Page 2 of 3
Re: Thieves help me out!
Posted: Tue Oct 29, 2013 8:10 pm
by
Hmm..So i posted this big long reply and its missing. No idea what happened there.
Let me sum it up:
I can see it from both sides.
It seems a little unfair to be an average PC and to suddenly get assassinated and have no idea who did it.
However it seems a little unbelievable that a professional assassin wouldn't have a way to somewhat conceal their identity.
i imagine that the only times an assassin would be actually assassinating another PC would be if they were hired to do so..(I mean I have a skill-set, and I don't do it unless someone pays me to do it, you know). Which means another PC, or a staff-run character (like maybe a King / religious leader) hired them.
This is all assuming that a player doesnt just go about abusing it.
Maybe a good solution would be to have a staff-run assassin guild leader of some sort that makes sure that players are not attempting to assassinate other players without a good reason to do so. Or maybe even take it one step further and any assassinations have to be actually approved by the assassin leader, anything else is considered rogue and is a punishable offense. Might seem like a lot of work, but again I don't think it will be a common occurance, more of a story-line thing. The leader takes care of the legal issues of it all and protects the assassin as it's a valid contract..otherwise it's just murder. (That make sense? it does in my head)
I would say implement a method of masking for assassins, if there is a problem with abuse just take it out. Why worry about something that hasn't even happened yet?
Re: Thieves help me out!
Posted: Tue Oct 29, 2013 8:17 pm
by
Good stuff so far. I think it's safe to say Assassin's Creed is an influence of our assassins here. At least how they were perceived in their world. Being an assassin already puts you at the center of blame for any murder. That would be widely known and accepted. If someone wants to take it upon themselves to chase down an assassin for murdering them, that's certainly acceptable. Taking their claim of an assassin to a knight marshal for justice might go overlooked. They are assassins and this is what they do. Your beef is with whoever hired them most likely.
As far as their role in society, I think a look at the academy should explain it all. Thieves are considered outcasts while Assassins have an official chamber with the other classes. They are tools of their respective faction. They might kill for money or on behalf of their religion. Giving them name only disguise was our attempt to compromise on the potential overpowered aspect of what disguise brings to a fighting class and leaving them completely exposed. As mentioned above, masking would be good for recon work. For getting closer to your target. Sure it will be used as a tool to get away, but without disguise race, gender, height, weight, or age they are still largely exposed when carrying out an assassination. It's still a disguise skill though, not an actual mask. We toyed with the idea of a hooded cloak that hid your name from view and we may still use that at some point, but it was full of bugs when it came to interacting with hooded players.
I will say this though, Thieves and assassins are not the same. In dgate you only had one option, the thief class, and from that you had to role play as an assassin, a con artist, shadow mage, or anything else that loosely fit into the class. By separating the two we are able to restore some honor to the assassin class and expand them across all religions instead of limiting them to just Itzal. You're welcome to roll a thief and role play as an assassin, but you won't be as effective in combat. Thieves here are more defensive than offensive (excluding the currently overpowered backstab) while assassins are one of the most dangerous offensive threats in the game.
Re: Thieves help me out!
Posted: Tue Oct 29, 2013 8:18 pm
by
Maybe you could 'tag' someone, PC or other, so you can keep tabs on them. I guess that means assassins would have a slight psionic or 'sixth' sense about where their target is.
How detailed you get with the track is another thing
Re: Thieves help me out!
Posted: Tue Oct 29, 2013 8:23 pm
by
Oh and another note, if assassins are one of the most offensive threats in the game, then they need to be vulnerable somehow. It should take some skill in order to use an assassin effectively; they shouldn't just become a 'warrior but better' class.
Re: Thieves help me out!
Posted: Tue Oct 29, 2013 8:37 pm
by
Well if traps ever get put in that would be a way to kill someone without them knowing exactly who did it except it had to be an assassin, just which one.
As long as we can kill ERCs I'm fine with whatever
Re: Thieves help me out!
Posted: Wed Oct 30, 2013 4:57 am
by
Great suggestions for assassins!
While we appreciate everyone's passion for gaming, this is not the place to speak ill of former players. As we like to keep our drama IC, not OOC, some previous posts in this and other threads have been edited to reflect this position.
Re: Thieves help me out!
Posted: Thu Nov 07, 2013 8:45 pm
by
Never Mind
Re: Thieves help me out!
Posted: Thu Nov 14, 2013 1:24 pm
by
After messing around with a few of the thief skills, I thought I would share my observations. Shadowstrike is a cool skill and love it. The problem is it is hard to level outside of the academy. Since there is currently no way to move into a room hidden, you have to hide upon entering a room prior to being put into combat. Seems creatures in Pearl are much "faster" than the academy, while not impossible, it is about a 50/50 shot at most hunting places in and around Pearl. Seems there is a hidden front loaded delay when trying to hide. Leveling this skill past 10, when the multiple uses goes away, will be "painful".
Backstab has the same issues as Shadowstike, as you need to hide prior to using it. You basically get one use per creature, so again painful to level. If anybody ever gets to level 20 they should be the thief's medal of honor.
Pilfering is cool but seems to have a bug. Seems there are four possible outcomes to an attempt; failure, failure and your spotted, success and you find or pilfer nothing, and a successful pilfer and you get 5 doubloons. If you pilfer while hidden, you should be revealed on a failure, but currently you are also revealed on a successful attempt when you get some doubloons.
I still think disguise is way overpowered, the ability to mask your identity at level 1 for as long as you want is too much. Perhaps put a timer on it, that increases with levels? Would be cool if your disguise "falls apart" in the middle of a crime.
All in all, love the skill tree so far, just wish there was a way to train the specialty skills more efficiently.
Re: Thieves help me out!
Posted: Thu Nov 14, 2013 1:58 pm
by
sneaking into a room should put you into hiding.
Re: Thieves help me out!
Posted: Fri Nov 15, 2013 7:49 am
by
Does every single skill in game go to level 100....and does it really need to if so? Would it be feasible that some skills cap out lower?