Priest discussion and feedback

Discuss your favorite races, ask the questions you've always wondered about, or just follow along in the conversation. This is the place for everything that is Shattered Isles. Keep your debates civil. Trolls will be executed on sight.
Wonton
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 8:35 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Wonton »

Perhaps, though I don't want you to feel 'run out' of the discussion. :/

Let's put quabbles over 'downtime' aside. I think what you're looking for, and please, correct me if I am wrong, is for staff to open an undead hunting ground in between Crypts and Vampires in which you can utilize Strike and turn, and not have to underhunt in the crypts and struggle to hunt effectively in vampires - which would give you (and by extension the rest of us priests) a more normal hunting curve like that of other classes. Our hunting graduation curve would be, then: Golems > Skeletons > A few other low-level Academy MOBs > Crypts > Hunting Ground X > Vampires.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Swamp Ape »

My case is perhaps unique and Doxx may not be the best example for me to use when we are debating priest hunting. I use bite as my primary attack which does not restrict me to undead. I do hunt vampires occasionally but my primary hunting grounds are the statues. With that being said I have experience with a melee type of attack and prayers but I'm not sure how compatible that is with our current debate since naturals are not really the same as "traditional" melee.

To be honest I don't even think I've ever been to the crypts and I'm not even sure where they are. I was in a cemetery looking area before just north of the pearl gates but nothing ever spawned. I think that's the same place where your spirit goes after you die and is waiting for resurrection. Is that where the crypt is located?
Wonton
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 8:35 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Wonton »

Swamp Ape wrote:I was in a cemetery looking area before just north of the pearl gates but nothing ever spawned. I think that's the same place where your spirit goes after you die and is waiting for resurrection. Is that where the crypt is located?
That's where it is. Keep going southeast until you get to a 'stone slab', and then "go" through the slab. I think it's also 'east' as far as directional commands go. MOBs'll spawn down in the crypt area.
SwampApe wrote:My case is perhaps unique and Doxx may not be the best example for me to use when we are debating priest hunting. I use bite as my primary attack which does not restrict me to undead. I do hunt vampires occasionally but my primary hunting grounds are the statues. With that being said I have experience with a melee type of attack and prayers but I'm not sure how compatible that is with our current debate since naturals are not really the same as "traditional" melee.
This is likely where we're clashing in our previous discussion. Because priests aren't built for combat as a class, they won't be able to hunt effectively in most hunting grounds. However, thanks to turn and strike, we can at least land around par with a mage's income in undead hunting grounds. You've been hunting in an area where your class' skills are not designed to be effective (as far as killing things go), so that's probably a reason why you've been having so much trouble.

As well, if bite works off of unarmed DR, then you'll have less DR than you would if you had trained CC as a priest. Granted, I think it's cool you went for naturals as opposed to weapons, so I'm not knocking you for the choice, but the lower DR from naturals, as opposed to CC, is likely increasing the disparity you've found hunting in a ground not built for priests.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Swamp Ape »

On top of Doxx not being a traditional priest, I think the original topic that i was referring to also got a bit off track. I don't think money making potential through hunting should be driven by class mechanics. I think every class should have an equal opportunity to make as much money as any other class. This is not about priests, I am talking about every class. Make the classes unique in different ways but not through financial inequality.
Synche
Academy Student
Posts: 3
Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2014 3:12 am

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Synche »

I'm a new guy from DGate and I have to ask how the variety is here with regards to templar and priests based on religion.

The religious variants of heart and sword clerics based on their God was one of the most amazing things about the old game, and I am eager to discover if that is replicated here, or if all priests are just priests.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Swamp Ape »

Templars have not been released yet so at this time we have very little information on them.
Bocon L
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat May 31, 2014 5:04 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Bocon L »

I think the old ways of X class should earn more than Y class, have been phased out in most of the other MUDs I have played before this. As long as you can buy mechanical advantages with money, there should be no huge gap in earnings potential. I'm OK with that potential being undead only for priests, as long as it exists.

