Tell me again how weak mages are.

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Requiem
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 53
Joined: Thu Sep 19, 2013 2:18 am

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by Requiem »

It would be interesting to see what results you would get if you used all your class skills. It looks from your stamina that you were using a one handed weapon, which I don't think is the most effective way to kill a mage. I'd think you would want to backstab or shadowstrike then switch to a two hander. I do agree a level 11 mage should not be a serious threat to a level 60+ weapon user.
User avatar
SquallScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 165
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by SquallScribe »

Requiem wrote:It would be interesting to see what results you would get if you used all your class skills. It looks from your stamina that you were using a one handed weapon, which I don't think is the most effective way to kill a mage. I'd think you would want to backstab or shadowstrike then switch to a two hander. I do agree a level 11 mage should not be a serious threat to a level 60+ weapon user.
Your sanity and reasonable demeanor are refreshing when discussing mechanics issues, of which this game has many. A level 11 anything should not be a serious threat to a level 60+ anything. Right now, the two main issues skewing PvP are sporadic melee damage where no matter a melee's level, their damage range is highly inconsistent, and that mage damage never increases after about level 20. There are, of course, strategic considerations to be made during any combat situation, and ultimately knowing how best to utilize your class (as well as having good armor/weapons) will always give someone an advantage. It must be acknowledged, when discussing caster v. melee PvP, that they both operate differently and there is a lot to be done to balance them against each other and against themselves. It is something that has to be done together and with mechanical stability in mind.
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by Wren »

That is very aggravating, and it is just as annoying for actual high and multiple-leveled mages. A level 11 mage does maybe 2 points of damage less per hit than a level 80 mage. The ONLY difference is fairly minute, and that would be the fail/success rate. A high leveled mage has a much lower fail rate, but the fact that our damage does not improve at all I guess is there to balance us long-term.
Ah-hah, so that's how it works. I did notice a lot of failed attempts, though even with them the damage output was very consistent and frequent. I have to agree that it's rather unfortunate that there is virtually no difference between a low-levelled mage and a high-levelled one, considering the work put into the latter. Though, I guess if the damage scaled with their spell level, we'd either see lowbie mages doing practically nothing which isn't fair to them, or higher ones doing absurd amounts of damage, depending on which end gets 'balanced', so this is the happy medium of sorts.
It looks from your stamina that you were using a one handed weapon, which I don't think is the most effective way to kill a mage.
Wren doesn't actually own a 2-handed weapon. For the sake of RP more than anything I like to limit what she's adept with when it comes to weaponry and the like. That aside, I'm genuinely curious as to whether or not a blacksteel 1-hander is stronger than a steel 2-hander. I use the former for PvP because I've been under the assumption that it's either better, or equal to a stronger weapon of lesser quality. I'd love if someone could in fact confirm or correct me on this!
I do agree a level 11 mage should not be a serious threat to a level 60+ weapon user.
A level 11 anything should not be a serious threat to a level 60+ anything.
Completely agree.
Right now, the two main issues skewing PvP are sporadic melee damage where no matter a melee's level, their damage range is highly inconsistent, and that mage damage never increases after about level 20.
Ultimately, I think tightening up the melee damage range even a little, and getting resist to work, would almost if not entirely fix these issues when it comes to balancing PvP. There's also the added benefit of my class being able to hunt more effectively in areas where we're vulnerable, since better damage means killing things before they kill us. In regards to mages, I'm not sure what to suggest beyond maybe finding a way to scale their spell damage with their level without crippling lowbie mages or making high ones unbeatable by those of comparable level.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Post by Snaek »

We discussed our approach for spell damage at the OOC spell and prayer meeting. The current damage progression for attack spells is not set up for any kind of balancing against melee. It's an outdated approach that has been pointed out and accounted for in the new attack spell structure. Existing spells are not going to see their damage change. They'll be replaced with similar spells when the new structure goes in.

Resistance to spells is another part of the balancing act we are adjusting with the next update as well, also discussed in the meeting. Both of these are slated for the next patch along with curses for priests. It's our current coding project with nothing scheduled ahead of it.

Austere was working on getting this log posted. I will get it up later tonight if he didn't.

Thanks for the continued feedback. A lot of this factored into our new plan for attack spells.
Post Reply