Priest discussion and feedback
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 5:33 pm
Hi, Halisera's player here. I thought I'd open this form to collate any feedback and discussion about priests, seeing as there was quite a bit of discussion about them from the armor changes thread, and this seemed like a better place to explore the topic.
I'll begin by offering my general observations of the class so far.
AR/DR progressions
Weapon: 3/4
Unarmed: 2/3
I was actually pleasantly surprised to see the class have a 3/4 progression. I briefly played a mage and a scout before settling into a priest. So, for reference, Mages have a 3/3 and scouts a 6/6, so a 4 in DR actually puts them in a nice median between a mage and a melee(ish) class. The AR seems about right to me, though I could see them also having a 2. But there is currently too much in the air at the moment - what with all the updates coming - to even begin tweaking Priests AR (or DR) progression, and I don't think it's really a problem where it's at now.
I'm going to guess that unarmed progressions are the same across the board for all classes, and that one would train it (most likely mages as the DR gains are the same) so they didn't have to carry around a weapon, and with a 2 it doesn't seem like it'd be a viable option for attack. Which is fine.
An idea though: set priests to have 2/4 UC, 3/3 CC. I say this because it'd allow for a subtle difference between RP styles and how a character builds their priest. Do they forego weapons and make a more defensive priest, or practice CC and become more effective in combat? Granted, at 3/3 a priest's combat options are still limited - but then again, mechanically speaking, combat isn't the class' role. For those characters who want, say, a battleaxe wielding harbinger of doom priest, they'd likely be more interested in getting that AR, and the Templar class would probably better suit such a playstyle. As I said before though, I think there's too much going on to even consider altering something like that, so I'm just musing out loud.
Prayers
Currently, my arsenal of prayers fits what I expected a healing class to have. Health and stamina healing, along with a buff, and an equalizer (revoke: to remove buffs on enemies, or debuffs on allies - if they exist/when debuffs are added. I haven't seen any). I brighten to see curses added to the priest's utility belt, though I'm not sure yet what kind of effects they have.
Mechanically speaking, I see the priests as the healing class, but also as the main support class, meaning I think they should have more buffs as well as the Curse debuffs added to their class skills down the road. So 'Blessings' and 'Curses' to aid allies or hinder enemies - all in exchange for their stunted damage output.
I can't comment much on failure / success rates, but it seems sometimes that I fall in to a failing groove, where my prayers will fail 5 times or more in a row before returning to a more normal fail/success rate. It seems to happen every so often when it just gets caught in a fail block, so I'm not sure if that's something odd in the mathematics of the code or not.
Armor and priests
Since this was brought up in the Armor thread, I figured I'd open up some discussion for it here.
Personally, I don't think Armor detracts from the value of a priest, as long as the protection values don't skyrocket too high. Some skills rise stamina, but I haven't seen one that rises HP, so characters will always have a finite health reserve even as enemies grow stronger. From the armor post, Nikolas said someone got hit for 35 from a vampire, so perhaps there will be, say, "sandworms" that hit a character for 40, or 50. Even at 50% reduction, that's 20 - 25 damage each hit, out of a reserve of 185 (for elves - less or more for other races). At an average of 20 dmg per hit, that's 10 rounds you could survive at minimum, misses or defensive blocks aside, meaning you'd better be able to kill the worm in 9 hits before you have to flee.
I understand that protection values that are 'too high' is a matter of perspective, but that's a mechanic I think should be discussed in the armor thread Nikolas restarted so we keep the two topics separate.
Anyway. New or old armor values, I don't think it has much impact on a priest's utility in a group. Of course, without a group, we can't hunt in many places for doubloons, but I'll talk about this more in my next section.
Speaking of...
The Priest's Moolah
I, too, have noticed the means of income for priests is stunted by the fact that we can't really hunt well in a place we can't utilize our holy strike or turn, and I count only three hunting areas for that: Skeletons, Crypts, and vampires. The training curve isn't so bad from Skeletons to the crypts. I was able to effectively hunt in the crypts when I reached 10 heal, 5 strike, 10 CC, and 10 turn, which wasn't hard to get to. After repair costs, I was making around 500 doubloons every few hours, and I'd likely make more if I just attacked using Holy Strike instead of turning first (But turn also raises a priest's stamina, so I like to train that up too :3). From what I've noticed, however, it's going to take a long moment from now before I can effectively hunt at Vampires, so I'll be staying at crypts while other characters move on to more lucrative hunting grounds.
---SIDE NOTE---
So this is interesting to consider: having turn raise my stamina makes me want to use it more. Kind of a 'duh' thing to consider, but what I think the take away here is that positive reinforcement works better than punishment. Take Elder Scrolls as an example. In Oblivion, wearing armor gave you less spell efficiency, which is the way games normally balance spell casters. But that's boring and chokes individuality. So what'd they do to fix it? Let let characters wear all the armor they wanted, but gave them an incentive to not wear armor. Mage robes increased magic recovery, and, at times, reduced their casing costs. It gave mage-style characters a reason to not wear armor, instead of punishing them for wearing it. It was a refreshing mechanic to see, and I think aspects of that kind of class balancing could be used in Shattered Isles going forward to make for an interesting and unique game.