Healing was brought up at some point as some kind of equalizer, or reason why priests should earn less. Well, everyone can heal, and it's no different than how most priests heal while solo. We don't just stand there and heal through monster damage while trying to kill them. We retreat, heal up, then head back into the room to fight again. Just like every other class does. Thanks to low DR, we also get to enjoy a longer downtime than any melee class does. Asking a casting class to continue to raise CC over their main skills, just to obtain some DR is absurd. Thats's like a warrior who has to work hiding in order to hunt decently. I also consider mend to be a "core" class ability for anyone other than a priest.

To me, dealing high amounts of damage is a far more beneficial ability to have than healing. I cannot heal things to death to make money from it. Nor can I scare off my enemies with huge healing numbers. I can stall a fight until I run out of ftg, but that's it. I'd love to know how much mend heals in and out of combat at decent levels as well.

Healing is only really different in a group setting. But right now, earnings don't really increase if you group, so money wise, it's not really worth it. And believe it or not, keeping a group healed, vigored, and shielded is a lot of work. You actually have to pay attention, unless there's an auto group healing/vigor script I don't know about.

As a side note: I compared priests in this game to a D&D cleric, when I saw they could wear heavy armor and wield a shield.

To sum it up: As long as you can buy mechanical advantages, there should be no major disparity between all classes when it comes to making money.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Swamp Ape »

Bocon L wrote:I think the old ways of X class should earn more than Y class, have been phased out in most of the other MUDs I have played before this. As long as you can buy mechanical advantages with money, there should be no huge gap in earnings potential. I'm OK with that potential being undead only for priests, as long as it exists.

Healing was brought up at some point as some kind of equalizer, or reason why priests should earn less. Well, everyone can heal, and it's no different than how most priests heal while solo. We don't just stand there and heal through monster damage while trying to kill them. We retreat, heal up, then head back into the room to fight again. Just like every other class does. Thanks to low DR, we also get to enjoy a longer downtime than any melee class does. Asking a casting class to continue to raise CC over their main skills, just to obtain some DR is absurd. Thats's like a warrior who has to work hiding in order to hunt decently. I also consider mend to be a "core" class ability for anyone other than a priest.

To me, dealing high amounts of damage is a far more beneficial ability to have than healing. I cannot heal things to death to make money from it. Nor can I scare off my enemies with huge healing numbers. I can stall a fight until I run out of ftg, but that's it. I'd love to know how much mend heals in and out of combat at decent levels as well.

Healing is only really different in a group setting. But right now, earnings don't really increase if you group, so money wise, it's not really worth it. And believe it or not, keeping a group healed, vigored, and shielded is a lot of work. You actually have to pay attention, unless there's an auto group healing/vigor script I don't know about.

As a side note: I compared priests in this game to a D&D cleric, when I saw they could wear heavy armor and wield a shield.

To sum it up: As long as you can buy mechanical advantages, there should be no major disparity between all classes when it comes to making money.
I think a lot of what you said is what I was trying to say but you worded it much more clearly.
Wonton
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 8:35 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Wonton »

A few thoughts:
Bocon L wrote:I think the old ways of X class should earn more than Y class, have been phased out in most of the other MUDs I have As long as you can buy mechanical advantages with money, there should be no huge gap in earnings potential. I'm OK with that potential being undead only for priests, as long as it exists.
Hunting grounds where we hunt effectively exist, they just aren't as plentiful as maybe they should be, so I really thing a lot of the issues can be addressed by opening up that extra undead one I've mentioned before.
Bocon L wrote:Well, everyone can heal, and it's no different than how most priests heal while solo. We don't just stand there and heal through monster damage while trying to kill them. We retreat, heal up, then head back into the room to fight again. Just like every other class does.
While everyone can heal, they won't be as effective as a priest. From earlier posts, characters using mend also get delays if they heal in combat, and still get diminished returns as opposed to priest rates either in or out of combat. So yes, other classes can heal, but it's not nearly as effective as a priest's ability to.

