Page 1 of 1
Goblins: Do they have a chance?
Posted: Wed Apr 04, 2012 3:46 pm
by
Since the beginning, we've had it in minds that goblins would be included in the list of playable races. However, when I think playable, I tend to think "able to coexist." Judging by the current goblin help file, they've lived difficult lives and have learned to adapt to it. They are not pranksters, but are rather cunning and clever instead. They are considered outcasts or "bad guys," which has me wondering just how does one live and shop in the academy as a little green student?
I've seen other games where goblins were killed immediately upon sight, but that isn't something we want to do here. Should we "ban" them from the academy and force them to live difficult lives?
Any and all thoughts would be appreciated.
Re: Goblins: Do they have a chance?
Posted: Thu Apr 05, 2012 9:01 am
by
TL;DR: I need more Lore to make Shatteres Isles-specific comments on Goblins and their feasibility as a player race.
Based on what I've read so far, I haven't really got a very clear image of where exactly Goblins figure into the bigger picture. They sided with Itzal during the Shattering, but they're on 'coexisting' terms with Pyrous by now. Aside from that, I don't really know much of anything about them. More Lore would definitely help shape an image of what goblins are like in SI, and where they should stand as a playable race. Some questions that come to mind are, how did ALL goblins go in with Itzal's wager, and what exactly did it entail? Is there some goblin king that decided to go for it, automatically binding an entire race already following 4 different gods to do an up-and-coming 5ths bidding? If so, did religion play a smaller role in the life of your average goblin than their race did before and during the events leading up to the Shattering? If not so, what
did happen between 'now' and 'then' that caused all but Pyrous to turn their backs on them?
In more traditional fantasy settings, goblins are typically a 'lesser race' of weak-willed, easily manipulated, physically
and intellectually inferior cretins with a predisposition towards conniving and backhandedness. Many cookie-cutter RPGs will present goblins as (one of) the first dime-a-dozen NPCs you get to kill until a) there's none left, b) there's nothing left to gain from killing them or c) you get bored with bashing buttons. They're usually right up there next to the rats and slimes. In fact, their role as the cliché idiot baddies is so well-established there's a relatively succesful webcomic dedicated to it.
(Suitably titled Goblins, of course.)
That said, it seems SI opts for a different take on the miniature greenskins. While they're still classically diminutive in physique, it seems they're less mentally incapable than their cannon fodder cousins found in other fantasy realms.
(Off topic: how the hell is Barbarian a valid class for something hardly tall enough to headbutt me in the knee? Moodswings, soit; they've got the mindset, but there's more to Barbarians than Just Being Really Angry, like some brawn to back it up.) However, without more information about their race's history, or even the history of the world as a whole, I can't add anything to this thread beyond the observations above.
How can one consider how to treat an entire race if little to naught is known about them? As sung by Corey Taylor; "I won't control or restrain things I do not understand."
EDIT: Maybe
this Goblins comic can help?
Re: Goblins: Do they have a chance?
Posted: Thu Apr 05, 2012 12:16 pm
by
Perhaps the original question was not clear enough. The reason we are opening this up to the community is because we are at a difficult place with our Goblin lore. I've seen the role-play of goblins run into the ground. I've followed it through two games that a large portion of our playerbase will come from, and I want to prevent it from spreading here. So we're asking you, how do you make a goblin fit into society as a functioning piece? What makes them valuable to any hunting party?
I think the cleverness of a goblin has been lost. I want to see that restored here. People have associated chaotic with Goblins for so long that just being disruptive for the sake of being disruptive has become "acceptable" behavior. This is your chance to help us shape goblins and explain why they are the way they are.
As for why Goblins switched to Itzal and what the wager was... that's really up for you to decide as well. It's like a magic trick. If I told you how it worked, it wouldn't be as interesting. What do YOU think every goblin would want so badly that they'd ditch all the other religions to gain it? What could Itzal promise them? Do modern day goblins even know what the original wager was for, or have they twisted it into their own version of what they'd ask for in the same situation?
Also, what about Goblins would make them desirable to Itzal in the first place? They had to have had some value.
These are the questions we need help answering so that we can better define their history and their RP.
Re: Goblins: Do they have a chance?
Posted: Thu Apr 05, 2012 12:43 pm
by
I can see plenty that goblins would bring to the table as far as a race depending on their inherient class. my only thought is the way that the academy is structured and set up. i think any of the more eviler folk, and those that are less then law abiding won't be able to prosper in a rigidly law structured place like the academy.
on the surface the academy is just that, an academy run by the ATC. probably to help raise its own power by shaping and influencing those that go through its doors and the like. there would have to be like an underbelly to it, like the part of the academy that gets a blind eye turned towards it where the people who will shape the assassins, thiefs, spies etc of the ATC are training. just from the way things have played out in game so far i see it hard fully intergrating such races/classes into the academy itself without severe RP disruptions to the already established ethics code that has been established.
though any kingdom or large entity knows the value of these underhanded and more chaotic beings. everything after all has its uses. perhaps a secret area within the sewers, or following the RP that is being done in overlast can create an area for these less then deseriables.
though i just don't see the academy as a place that has been set as a neutral stomping ground, where all are welcome. the ATC has an established front they need to feign, looking at it from a worldly view they need to appease whatever ruling power resides over new archai, though at the same time i don't see something as large as the ATC overlooking the potential of Goblins and other less deseriables.
so i guess as i've already stated it would probably be easier to set up an area that is purposfuly overlooked by the powers of the ATC where these folk thrive and prosper. because I too would love to be able to see races like Goblins played out, and not just the chaotic nature of the race but the cleverness as well. something that has always been said about the goblin race, though never really used to its advantage.
Re: Goblins: Do they have a chance?
Posted: Thu Apr 05, 2012 1:52 pm
by
Could the solution be something as simple as not calling them Goblins? Perhaps just changing the name would be enough to ensure the race will not fall back on old role-playing habits. The old mindset of what is “acceptable” Goblin behavior could be reigned in if they are not associated with how we think Goblins should be viewed. I think regardless of how the lore falls into place, the old habits will emerge in the end. If they are not called Goblins the link that associates them with the old style of play will be broken.
Re: Goblins: Do they have a chance?
Posted: Thu Apr 05, 2012 3:13 pm
by
well the biggest problem i see is some of what Eirik pointed out, people assossiate by name. hense why the internet is named based and not based off the IP of different areas, its easier for people to remember the names. and as such any race that has a pre-manufactured history based on the lore of the creature itself, it becomes harder for the disassossiation to be made by people.
though i feel this is one of the fun aspects of RPing, granted it would be easier to change the name as some games do this. the race itself is for all intents and purposes something else, but to keep people from making that name to creature assossiation they simply change the name of the creature.