Tell me again how weak mages are.

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
User avatar
SquallScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 165
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by SquallScribe »

Blink wrote:
But yes, mages ARE a bit broken, for the reasons Anselm has stated. We aren't going to get a very accurate reading or combat test without those issues fixed. It doesn't matter much time you've put into grinding, SI isn't designed for one person to be hugely powerful. Taking on two or three characters will often prove difficult, unless something is very broken, or levels in your primary attack are vastly different. (Assuming everything is fixed and working right, like mid level third tier attack spells)
Yes, resists appear not to be working properly and I hope it is fixed as well. As well, melee damage range needs to be tightened up, but I believe Anselm and Gir have both said staff is working on correcting that. No PC is going to be able to win all the time, or against multiple opponents. That is just the nature of the game, and no amount of time spent leveling should justify you to win in all situations and against all classes. Anselm has said all classes have a foil.
Blink wrote: Oh yeah, I want to say I'm also glad that there are a ton of Human and elf melee people in the game. It's good to have roleplay diversity. It can get pretty tiresome when every warrior is a Vukasin and every mage is an Elf.
Racial diversity does make the game more enjoyable. The point I was making is not that racial diversity should not occur - it's that a low strength mod melee is likely going to lose to a race and class combo designed to foil it ... especially under 1v1, prepared, no-surprise circumstances. Just as a Human warrior will likely lose to a Gavial or Vukasin warrior of the same levels due to the HP disparity and racial strength bonus when using the same level equipment (unless of course the RNG is being exceedingly generous to the Human that day). These are simple facts of race/class combos and need to be considered when comparing mechanics. As it stands, the Gavial do not have options other than warriors or barbarians to play, even if they wanted to - for RP purposes - drive a Gavial toon with a terrible casting mod when casting mods are implemented.
Draven wrote: So the thing that makes people upset is people with the highest Armor/Weapon combo couldn't beat you and it seemingly didn't matter what level CC they were, that seems problematic.
This goes back to the fact that some RP race/class combos (Human, Elf, Sylph, Goblin melee) are not as strong as their more bestial counterparts, and when facing a race designed for the class they are, will likely lose if the attack levels are comparable. It is the same situation as described above for melee. A Gavial warrior of the same levels as a Human warrior will almost always beat the Human warrior because the Gavial race is designed to excel as a melee. The Human is mostly average at it. I'd wager if Blink and Faran were to throw down, the outcome would be a complete toss-up since they are equitably matched.
Draven wrote: I certainly wouldn't win if I just won CC only in addition to parry, dual parry, and shield block. Warriors have other skills to work combat related as well as assassins.
Parry, dual parry and shield block are all passive skills that level at the same time without added delay of leveling close combat. Shield block is the only skill I can level passively as well. While it's true melee have the capacity for much more utility in this game than they do in others, during the Draven/Faran fight you only used close combat. Again, had you been using equipment of the same level (blacksteel), and were melee damage ranges tightened as well as resists working properly, you would have won.

Also, I did not mean to imply you have also not worked to level the Draven character, but it is evident that viability of power in three months versus six months makes leveling close combat (your only damage-inflicting attack skill until dual wield is implemented) a different bag than leveling the number of spells required to have the attack power and utility I do right now. That is just the nature of the beast between casting and melee, though, and I welcome the challenge to continue unlocking spells and improving my PC.
Blink wrote: A Human mage trained up may well have caused the same controversy by beating a bunch of high level warriors at the games because spell resists aren't working. Maybe the coming OOC games will help hash some of these issues out.
That is entirely probable, although elves do start out with higher intelligence and wisdom stats which I believe contributes to overall casting success/failure. Perhaps it doesn't right now, but it is certainly intended to.
Blink wrote: It'd be a poor long term character strategy to rely on broken things to make my character powerful.
Indeed it would, and it would benefit everyone if people could continue to make thoughtful, honest feedback with the overall goal of making the game balanced and enjoyable for everyone.
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by Creon »

Parry, dual parry and shield block are all passive skills that level at the same time without added delay of leveling close combat. Shield block is the only skill I can level passively as well. While it's true melee have the capacity for much more utility in this game than they do in others, during the Draven/Faran fight you only used close combat. Again, had you been using equipment of the same level (blacksteel), and were melee damage ranges tightened as well as resists working properly, you would have won.
I meant the entire event.
Seryth
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 87
Joined: Wed Dec 18, 2013 10:44 pm

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by Seryth »

I really don't understand this, "X class is easier to level" stuff. Yes, in order for a mage to level their utility spells, they have to PT them separately. This can be time consuming, but it isn't hard. Triggers/timers/scripts are easy. This isnt to say everything is working perfectly (like priests only being able to cast their shield once every 7 minutes or something because they have no dispel), but it took me about 20 minutes to figure out a cycle of "shield + buffs + dispel + vigor" to VERY efficiently level like 5 different spells. Important spells. Yes, leveling that many skills won't go as fast as leveling one skill (like CC), but thats because you're leveling several skills at once.