Also, healing returns actually heal for quite a bit. I've found that I don't have to flee when at low health, I just have start healing at a certain point to compensate for some failures before the heal returns catch up and surpass damage taken in. Obviously, it depends on the MOB and your heal level to determine when that 'sweet spot' is to start healing back up, but priests don't necessarily have to run as other classes do. We're still not doing damage while we heal this way, but we're grinding up a class skill, so it's as good for our class as, say, grinding up CC is for melee.
Bocon L wrote:Thanks to low DR, we also get to enjoy a longer downtime than any melee class does.
I've already spoken on my definition of 'downtime', so I won't really debate this. I'll only say that, when hunting in undead areas, we actually fare better than the a mage does (perhaps even some melee classes); while we both have one defense, our DR ratings are equal in some cases (and are better in others), we put out the same damage, and we can heal faster. But that's cool because mages can hunt more effectively in areas priests can't. It's all what the class is built for.
Bocon L wrote:Asking a casting class to continue to raise CC over their main skills, just to obtain some DR is absurd. Thats's like a warrior who has to work hiding in order to hunt decently.
I completely agree with this. If I want to work CC to get those extra stamina raises, cool, but it's absurd to require for the DR boost. We have shield prayers that boost DR, but the shield spell doesn't really seem to add all that much, so I'm not sure how useful it really even is.
Bocon L wrote:I also consider mend to be a "core" class ability for anyone other than a priest.
I've also said my piece on why I don't think mend is a 'core' ability for anyone. It might be 'universal,' but not 'core'.
Bocon L wrote:To me, dealing high amounts of damage is a far more beneficial ability to have than healing. I cannot heal things to death to make money from it. Nor can I scare off my enemies with huge healing numbers. I can stall a fight until I run out of ftg, but that's it.
This comment is the one that sticks out to me the most, especially coming from one who picked a support/healing class to play. The SI page does say that priests are "moderately skilled in combat" which is misleading, but it also says that they "specialize in healing abilities" which is true. I feel like if you value damage over healing, playing a templar (when it opens) or a more damage-focused class might be more to your play style.
Bocon L wrote:Healing is only really different in a group setting. But right now, earnings don't really increase if you group, so money wise, it's not really worth it.
Priests need an expanded toolbox. Healing can't be all we do because that's boring. A valuable skill or not, it just is. So, hopefully priests will get some love with the update that will increase our value both solo and in group dynamics.
Bocon L wrote:And believe it or not, keeping a group healed, vigored, and shielded is a lot of work. You actually have to pay attention, unless there's an auto group healing/vigor script I don't know about.
I actually have an automated hunting script built. It's a bit crude, but it works pretty well. The only thing it doesn't do effectively is keep the party shielded, but shields aren't really worth it as it is, so meh.
Bocon L wrote:As a side note: I compared priests in this game to a D&D cleric, when I saw they could wear heavy armor and wield a shield.
I'm not going to lie, I had a similar view when I first rolled because of what I read in the class description page, though I still expected to specialize in healing abilities. However, after some thought, and realizing the combat clergy class is being released soon, I don't think relating the SI priest to the D&D cleric is a good comparison. A D&D cleric will most likely be SI's templar and priest class combined (sorta, maybe, I dunno - the class isn't out yet), but the individual classes likely won't have the same combat prowess and the wide range of effective prayers. It'll be split.
Last edited by Wonton on Wed Sep 17, 2014 11:12 am, edited 1 time in total.
Wonton
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 8:35 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Wonton »

Synche wrote:I'm a new guy from DGate and I have to ask how the variety is here with regards to templar and priests based on religion.

The religious variants of heart and sword clerics based on their God was one of the most amazing things about the old game, and I am eager to discover if that is replicated here, or if all priests are just priests.
Hi and welcome!

I never played DGate, so I can't really answer your question as well as you might like, but the main difference between the priests (and templars too, when they are released) will be the religion you choose.

If you haven't already, I'd give the main site's race and religion pages a read through (plus some of their history stuff posted) to give yourself a good idea on how to craft your character in SI.

The priest class seems to have the same skills across religions, so maybe the answer to your question is 'all priests are just priests,' but the subtleties come in the way your priest operates based on the religion and race you choose - so it's likely less mechanical and more RP focused.
Post Reply