newbies such as myself aren't even fully aware of what the scope of available skills are (though I have a decent idea of many that exist).
I admit, the grind is something prodigious though. I've thought about triggering/aliases for stuff, but honestly, after two minutes, my eyes glaze a bit from seeing crafting message #52, so if there is a specific attempt by an admin to grab player attention, it would have to be color coded, or sound triggered for. Something to snap my eyeballs back to focus instead of a blur of crafting messaging.
I admit, the grind is something prodigious though. I've thought about triggering/aliases for stuff, but honestly, after two minutes, my eyes glaze a bit from seeing crafting message #52, so if there is a specific attempt by an admin to grab player attention, it would have to be color coded, or sound triggered for. Something to snap my eyeballs back to focus instead of a blur of crafting messaging.
-
CoralScribe
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm
Re: First Impressions Tied with questions.
All of Kaiah's suggestions are good. Like most MUDs, the real fun comes from a sense of community. There are plenty of group hunts one can participate in (they tend to run Mondays and Tuesdays, though I think it's weekends for the moment) and there's always something going on somewhere.
Grinding, or power training (PTing) as it tends to be called here, isn't actually required. At all. The system is designed to take a very long time, and attempting to rush it is not a good idea - we are used to games like WoW where there is a race to the top level, but this isn't that type of game. For the gathering skills, once you unlock level 1 mining, you can mine in the easiest place in the game as well as the most dangerous. For combat, you can always group with others until your levels increase. Crafting has a list that unlocks with levels, but you don't have to have 50 levels in a craft to be good at it or even say you are (it's really really long to level crafts!).
Level when you feel like it, meet others when you can, and try to find your place in the interactive story that you are now a part of. I think if you don't look at the uses slowly go down and see yourself as interacting with the world that it can help.
As always, I'm usually in the Academy tavern, the Black Heart Tavern. Feel free to stop by and I'll be happy to talk with you, teach you about the crafts, or possibly even go hunting.
Grinding, or power training (PTing) as it tends to be called here, isn't actually required. At all. The system is designed to take a very long time, and attempting to rush it is not a good idea - we are used to games like WoW where there is a race to the top level, but this isn't that type of game. For the gathering skills, once you unlock level 1 mining, you can mine in the easiest place in the game as well as the most dangerous. For combat, you can always group with others until your levels increase. Crafting has a list that unlocks with levels, but you don't have to have 50 levels in a craft to be good at it or even say you are (it's really really long to level crafts!).
Level when you feel like it, meet others when you can, and try to find your place in the interactive story that you are now a part of. I think if you don't look at the uses slowly go down and see yourself as interacting with the world that it can help.
As always, I'm usually in the Academy tavern, the Black Heart Tavern. Feel free to stop by and I'll be happy to talk with you, teach you about the crafts, or possibly even go hunting.
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
Re: First Impressions Tied with questions.
I just suppress the scripting spam, or divert it to another window with CMUD, but still.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
-
EliteJarod
- Academy Student
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Tue Jun 07, 2016 9:12 pm
Re: First Impressions Tied with questions.
The other thing that I would recommend is removing or lowering the round time on failure.
I can cast magic in 4 seconds or fail for the same duration lol.
I can cast magic in 4 seconds or fail for the same duration lol.
Re: First Impressions Tied with questions.
From what I have experienced in this game so far, this is a world constructed for players to come and
create a character that will grow emotionally(rp/social interaction) and physically(skills) over time... years, not months.
It is definitely not a short story in a paperback collection. This is shelves of novels. And I do hope we
all remember what holding and reading a book is like
The community its self is not very old (only 4 years is it?), and we are possibly looking at an increase in population
very soon. This will add even more niches that folks can fill in addition to those mentioned by Shadowbane. The word
Trader is a very broad term that could cover anything from an official ATC merchant(the only one you really need decent skills
to accomplish) to a back street informant. Sell carved trinkets to new students, run for political office, Take out loans to buy
land and a building and rent it out for profit. Start a newspaper with a temple or political slant. sell fruit on the street
corner and dodge the taxman. Collect personal histories of other adventurers. Put on a stage production and charge admission.
Be a messenger or courier. Haul things for sylphs and get payed by the pound. Be a professional begger. Hire on as a personal
assistant.
All of the above and more (excepting the ATC Merch), can be done with no more than three hours grind in the Acadamy.
Want to be a professional? Here is where you have to put in the time. Not to learn how to hold a knife (you already know how
to do that), but how to efficiently slice the enemy to speed their bleeding, or what part of the body to smack and cause
internal bleeding. The best angle to hold your shield so the blow slides off and not break your arm.
Can you create a flickering flame in your hand? maybe, but to intensify it to a fireball, and then be able to hurl it at
a creature could take a lot of concentration and practice. How about the intonation and inflection of that Prayer that
you first had to memorize each syllable of. Is it the ultimate song that is pleasing to your god right down to the last utterance?
On the crafting side, learning to carve or sculp something harder than playdough takes study and practice to learn the grain and
fault lines that makes the final touch either break it or make it.
I have found that I do my best 'power training' while interacting with others. Hunting or sitting and crafting while talking and
getting to know each other and ourselves.
But enough rambling from a bad spelling old fart. Oh, and Welcome to SI!
@Althea
On skills etc. You can gain a lot of info from other characters of the same class as well as other classes with some casual conversation
in game.
