Don't Get Defensive Update
Re: Don't Get Defensive Update
Agreed. From an rp perspective I'd rather have dodge/parry than parry/dual parry. I will also never use a 2 hander. Shadowstrike, backstab, and I assume other stuff relies on it.
Re: Don't Get Defensive Update
Assuming it isn't its own skill, I think dual-wielding just gives us a higher chance of parrying in general.Seryth wrote:Agreed. From an rp perspective I'd rather have dodge/parry than parry/dual parry. I will also never use a 2 hander. Shadowstrike, backstab, and I assume other stuff relies on it.
You also cannot use SS or BS with anything that isn't a dagger, so even one-handed swords/weapons are unusable for these abilities.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Re: Don't Get Defensive Update
I love two-handers. With the same ftg drain as a one-hander there is absolutely no reason to ever use a one-hander until dual wield comes out.
And then it is a skill that will need to be worked up to be useful. so it will still be awhile until it matches or outpaces(if ever) the DPS of a two-hander.
For a class that should be all about the DPS I don't think losing dodge is that big of a deal as long as dual parry works with parry, and not against it. But being hit by anything not considered a weapon is a bit too far. If naturals ever come into line Assassin's will get owned by biters and clawers not being able to defend.
Even from a RP perspective, we're supposed to be providing a real service to people. it's a respected job. Like Assassin's Creed. A large flashy two-hander will deter more people and intimidate than a one-handed weapon. or two pig-stickers. But one of the 1st moves you learn in Assassin's Creed is dodge, then you whack them with your giant axe
And then it is a skill that will need to be worked up to be useful. so it will still be awhile until it matches or outpaces(if ever) the DPS of a two-hander.
For a class that should be all about the DPS I don't think losing dodge is that big of a deal as long as dual parry works with parry, and not against it. But being hit by anything not considered a weapon is a bit too far. If naturals ever come into line Assassin's will get owned by biters and clawers not being able to defend.
Even from a RP perspective, we're supposed to be providing a real service to people. it's a respected job. Like Assassin's Creed. A large flashy two-hander will deter more people and intimidate than a one-handed weapon. or two pig-stickers. But one of the 1st moves you learn in Assassin's Creed is dodge, then you whack them with your giant axe
Re: Don't Get Defensive Update
My favorite quote from Once Upon a Time in the West.
"You were just supposed to scare them!"
"People scare better when they're dying."
"You were just supposed to scare them!"
"People scare better when they're dying."
Re: Don't Get Defensive Update
I appreciate that most of you would avoid two handed weapons, but we are not on the honor system. Some things have to be enforced on our end for mechanical reasons. Any class, any person can make a case for being able to dodge. It's a skill to master, but anyone could do it if that's the argument.
Also dual parry is its own skill.
Also dual parry is its own skill.
Re: Don't Get Defensive Update
We just need to wait until the full update to see what happens with dodge and dual parry. I'm actually fine with losing dodge as long as getting something in return.
That being said. I have a few things I'd like to point out from my understanding of the mechanics.
Dual Parry is pretty much a PvE skill for hunting. Maybe useful in group PvP if you're the only target.
In single PvP combat.
vs. Scouts w/melee - parry only w/missiles - defenseless
vs. Thieves - parry only
vs. Barbarians - parry only unless barbs get a 2nd swing.
vs. Fighters w/two hands - even. w/shield - parry only while the fighter still has two defenses
vs. Mage - defenseless
vs. Templar - parry only
vs. dragons/wyverns - defenseless
vs. Assassin - battle until swords break
So any player can render that skill useless. The only counter to that is if dual wield is worth the risk.
according to the website and help file it's a 20% decrease in attack and 5% in damage.
Assuming a 2-hander is 45pts and a 1 hander is 35pts at 4secs a swing. I know this is low, probably around iron quality, but assuming a 10pt difference here just to be on the safe side.
We see 1.5x more damage from the 2 one-handers over the two-hander which is nice.
If dual wield adds 1 second to it we see 1.18x the damage. not that bad.
if it adds 2 secs we're at 0.98x the damage. Hand me my two-hander.
So, just an extra 2 sec delay renders it a useless skill. meaning back to just parry.
And that's assuming you hit your target 100% of the time.
and with the 20% decrease in attack... You're effectively at a lower level when it comes to attacking. Don't know the progression so didn't use the AR numbers but should still be close.
level 10 = 8. -2 levels in AR
level 20 = 16. -4 levels in AR
level 30 = 24. -6 levels in AR
level 40 = 32. -8 levels in AR
level 50 = 40. -10 levels in AR
level 60 = 48. -12 levels in AR
level 70 = 56. -14 levels in AR
level 80 = 64. -16 levels in AR
level 90 = 72. -18 levels in AR
level 100 = 80. -20 levels in AR
As you can see with the AR reduction around level 30-40 you could be missing often enough to negate any damage gain with just a 1 sec delay. Then eventually you negate a no second delay.
For hunting you're forced to hunt lower level areas the higher level you are... which you have to do anyway when using a two-hander because you can't dodge and they hit you more often.
Plus hunting lower level mobs means they miss you more anyways so you don't really need the dual parry.