---/SIDE NOTE---
So, if not hunting for coin, then what? Crating seems to currently be the only reliable means of income for priests, and it seems to be what most players are focusing on now. Unfortunately, we can't utilize our skills that way, but that's the same for any class during ccrafting as it doesn't seem to be combat intensive. However, for those priests who don't want to have a crafting aspect to their RP, and who don't think they make enough from hunting, I'm not sure what else there is. I guess you could always send the offering basket around at temple meetings.
Thing is, though, priests don't have a lot they mechanically need to spend money on. The best armor or weapon doesn't help us heal better. Granted, the better the armor, the better we stay alive, which is only a plus, but it's not as critical to a priest because we can heal away the pain. A shiny weapon isn't a bother either mainly because a bone dagger or a death blade with both give us the full 4 DR per level, and seeing as we'd likely need double the levels to be on par with a melee class, attacking doesn't seem to be the rout we'd take in battle, not when we'd be busy healing anyway. A better weapon may help us hunt better, true, and help offset our steep hunting curve, but it's still not apart of the class' core mechanics. Now, that aside, we still want to buy shinny stuff for our characters for RP reasons, and that's well and good, but speaking strictly mechanically, steel-grade weapons and armor would likely suit our purposes just fine. Armor, as I said, is a slight exception to this, as it increases our survivability and allows us to be a sort of tank; couple better armor with better weapons and we can hunt better, which is a plus, true, but it still won't help us heal better. There's an idea though: 'weapons' that improve some aspect of the 'casting' classes. But that's neither here nor there right now.
If we're patient enough to wait for custom orders, we could likely just order the weapon/armor that we needed. I'm guessing armor and weapon orders are few and far in between, so we should have plenty of time, even hunting just in the crypts, and even if no crafting is involved, to raise money to purchase a custom piece.
All that to say even though we have a stunted doubloon intake, it doesn't appear that we particularly need all that many doubloons - at least the doubloons necessary to out bid someone at a peddle for that one weapon / armor piece we need to improve how our class functions. This is all perspective though, I know, and it does kinda stink not to have the same, smooth hunting ground graduation as the other classes. But that stems from not being able to do damage, which is a necessary counterweight to healing, I think, so it might have to be something that we live with as a class, and knowingly trade for the power to restore.
Thanks for reading if you got all the way through! These are just my thoughts, and I'd like to know how other priests - or anyone, really - see the class developing in the context of Shattered Isles.
Thank you much!
Halisera's Player
I'll begin by offering my general observations of the class so far.
AR/DR progressions
Weapon: 3/4
Unarmed: 2/3
I was actually pleasantly surprised to see the class have a 3/4 progression. I briefly played a mage and a scout before settling into a priest. So, for reference, Mages have a 3/3 and scouts a 6/6, so a 4 in DR actually puts them in a nice median between a mage and a melee(ish) class. The AR seems about right to me, though I could see them also having a 2. But there is currently too much in the air at the moment - what with all the updates coming - to even begin tweaking Priests AR (or DR) progression, and I don't think it's really a problem where it's at now.
I'm going to guess that unarmed progressions are the same across the board for all classes, and that one would train it (most likely mages as the DR gains are the same) so they didn't have to carry around a weapon, and with a 2 it doesn't seem like it'd be a viable option for attack. Which is fine.
An idea though: set priests to have 2/4 UC, 3/3 CC. I say this because it'd allow for a subtle difference between RP styles and how a character builds their priest. Do they forego weapons and make a more defensive priest, or practice CC and become more effective in combat? Granted, at 3/3 a priest's combat options are still limited - but then again, mechanically speaking, combat isn't the class' role. For those characters who want, say, a battleaxe wielding harbinger of doom priest, they'd likely be more interested in getting that AR, and the Templar class would probably better suit such a playstyle. As I said before though, I think there's too much going on to even consider altering something like that, so I'm just musing out loud.
Prayers
Currently, my arsenal of prayers fits what I expected a healing class to have. Health and stamina healing, along with a buff, and an equalizer (revoke: to remove buffs on enemies, or debuffs on allies - if they exist/when debuffs are added. I haven't seen any). I brighten to see curses added to the priest's utility belt, though I'm not sure yet what kind of effects they have.
Mechanically speaking, I see the priests as the healing class, but also as the main support class, meaning I think they should have more buffs as well as the Curse debuffs added to their class skills down the road. So 'Blessings' and 'Curses' to aid allies or hinder enemies - all in exchange for their stunted damage output.
I can't comment much on failure / success rates, but it seems sometimes that I fall in to a failing groove, where my prayers will fail 5 times or more in a row before returning to a more normal fail/success rate. It seems to happen every so often when it just gets caught in a fail block, so I'm not sure if that's something odd in the mathematics of the code or not.
Armor and priests
Since this was brought up in the Armor thread, I figured I'd open up some discussion for it here.