You might also try the search function at the top and scroll through some of the OOC folders here. I know you can find priest as well as
some general mage and scout info on skill progressions. But be aware that they can and will change.
create a character that will grow emotionally(rp/social interaction) and physically(skills) over time... years, not months.
It is definitely not a short story in a paperback collection. This is shelves of novels. And I do hope we
all remember what holding and reading a book is like
The community its self is not very old (only 4 years is it?), and we are possibly looking at an increase in population
very soon. This will add even more niches that folks can fill in addition to those mentioned by Shadowbane. The word
Trader is a very broad term that could cover anything from an official ATC merchant(the only one you really need decent skills
to accomplish) to a back street informant. Sell carved trinkets to new students, run for political office, Take out loans to buy
land and a building and rent it out for profit. Start a newspaper with a temple or political slant. sell fruit on the street
corner and dodge the taxman. Collect personal histories of other adventurers. Put on a stage production and charge admission.
Be a messenger or courier. Haul things for sylphs and get payed by the pound. Be a professional begger. Hire on as a personal
assistant.
All of the above and more (excepting the ATC Merch), can be done with no more than three hours grind in the Acadamy.
Want to be a professional? Here is where you have to put in the time. Not to learn how to hold a knife (you already know how
to do that), but how to efficiently slice the enemy to speed their bleeding, or what part of the body to smack and cause
internal bleeding. The best angle to hold your shield so the blow slides off and not break your arm.
Can you create a flickering flame in your hand? maybe, but to intensify it to a fireball, and then be able to hurl it at
a creature could take a lot of concentration and practice. How about the intonation and inflection of that Prayer that
you first had to memorize each syllable of. Is it the ultimate song that is pleasing to your god right down to the last utterance?
On the crafting side, learning to carve or sculp something harder than playdough takes study and practice to learn the grain and
fault lines that makes the final touch either break it or make it.
I have found that I do my best 'power training' while interacting with others. Hunting or sitting and crafting while talking and
getting to know each other and ourselves.
But enough rambling from a bad spelling old fart. Oh, and Welcome to SI!
@Althea
On skills etc. You can gain a lot of info from other characters of the same class as well as other classes with some casual conversation
in game.
You might also try the search function at the top and scroll through some of the OOC folders here. I know you can find priest as well as
some general mage and scout info on skill progressions. But be aware that they can and will change.
Re: First Impressions Tied with questions.
@RPGer: Agreed, I can sometimes find what I'm looking for through judicious use of the search function, and some luck, it's just one of those things to me, that isn't in my mind meant to be a 'secret' part of the game obscured from players. It would, in its present state feel like removing religion and race tabs from the main page, and suggesting that one ought to search the forums to find out what races and religions are availble. While perhaps a little more dramatic than trade skills, it's not a terribly far shot for players. A "stickied" forum topic for these sorts of things would also be good, too.
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: First Impressions Tied with questions.
The website is still a work in progress, as I understand it. Staff are focusing on fleshing out the game and hammering down details like levels before devoting time to polishing up the site. They make some changes, like they have to the religion pages, but I think their energy is currently concentrated on finalizing the game for September.
As for the bit about the eyes glazing because of craft (and combat) messages, gag triggers are your friend. Take the repetitive lines you see, copy-paste them into your trigger window when making new triggers, and select "omit from output" (if you use MUSH, might be similar in Mudlet though). It will basically block the message from being seen on your screen, thus making it easier to spot emotes, says or contacts (TELL is ooc, and largely the channel used by staff to communicate to players, but sometimes it's necessary to send a quick message like "BRB cat on fire" or something), and those pesky room emotes that could or could not be a quick script check done by one of staff if they've watched you craft or practice hiding for three or four hours without blinking.
Some players like the idea of skill unlock levels being secret, especially for the more shady classes like thieves and assassins. However, in game, I've found most will gladly at least point you in the right direction when it comes to asking about levels and training in an IC manner. I know staff plan to develop skill trees for the website for those who have no patience for discovery so they know what skills unlock stuff, but I don't know for sure if they intend to include the specific level. Typically, it's safe to say your primary combat and utility skill (your first and maybe second damage spell, your close combat, your vigor spell, hiding, etc) will be what unlocks your more advanced skills. Some have posted class skills on the forums, and that can give you a better idea of the pattern.
As for the bit about the eyes glazing because of craft (and combat) messages, gag triggers are your friend. Take the repetitive lines you see, copy-paste them into your trigger window when making new triggers, and select "omit from output" (if you use MUSH, might be similar in Mudlet though). It will basically block the message from being seen on your screen, thus making it easier to spot emotes, says or contacts (TELL is ooc, and largely the channel used by staff to communicate to players, but sometimes it's necessary to send a quick message like "BRB cat on fire" or something), and those pesky room emotes that could or could not be a quick script check done by one of staff if they've watched you craft or practice hiding for three or four hours without blinking.
Some players like the idea of skill unlock levels being secret, especially for the more shady classes like thieves and assassins. However, in game, I've found most will gladly at least point you in the right direction when it comes to asking about levels and training in an IC manner. I know staff plan to develop skill trees for the website for those who have no patience for discovery so they know what skills unlock stuff, but I don't know for sure if they intend to include the specific level. Typically, it's safe to say your primary combat and utility skill (your first and maybe second damage spell, your close combat, your vigor spell, hiding, etc) will be what unlocks your more advanced skills. Some have posted class skills on the forums, and that can give you a better idea of the pattern.

Hierophant of Itzal