Against lower level players it's not an issue. It's equally skilled opponents or DR beasts like thieves where you're better off with a two-hander.
But that's only assuming that the 20% decrease is static and doesn't decrease over levels. For all I know it could work completely different and that information could be outdated.
It also doesn't take into account if poison can be applied to one-handed swords or just daggers.
If dual wield will work with shadow strike/backstab
Also doesn't include if you can fight with one dagger and one sword in order to use poison.
Those damage numbers without poison would be: 0sec = 1.27x 1sec = 1.01x 2sec = 0.84x (here we see a 1sec delay nullify the gain immediately)
Until poison is implemented we won't know the damage possible. or if the poison have more than one effect.
Damage? slow? paralyze?
Of course that leave fighters high and dry.
So a lot of variables to account for.
So you can see why some people wouldn't be too happy about losing Dodge since they don't know what the benefit for the trade-off would be.
That being said. I have a few things I'd like to point out from my understanding of the mechanics.
Dual Parry is pretty much a PvE skill for hunting. Maybe useful in group PvP if you're the only target.
In single PvP combat.
vs. Scouts w/melee - parry only w/missiles - defenseless
vs. Thieves - parry only
vs. Barbarians - parry only unless barbs get a 2nd swing.
vs. Fighters w/two hands - even. w/shield - parry only while the fighter still has two defenses
vs. Mage - defenseless
vs. Templar - parry only
vs. dragons/wyverns - defenseless
vs. Assassin - battle until swords break
So any player can render that skill useless. The only counter to that is if dual wield is worth the risk.
according to the website and help file it's a 20% decrease in attack and 5% in damage.
Assuming a 2-hander is 45pts and a 1 hander is 35pts at 4secs a swing. I know this is low, probably around iron quality, but assuming a 10pt difference here just to be on the safe side.
We see 1.5x more damage from the 2 one-handers over the two-hander which is nice.
If dual wield adds 1 second to it we see 1.18x the damage. not that bad.
if it adds 2 secs we're at 0.98x the damage. Hand me my two-hander.
So, just an extra 2 sec delay renders it a useless skill. meaning back to just parry.
And that's assuming you hit your target 100% of the time.
and with the 20% decrease in attack... You're effectively at a lower level when it comes to attacking. Don't know the progression so didn't use the AR numbers but should still be close.
level 10 = 8. -2 levels in AR
level 20 = 16. -4 levels in AR
level 30 = 24. -6 levels in AR
level 40 = 32. -8 levels in AR
level 50 = 40. -10 levels in AR
level 60 = 48. -12 levels in AR
level 70 = 56. -14 levels in AR
level 80 = 64. -16 levels in AR
level 90 = 72. -18 levels in AR
level 100 = 80. -20 levels in AR
As you can see with the AR reduction around level 30-40 you could be missing often enough to negate any damage gain with just a 1 sec delay. Then eventually you negate a no second delay.
For hunting you're forced to hunt lower level areas the higher level you are... which you have to do anyway when using a two-hander because you can't dodge and they hit you more often.
Plus hunting lower level mobs means they miss you more anyways so you don't really need the dual parry.
Against lower level players it's not an issue. It's equally skilled opponents or DR beasts like thieves where you're better off with a two-hander.
But that's only assuming that the 20% decrease is static and doesn't decrease over levels. For all I know it could work completely different and that information could be outdated.
It also doesn't take into account if poison can be applied to one-handed swords or just daggers.
If dual wield will work with shadow strike/backstab
Also doesn't include if you can fight with one dagger and one sword in order to use poison.
Those damage numbers without poison would be: 0sec = 1.27x 1sec = 1.01x 2sec = 0.84x (here we see a 1sec delay nullify the gain immediately)
Until poison is implemented we won't know the damage possible. or if the poison have more than one effect.
Damage? slow? paralyze?
Of course that leave fighters high and dry.
So a lot of variables to account for.
So you can see why some people wouldn't be too happy about losing Dodge since they don't know what the benefit for the trade-off would be.
Re: Don't Get Defensive Update
Do assassins get the reverse offensive / defensive ratings as thieves? Thieves are 4 OR and 6 DR per level, so are Assassins 6 OR / 4 DR per level?
- Illegal Activity
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 87
- Joined: Wed Dec 11, 2013 11:17 pm
Re: Don't Get Defensive Update
I think they get 6/5 per level!
Re: Don't Get Defensive Update
6*50 = 300 AR 300/20% = 240 240/6 = 40 So yeah... my calculations are correct. Level 50 would see a 10 level drop in attack rating.
Re: Don't Get Defensive Update
So let me get this straight, Assassins will lose the ability to dodge once duel wield/parry are implemented, at which time the dodge levels will convert to duel wield. Thieves will lose the ability to parry but gain those uses to a different class skill. Are these the only two classes affected by this change? Assassins are going to have to cry me a deep river before I feel bad about them losing dodge, knowing they get a 6/5 progression, that's 33% more AR and 17% less DR than thieves, for what, the ability to pilfer? I think that is more than enough to crown them as the shadowy offensive powerhouses that they should be.