Personally, I don't think Armor detracts from the value of a priest, as long as the protection values don't skyrocket too high. Some skills rise stamina, but I haven't seen one that rises HP, so characters will always have a finite health reserve even as enemies grow stronger. From the armor post, Nikolas said someone got hit for 35 from a vampire, so perhaps there will be, say, "sandworms" that hit a character for 40, or 50. Even at 50% reduction, that's 20 - 25 damage each hit, out of a reserve of 185 (for elves - less or more for other races). At an average of 20 dmg per hit, that's 10 rounds you could survive at minimum, misses or defensive blocks aside, meaning you'd better be able to kill the worm in 9 hits before you have to flee.
I understand that protection values that are 'too high' is a matter of perspective, but that's a mechanic I think should be discussed in the armor thread Nikolas restarted so we keep the two topics separate.
Anyway. New or old armor values, I don't think it has much impact on a priest's utility in a group. Of course, without a group, we can't hunt in many places for doubloons, but I'll talk about this more in my next section.
Speaking of...
The Priest's Moolah
I, too, have noticed the means of income for priests is stunted by the fact that we can't really hunt well in a place we can't utilize our holy strike or turn, and I count only three hunting areas for that: Skeletons, Crypts, and vampires. The training curve isn't so bad from Skeletons to the crypts. I was able to effectively hunt in the crypts when I reached 10 heal, 5 strike, 10 CC, and 10 turn, which wasn't hard to get to. After repair costs, I was making around 500 doubloons every few hours, and I'd likely make more if I just attacked using Holy Strike instead of turning first (But turn also raises a priest's stamina, so I like to train that up too :3). From what I've noticed, however, it's going to take a long moment from now before I can effectively hunt at Vampires, so I'll be staying at crypts while other characters move on to more lucrative hunting grounds.
---SIDE NOTE---
So this is interesting to consider: having turn raise my stamina makes me want to use it more. Kind of a 'duh' thing to consider, but what I think the take away here is that positive reinforcement works better than punishment. Take Elder Scrolls as an example. In Oblivion, wearing armor gave you less spell efficiency, which is the way games normally balance spell casters. But that's boring and chokes individuality. So what'd they do to fix it? Let let characters wear all the armor they wanted, but gave them an incentive to not wear armor. Mage robes increased magic recovery, and, at times, reduced their casing costs. It gave mage-style characters a reason to not wear armor, instead of punishing them for wearing it. It was a refreshing mechanic to see, and I think aspects of that kind of class balancing could be used in Shattered Isles going forward to make for an interesting and unique game.
---/SIDE NOTE---
So, if not hunting for coin, then what? Crating seems to currently be the only reliable means of income for priests, and it seems to be what most players are focusing on now. Unfortunately, we can't utilize our skills that way, but that's the same for any class during ccrafting as it doesn't seem to be combat intensive. However, for those priests who don't want to have a crafting aspect to their RP, and who don't think they make enough from hunting, I'm not sure what else there is. I guess you could always send the offering basket around at temple meetings.
Thing is, though, priests don't have a lot they mechanically need to spend money on. The best armor or weapon doesn't help us heal better. Granted, the better the armor, the better we stay alive, which is only a plus, but it's not as critical to a priest because we can heal away the pain. A shiny weapon isn't a bother either mainly because a bone dagger or a death blade with both give us the full 4 DR per level, and seeing as we'd likely need double the levels to be on par with a melee class, attacking doesn't seem to be the rout we'd take in battle, not when we'd be busy healing anyway. A better weapon may help us hunt better, true, and help offset our steep hunting curve, but it's still not apart of the class' core mechanics. Now, that aside, we still want to buy shinny stuff for our characters for RP reasons, and that's well and good, but speaking strictly mechanically, steel-grade weapons and armor would likely suit our purposes just fine. Armor, as I said, is a slight exception to this, as it increases our survivability and allows us to be a sort of tank; couple better armor with better weapons and we can hunt better, which is a plus, true, but it still won't help us heal better. There's an idea though: 'weapons' that improve some aspect of the 'casting' classes. But that's neither here nor there right now.
If we're patient enough to wait for custom orders, we could likely just order the weapon/armor that we needed. I'm guessing armor and weapon orders are few and far in between, so we should have plenty of time, even hunting just in the crypts, and even if no crafting is involved, to raise money to purchase a custom piece.
All that to say even though we have a stunted doubloon intake, it doesn't appear that we particularly need all that many doubloons - at least the doubloons necessary to out bid someone at a peddle for that one weapon / armor piece we need to improve how our class functions. This is all perspective though, I know, and it does kinda stink not to have the same, smooth hunting ground graduation as the other classes. But that stems from not being able to do damage, which is a necessary counterweight to healing, I think, so it might have to be something that we live with as a class, and knowingly trade for the power to restore.
Thanks for reading if you got all the way through! These are just my thoughts, and I'd like to know how other priests - or anyone, really - see the class developing in the context of Shattered Isles.
Thank you much!
Halisera's Player