As a melee, I'd kill to have more skills to level. Right now I have masking (which is not terribly rewarding to level), Backstab (which is not allowed to be PT'd on its own currently), and Shadowstrike (same situation as backstab) that are class-specific that I can level. Anything else I can level, a caster can level too. This is primarily why leveling CC is what melee do.

I can't wait to get secondary skills that I can level other than CC, but until then CC and defensive skills are all I can focus on. Mages aren't "harder" to level than Melee, and vice versa. Right now they just aren't even because a lot of stuff isn't implemented.
User avatar
SilverShade
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 197
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by SilverShade »

I have to agree with Seryth here. I would do morally questionable things to have something besides CC to work on combat wise. However, I was told I wasn't allowed to after I tried to come up with a way for me to train it and make it worth my while without cheating someone out of something or breaking a rule on the constantly changing list of rules.

I would love to be able to train something else. I really would. However, I don't have anything. It's not that it's easy, it's that I'm not allowed to focus train anything else that I have. I would love to be able to buddy train shadowstrike again. It was an opportunity to not only increase my character's proficency in a skill, but a chance to regularly RP as well without the hassle of moving, picking money and items up, or the occasional 'oh dear god, I'm dying and where did that other mob come from?' We don't have that anymore. :\
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by Wren »

Seryth wrote:I really don't understand this, "X class is easier to level" stuff. Yes, in order for a mage to level their utility spells, they have to PT them separately. This can be time consuming, but it isn't hard. Triggers/timers/scripts are easy. This isnt to say everything is working perfectly (like priests only being able to cast their shield once every 7 minutes or something because they have no dispel), but it took me about 20 minutes to figure out a cycle of "shield + buffs + dispel + vigor" to VERY efficiently level like 5 different spells. Important spells. Yes, leveling that many skills won't go as fast as leveling one skill (like CC), but thats because you're leveling several skills at once.

As a melee, I'd kill to have more skills to level. Right now I have masking (which is not terribly rewarding to level), Backstab (which is not allowed to be PT'd on its own currently), and Shadowstrike (same situation as backstab) that are class-specific that I can level. Anything else I can level, a caster can level too. This is primarily why leveling CC is what melee do.

I can't wait to get secondary skills that I can level other than CC, but until then CC and defensive skills are all I can focus on. Mages aren't "harder" to level than Melee, and vice versa. Right now they just aren't even because a lot of stuff isn't implemented.
I realize it isn't terribly relevant to the topic at hand, but thank you for posting this all the same. Another melee player and myself were just talking about that very thing not 10 minutes ago!

We're practically begging for more skills to level, and/or to be allowed to work the ones we have more effectively without breaking the rules. I completely understand a Mage's present point about having these extra time sinks, but their players may not realize how badly us melee folk want to be in their shoes! And again, multiple spells can be tied into the same script and worked altogether. I have a Mage I fool around on now and then, and it didn't take me long to figure one out.

Of course, again, things will change once more skills are implemented, but the waiting game does suck at times when you're restricted to non-combat skills and CC. Not trying to play the complain game here, just want Mages to know how much we actually envy them. Your situation is not as bad as you think!
I would love to be able to buddy train shadowstrike again. It was an opportunity to not only increase my character's proficency in a skill, but a chance to regularly RP as well without the hassle of moving, picking money and items up, or the occasional 'oh dear god, I'm dying and where did that other mob come from?' We don't have that anymore. :\
Those were good times. Was like playing shadow-tag.

Not to mention, can't train these types of attacks while in a party with anyone, since they're unusable if someone else is in combat, so it kind of discourages group hunting unless you stick to just CC.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by Blink »

I really don't understand this, "X class is easier to level" stuff. Yes, in order for a mage to level their utility spells, they have to PT them separately. This can be time consuming, but it isn't hard. Triggers/timers/scripts are easy. This isnt to say everything is working perfectly (like priests only being able to cast their shield once every 7 minutes or something because they have no dispel), but it took me about 20 minutes to figure out a cycle of "shield + buffs + dispel + vigor" to VERY efficiently level like 5 different spells. Important spells. Yes, leveling that many skills won't go as fast as leveling one skill (like CC), but thats because you're leveling several skills at once.
I prefer hunting to sitting in a room scripting. However, what we 'like' has little to do with it. The basic forumula of a mud like this is time invested equals some kind of power. (Not always killing power, it might say be movement and utility like teleport or disguise) When I'm hunting really hard I've made up to 12000 doubloons in a long day. To train a utility spell in a room for weeks I'm losing the opportunity to make enormous sums of money.
And again, multiple spells can be tied into the same script and worked altogether. I have a Mage I fool around on now and then, and it didn't take me long to figure one out.
I'm mystified what this is. I just checked actually. Air mages only have 2 utility spells that I can tell, shield and wall. And you can't cast them together, as it says you are already protected. Perhaps you are talking about water mage's water breathing ability? You can't cast slow on yourself and haste is gone.
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by Creon »

