Page 2 of 2
Re: Staff plans for Templars?
Posted: Tue Mar 11, 2014 6:57 pm
by
I only started playing because I thought Arcanists were out. Then I only chose an elf race for nightvision when darkness doesn't exist. If I thought I could switch over spell levels I would work my human mage.
Re: Staff plans for Templars?
Posted: Tue Mar 11, 2014 7:24 pm
by
Well this is a bit off topic at this point, but my 2 cents would to be not make exceptions for anyone wanting to class change. This is a dangerous road to go down, and what is good for one person is good for all.
If you want to roll a new class, you should have to roll a new character imho. No exceptions.
Re: Staff plans for Templars?
Posted: Tue Mar 11, 2014 7:31 pm
by
This is a dangerous road to go down
I really don't see how. Giving people options, within reason, can only be beneficial to keeping players happy and
playing.
If you want to roll a new class, you should have to roll a new character imho. No exceptions.
You're not restricted to one job in life, I see no reason why a character can't choose to pursue a new path down the road if there's a good enough reason for it, especially if you've poured a lot of time and effort into that character's growth both in game mechanics and in role play. Having alternate characters that you play seriously in a game like this is difficult, asking someone to shelf their main so they can play another class, with a whole new character they aren't invested in, makes no sense to me.
Re: Staff plans for Templars?
Posted: Tue Mar 11, 2014 8:02 pm
by
Mates,
Fantasy, and gaming, isn't real life. As much as one might like to use those arguments consistently, it sadly is not. Otherwise, I'd have a pet dragon and would be calling myself a Targaryen.
If we're going to use the real life argument, however, let's. Yes, whilst one may have multiple jobs in life, if they're applying and entering a new field then they must master new techniques. A warrior may, and likely does, have a different fighting style than an assassin. A fire mage would have different ways of manipulating and conjuring flame than an air mage would with the wind. If we'd kept haste in, they also would have leveled much faster.
Or if they're a templar. Let's say templars are implemented, since I'm sure my example of mage or priest will try to be debunked. I am a templar. I have a self-heal and likely a vigor spell. Now, one day I may want to be a warrior. I'm not sure. Maybe an assassin. But for now, I've got these prayers to help me level an already easy skill into a nearly effortless one. But now I think I maybe want to be a warrior. Warriors and assassins in comparison have it a bit tougher than me (though CC is by no means difficult or tedious to level), but I want to change into one. Is that fair? Or would you halve my levels, whilst letting a straight across change between assassin and warriors? Maybe you think it should be a case by case basis? Those aren't ever good, and is in fact why when I was arguing in favour of disguised personas being allowed to post under new accounts I listened to the counterarguments of making it a base standard applied equally.
Yes, our class change policy is tough. Yet, in its own way it's much nicer than some other games.
Cheers.
Re: Staff plans for Templars?
Posted: Tue Mar 11, 2014 8:40 pm
by
Fantasy, and gaming, isn't real life. As much as one might like to use those arguments consistently, it sadly is not. Otherwise, I'd have a pet dragon and would be calling myself a Targaryen.
But let's face it you actually have a small pussy cat and called it Teef.
Re: Staff plans for Templars?
Posted: Tue Mar 11, 2014 8:49 pm
by
Fantasy, and gaming, isn't real life. As much as one might like to use those arguments consistently, it sadly is not.
No, it isn't, but if there weren't at least some realism and relatability to real life then it wouldn't be engaging or immersive. I do get your point about fighting styles, but swordplay is swordplay, and it would be both difficult and awkward to have to explain IC why they can barely fend off skeletons and quails when they were taking on vampires the day before.
Or if they're a templar. Let's say templars are implemented, since I'm sure my example of mage or priest will try to be debunked. I am a templar. I have a self-heal and likely a vigor spell. Now, one day I may want to be a warrior. I'm not sure. Maybe an assassin. But for now, I've got these prayers to help me level an already easy skill into a nearly effortless one. But now I think I maybe want to be a warrior. Warriors and assassins in comparison have it a bit tougher than me (though CC is by no means difficult or tedious to level), but I want to change into one. Is that fair? Or would you halve my levels, whilst letting a straight across change between assassin and warriors? Maybe you think it should be a case by case basis? Those aren't ever good, and is in fact why when I was arguing in favour of disguised personas being allowed to post under new accounts I listened to the counterarguments of making it a base standard applied equally.
Honestly? Halving it would be an acceptable compromise, if anything. I would take it.
While I understand a case by case situation isn't entirely favorable, I don't agree with the idea that honest and hard-working players with potentially good IC/OOC reasons for a class change should have to suffer a penalty, because the minority might cheat or abuse the system.
Again, halving it could make a great compromise. You might not think CC is difficult or tedious to level, but that depends heavily on the class, if you have people to level WITH, and your schedule. Took me roughly 4 months to get where I am right now, and I'm able to play all day every day. Once I start school, it will take more than twice as long to get to that same level, assuming I still want to have time to RP. This is of course my own personal situation, and I may not even ask for a class change ever, but I want other people with similar issues and concerns to have that chance.
Re: Staff plans for Templars?
Posted: Tue Mar 11, 2014 8:57 pm
by
but swordplay is swordplay
This is because it's all one skill, and that actually annoys me that everything falls into this catch all called Close Combat.
There should be some kind of specialization.
Re: Staff plans for Templars?
Posted: Tue Mar 11, 2014 9:06 pm
by
I do get your point about fighting styles, but swordplay is swordplay, and it would be both difficult and awkward to have to explain IC why they can barely fend off skeletons and quails when they were taking on vampires the day before.
Maybe your character broke their arm/leg while in training for their new calling and the trauma of that incident required them to restrengthen themselves. Just tossing out an idea.
I don't agree with the idea that honest and hard-working players with potentially good IC/OOC reasons for a class change should have to suffer a penalty, because the minority might cheat or abuse the system.
I do fully agree with you here. However, people cheat/abuse systems everyday in both life and games, and if this is the best way to ensure maximum effectiveness, so be it.
There should be some kind of specialization.
Do you mean weapon-type specific?