Page 1 of 1
Priestly Revoke prayer observation and a suggestion
Posted: Tue May 12, 2015 6:13 pm
by
I am sure I am not the only one who has noted that if a person has more than one active prayer on them, for example, Holy Shield and Disease Ward, and a priest is revoking prayers from said person, the prayers will get revoked, one per successful attempt, in the reverse order in which they were applied.
I would like to see the priest be able to revoke a specific prayer, regardless of which order the prayer(s) have been applied to the person.
For example, an opponent player has a Holy Shield up followed by a Disease Ward. I may not care if the Disease Ward remains but I do want to remove the Holy Shield. As it currently operates I would need to revoke the Disease Ward first, then follow up by revoking the Holy Shield.
Thoughts anyone?
Flynt's player
Re: Priestly Revoke prayer observation and a suggestion
Posted: Tue May 12, 2015 6:22 pm
by
Agreed. There's actually a slight advantage for priests right now due to how it's set up. I tried to dispel a priest's shield spell in the games, and instead got their disease ward. This gave me the idea to try doing similar with telepathy for mages, but it didn't work out. I think it was the duration was too low compared to shield. Not looking for a mages are OP versus priest discussion, btw.

Re: Priestly Revoke prayer observation and a suggestion
Posted: Thu May 14, 2015 5:12 pm
by
I like the idea and have added it to my list. Our current setup does not support this though so it will take some thought and reworking to make it a reality. As it stands now, it becomes a tactic to stack your spells and prayers in a protective order. Of course the cost of upkeep increases, but still a valid tactic.
One thing I'd like to change though is the ability of priests to revoke spells and mages to dispel prayers. This was an unintended side effect of these abilities. I really want to keep prayers and spells separate and not blur those lines. No other class can dispel a mage's spell and a priest shouldn't be any different. Likewise a mage shouldn't know how to revoke a prayer. I'll likely address this sometime this weekend with the next planned patch.
Thanks for the suggestion!
Re: Priestly Revoke prayer observation and a suggestion
Posted: Thu May 14, 2015 6:20 pm
by
I don't especially mind that priests can dispel mages, and vice-verse, but I understand the desire of having "separation" between those two classes. In that thought, is it possible to make it so that dispel levels actually mean anything in regard to dispelling? For example, Smacky the baby mage who does not know x spell, shouldn't be able to dispel x spell until he learns that spell himself.
There's a very large problem with levels not really meaning all that much in regard to casters v. casters. A lot of it is tied to the damage progression problems affecting both casters and melee, but I think it would add an extra depth of tactics to combat if countering certain things were accorded at requisite understanding of the thing being countered. Or maybe a normal dispel spell leads to more specialized dispelling that targets certain prayers/spells to offer that dynamic in combat.
Because prayers and spells have some overlap, revoke and dispel could each work against the overlapped spells like shield, but then if a mage wanted to dispel a priest's plague and a priest wanted to dispel a mage's slow, they'd each have to work up their normal dispel/revoke into that specialization (e.g., a new dispel/revoke working only against that spell/prayer unlocked at a higher level of normal dispel). As it is, abilities don't scale much in usefulness based on level aside from a slightly better success rate.
Re: Priestly Revoke prayer observation and a suggestion
Posted: Thu May 14, 2015 7:52 pm
by
For RP purposes, I’ve chosen to view the situation as both mage and priest are tapping the same power source in their own way and the ability to revoke or dispel is more of a disruption of the power, so the need to know or understand the spell or prayer isn’t necessary.
I like the current system, I think it allows both classes to be vulnerable to each other and brings more tactics into play, which I’m for.
And add 1 vote to SquallScribe’s ideas.
Re: Priestly Revoke prayer observation and a suggestion
Posted: Fri May 15, 2015 1:53 am
by
Great responses and I appreciate your ideas and thoughts.
I am not for adding specific revoke prayer(s) to work against specific prayer(s) being revoked. Way too much work.
I would much rather see the difficulty of the revoke be dependent on the ability of the two priests involved. For example, A priest at level 10 Revoke and level 10 Holy Shield will not find it very difficult to revoke Holy Shield that was prayed for by a Priest with level 8 Holy Shield, but would find it extremely difficult to revoke Holy Shield prayed for by a priest that is at level 30 Holy Shield.
I believe this idea would also work well for mages and their Dispel skill.
Flynt's Player