I prefer hunting to sitting in a room scripting. However, what we 'like' has little to do with it. The basic forumula of a mud like this is time invested equals some kind of power. (Not always killing power, it might say be movement and utility like teleport or disguise) When I'm hunting really hard I've made up to 12000 doubloons in a long day. To train a utility spell in a room for weeks I'm losing the opportunity to make enormous sums of money.
I think what mages request is that there just be 1 spellcasting skill instead of leveling individual spells and be more on par with what melee class do. Seems to make more sense since correct me if I'm wrong but some spells don't even get better at all with level.
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by Wren »

I'm mystified what this is. I just checked actually. Air mages only have 2 utility spells that I can tell, shield and wall. And you can't cast them together, as it says you are already protected. Perhaps you are talking about water mage's water breathing ability? You can't cast slow on yourself and haste is gone.
In my Mage's case it's Shield/Dispel until I run out of stamina, Invigorate back up to full, rinse and repeat.
I think what mages request is that there just be 1 spellcasting skill instead of leveling individual spells and be more on par with what melee class do.
Wait, what?
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by Blink »

I think what mages request is that there just be 1 spellcasting skill instead of leveling individual spells and be more on par with what melee class do. Seems to make more sense since correct me if I'm wrong but some spells don't even get better at all with level.
Staff already said no to that. And yes some spells give near nothing like Wall, or very minimal gains like shield. And of course third tier attack spells have some problem where they don't raise in level at a certain point.
In my Mage's case it's Shield/Dispel until I run out of stamina, Invigorate back up to full, rinse and repeat.
Oh sorry I misunderstood you. I thought you were saying you could cast multiple utility spells on your mage, then dispel it once. Yes I'm familiar with basic stuff like triggers and loops and use them for in place training. That's part of why I enjoy hunting more though. I only use macros hunting and so it focuses my concentration intently, which I like. Similar to playing Diablo and such.
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by Aumnren »

Wren wrote:Not to mention, can't train these types of attacks while in a party with anyone, since they're unusable if someone else is in combat, so it kind of discourages group hunting unless you stick to just CC.
Try this: Let's say you and Kaiah and Blink went on a hunt. Go together, but don't group up. Before you move, 'look' into your surrounding rooms. When you spot a mob, send Blink in first to catch the agro, then you and Kaiah can move in, hide, and SS or BS until you fail. Kill the mob, rinse and repeat.
Seryth wrote:Yes, in order for a mage to level their utility spells, they have to PT them separately. This can be time consuming, but it isn't hard. Triggers/timers/scripts are easy . . . it took me about 20 minutes to figure out a cycle of "shield + buffs + dispel + vigor" to VERY efficiently level like 5 different spells. Important spells.
The point here wasn't that it was hard. Triggers make most things pretty easy and mindless to level if you have it set right. The point was that mages level attack, defense, and utility with separate skills, while most of this is condensed into one for CC. It is simply that a mage needs to spread time around a variety of skills depending on what it wishes to level.

If a mage wants to level their attack, they train their attack spells.

If a mage wants to level defense, they do have their passive shield block, but they either level shield or, slow (which is the more potent defense of the two) - or even CC if they want that little bit of hope with the RNG

If a mage wants to up their stamina for more casting, they can either train vigor or CC.

If a mage wants to up their utility, they can train portal, gate, or any of others they have.

If a CC class want to level their attack, they train CC

If a CC class wants to level their defense, they train CC

If a CC class wants to up their stamina, they train CC

if a CC class wants to level their utility (the few that they have, and hopefully there will be more), they train those separately, though for the majority of the CC classes, these utility skills are all unlocked by CC.

Yes, you can tie together certain spells to help to level a couple, but you're not leveling these all at once. Each spell still takes its 4 seconds to cast. Vigor and Dispell currently help the mage to level the wide variety of their spells by decreasing the down time due to fatigue, and rightfully so.

Let me state something too, to be clear: I don't think the mages are wrong to be this way, having to level a variety of spells in order to up a certain aspect of their character. I think it separates their style from melee classes.

However,for casters like Faran and Blink, who pour hours into their characters to round them out in all these areas, their effort and the power they have achieved needs to be respected. I understand that there are broken aspects, including resist and damage ranges. These will get fixed. We will move on in the endless journey to balance out a game. But even after all this gets fixed, there's something that needs to be recognized: Mages are not going to be punching bags for melee classes. They are going to need to be approached carefully and with a bit of thought, just like any other leveled PC character should. Just because you have a big sword and a good number of CC levels, doesn't automatically entitle you to an immediate victory against a casting class.
Post Reply