Page 1 of 1
Murderous Rage
Posted: Sun Apr 01, 2012 11:54 pm
by
was wondering if there is anything planned to make this skill a bit easier to level . I do understand the skill itself has some very good utility use for barbs, but in its current carnation gaining uses for it is murderously slow, and when you think about 100 levels of it. even if its something that should not be easily attainable shouldn't be a lifetime en-devour.
i was thinking maybe when you where in a state of rage, you could get 1 use everytime you effectivly attack a mob. though i don't know if that would make it to easy to work, though i don't think it would. although honestly even after thinking about it for a long peroid of time i am drawing a blank on effective solutions that also wouldn't make the skill to easy or break it. cause i also know it wouldn't do much good being able to stop it, would just make it to easy to PT.
so any suggestions from folks? just would like to think of other ideas people might have
Re: Murderous Rage
Posted: Mon Apr 02, 2012 3:06 am
by
I pointed out the same thing a while back and as far as I understand, the plan is to make Rage work a bit like the battle cries; have it run out if you're out of combat for a short period of time.
You are right about it being virtually untrainable in its current implementation; I'm essentially using it non-stop, but especially after success rates got a boost, my rage has been stuck at level 7.
Re: Murderous Rage
Posted: Mon Apr 02, 2012 10:06 am
by
I have been trying to decide if rage is even worth using. I am not sure if the benefits outweight the risks for using it at this time. I have only ever been killed by a MOB when I am enraged. Most of those instances could be attributed to user error but it does get frustrating all the same. Is there a damage boost for being enraged? If there is I have not noticed it.
Also, much like skills such as digging and chopping. In a sense it seems the higher you advance the more you are being punish by having a higher success rate. For leveling purposes, I would much rather have a low success rate because of the time that is consumed while you wait to finish chopping trees. Maybe we can get a use for every pulse on skills like this? The same system could be given to rage. Have it pulse and give us a use every pulse. I can only imagine how tedious something like digging will become to level when you start getting a successful dig nearly everytime. The added delay for waiting on top of the uses that will be needed will become insane.
Sorry if I derailed a bit there but the point I was trying to make is that I would like to see a system in place that could work for both rage and trade skills. A pulsing system w/uses seems like a good solution to both.
Re: Murderous Rage
Posted: Mon Apr 02, 2012 11:03 am
by
no worries about the derail, and i do know the use system is getting an overhaul. even though use wise it slows down from the success. for the raising of other skills i don't mind as they are pretty darn resource heavy and time consuming it's nice to actually get the resources you need. and things being in alpha phase i am already prepared for things changing at the drop of a dime, just a matter of when are overworked coders get a chance to implement the changes.
and honestly i really enjjoy the changes, being able to enjoy the game and see it evolving and changing and being shaped by staff and players is really exciting for me. which is why i always try and find out peoples thoughts and ideas about various things
Re: Murderous Rage
Posted: Mon Apr 02, 2012 11:09 am
by
although i will say i feel murderous rage is worth working, the HP boost and attack boost is pretty impressive. although it is a bit easier for me to work it because of my higher level CC skill
Re: Murderous Rage
Posted: Mon Apr 02, 2012 1:04 pm
by
For what it's worth, I will say I would rather have the current system than nothing at all. This is a far cry better than other games I have played.
That being said and to get back to rage. I have limited levels in rage so perhaps my opinion will change when I get it a bit higher. Right now I get +40 HP and +25 AR and -25 DR. I am just as successful hunting with rage as I am without rage. In fact, I would hazard to say I am better off not using rage because I have less downtime healing and re-vigoring but of course, I do appreciate the added first aid uses I rack up when using rage. I'm quite certain first aid will become invaluable to me at higher levels.
Re: Murderous Rage
Posted: Mon Apr 02, 2012 7:43 pm
by
I don't know what the new system will have, but I think having rage be passive to kick in (like parry or shield block) and base kicking in on how hurt you are (the higher the rage level the less hurt you have to be), and then let rage be it's own combat skill would work. Instead of getting rage uses and close combat uses you just get rage uses when enraged, and ranged or close combat uses when out of rage.
What I never liked (and was guilty of myself) was pre-raging, having group members beat you silly until rage kicked in, I don't know what system can prevent players from doing that, other than their own RPing integrity!
Re: Murderous Rage
Posted: Mon Apr 02, 2012 10:06 pm
by
A slight variation on the system MsMaibe describes --
How about rage not acting like a multi-round / timer-based 'buff' but acts on single hits, just like parry and block do (on hits you deal rather than receive though, for obvious reasons)? Have it increase damage and/or the chance of a critical hit, and correlate the chance of success with the relative (or absolute) amount of damage sustained?
This would mean you don't get the temporary hitpoints, but those are a farce as is anyway as you lose the temporary hitpoints you gained when your rage fades. Right now they only serve as a relatively small bonus to the buffer your healer has to fill up.
The correlation with sustained damage (note how I very specifically avoid saying "remaining hitpoints") would also mean barbarians have an incentive to go 'all out' and not run away to heal as soon as they get hurt; if they channel the rage getting hit generates, like the stereotypical barbarian is wont to do, their damage output can increase because of rage kicking in more often.
By not making rage a (briefly) persisting buff, group members have no incentive to bash you up before a fight. At most, the healers have one not to bother patching you up as carefully. If whatever you're hunting doesn't bash you up fast enough to get you in a range where your rage starts kicking in 'reliably', you probably don't need a group to hunt it.
EDIT: The implementation suggested above also conveniently crops the defense rating debuff. I'm not sure how fair or balanced this is, even though the suggestion nerfs Murderous Rage's Temporary HPs too. I tried to come up with further defense penalties, but came up blank as I don't know where the combat system's going to go and what will happen to attack and defense scores in its new incarnation... Perhaps it'd be better to see what the new combat system is like as a platform to build skills and complexities upon, before diving head-over-heels into cool things to build onto it.