Warning: this is a long post of limited interest to most. Read at your peril.
At the last coffee with creators, there was some, quite vague, mention of changes to tracking. Before changes are set in stone, I'd like to present my, and my character's, understanding of what tracking is and how it works.
There are a number of oddities about tracking. First and foremost, the tracker-scout clearly does not need to rely upon clues from the physical environment to track a target. This is revealed by the fact that the target being tracked need not have been anywhere near the location at which the scout begins tracking. Aruskin the character began to notice this when he was tracking the muggers found along the roads east and north of Pearl. The muggers rarely entered Pearl, and then kept pretty close to the gate, but Aruskin found he could track them from Town Center, as well as from the Crypt. In fact, being on the road outside the gate did not seem to improve the chances of tracking a mugger. Further experiments involving tracking individuals confirmed the point--the scout and the target need not have "crossed paths" in order for the scout to successfully "lock onto" the target. From this, it is clear enough that clues from the physical environment are not needed to track something or someone. This point is clear both to the player and the character, i.e. it is something that can be learned in game.
A second oddity is that tracking leads the scout to a location, rather than to the target. When a scout tracks, he gets an initial lock onto the target's location, and is led step by step to that location. If the target moves from that location while the scout is tracking, the scout will not be led to the target's new location, even if that new location happens to be right next to the old location. Again, this is clear both to the player and the character. Aruskin has repeatedly tracked targets to a location, only to find that it has moved on from that location, often only a few feet.
A third oddity is that tracking can work only along a path that could, in principle, be walked by the scout. For instance, Aruskin cannot track Flynt or Xiija if they are in skyrooms--something he has tried repeatedly. However, Aruskin can track targets that are in or at the top of the Watcher's Tower. When he does so, he is led to the locked door at the bottom of the Tower, and "told" that the path to the target leads, not up the Tower, but through the locked door. Of course, no one enters the Tower through the door. When I tried this with Trystan, he pathed himself to the top of the Tower, but I was still led to the door and pointed through the door. Now, so long as that door is locked, I can't actually walk through it and up to the top of the Tower, but I could do so in principle--I just need someone to unlock the door. The directional impulse that takes the scout step-by-step towards the target must follow a path that the scout could walk. Aruskin calls this the rule of walking.
Each of these oddities has been noticed by Aruskin the character, and he has developed the outline of a theory to explain them. The first point--that the scout does not need clues from the natural environment in order to track a target--is the most important. Aruskin's theory is that he is somehow gaining access to some non-natural aspect of the environment, i.e. a magical or spiritual aspect of the environment. When he successfully accesses this magical/spiritual aspect of the environment--Aruskin thinks of it as a kind of field--and if the relation between Aruskin and the target allow for tracking, Aruskin is locked onto a location containing the target at that time, and led step-by-step to that location.
This much is, Aruskin believes, firmly established by experience and experiment. However, it does raise further questions. What is this non-natural "field" that is being accessed? How do scouts access it? Why do only scouts have access to it? And what about the other oddities: the tracking to location rather than target, the rule of walking, and, just to add one more, the step-by-step directional impulse? All Aruskin can do here is speculate. He has come up with a speculative story, albeit one for which evidence is almost impossible to come by.
Aruskin believes that, in learning and practicing tracking in the naturalistic sense, scouts develop a power of concentrating upon the environment with the aim of locating a target that, over time, generates a limited access to a magical or spiritual field associated with the locations of living creatures (Aruskin also suspects that this field may be restricted to New Archai). Non-scouts don't engage in this long disciplinary practice, so they never develop the skill of concentration needed to access this magical/spiritual field. Moreover, since the ability to access this field develops through practicing naturalistic tracking, force of habit or some sort of mental inertia results in the ability being tied in various ways to some, but not all, of the restrictions of naturalistic tracking. Hence the rule of walking--naturalistic tracking is pretty much a ground-bound activity, and this tends to carry over to magical/spiritual tracking. Naturalistic tracking also tends to be a point-to-point activity, moving along from one clue to the next. Hence the step-by-step directional impulse.
What of the oddity of tracking to a location, rather than to the target? As a player, I'm pretty sure this is because it would just be too difficult to code tracking to a moving target. For Aruskin the character, it is more of a puzzle. His guess, and it is only a guess, is that the force of concentration needed is such that the scout can only lock onto an initial location and follow that out to the end, without being able to notice through the "field" movement by the target.
Again, this story about how scouts access the magical/spiritual aspect of the environment that enables non-naturalistic tracking is almost purely speculation on Aruskin's part. It makes modest sense of what is known about tracking, but other explanations could do the same. What is almost certainly true is that scouts do access something magical or spiritual in tracking.
Regarding changes to tracking, my hope is that it does not get reduced to some set of naturalistic abilities. Tracking is currently about the only thing that really sets scouts apart from other classes, since bows are really just two-handed spears at this point. I've had a lot of fun trying to understand what tracking is and how it works, and the idea that it is at least partly magical/spiritual in a way unique to scouts adds greatly to the enjoyment of playing a scout.
--Aruskin.likesweirdthings
Tracking
Re: Tracking
I'd guess that it's some sort of divine power, likely given by Tetherias, the patron of scouts.
Re: Tracking
After reading through and pondering on the ideas:
As a living thing moves through the lands, they disturb or set up eddies/swirls (or resonences(sp)) in the natural essence of the world.
As you say, the scout has an innate 'tuning' ability that can sense to various degrees where that disturbance is at that exact moment of checking.
So... yea, I agree
As a living thing moves through the lands, they disturb or set up eddies/swirls (or resonences(sp)) in the natural essence of the world.
As you say, the scout has an innate 'tuning' ability that can sense to various degrees where that disturbance is at that exact moment of checking.
So... yea, I agree
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Tracking
My biggest beef was that it could be used to track someone disguised while using their real name. That part was too much potential for abuse, and I don't trust the average Joe to not take advantage when the opportunity presents itself.

Hierophant of Itzal
Re: Tracking
Since tracking is, at least in my interpretation, a semi-magical skill, I'm not sure that using it to track someone who happened to be in some sort of disguise would be an abuse. The character name is a game-mechanical way to allow the tracker to focus upon a specific character who would be presented as a presence to which the tracker is drawn step-by-step. That presence wouldn't necessarily change just because the character adopted a disguise.Shadowbane wrote:My biggest beef was that it could be used to track someone disguised while using their real name. That part was too much potential for abuse, and I don't trust the average Joe to not take advantage when the opportunity presents itself.
That said, yes, I can imagine ways in which tracking might be used to, in effect, nullify disguise, and agree that this would be a bad thing. However, we would need to get disguise really working in-game, and then see how things develop, before deciding upon the compatibility of the two skills, and what, if any, adjustments are needed.
--Aruskin
Re: Tracking
Thanks for the detailed feedback. This is exactly the sort of stuff I was looking for when I brought up the vague changes. It's not the mechanics of the skill that I disagree with, but it's evolved beyond the traditional tracking skill that is based on where someone has been and where they are going.
Tracking someone by their real name is a known issue that will be resolved when tracking cycles around for scheduled maintenance.
Tracking a flyer is something we purposely removed. I realize this is a bit tricky while we are stuck in limbo between technical tracking and whatever form of spiritual searching this is transforming into. There are no current plans to restore this as part of the skill.
The issue with tracking to someone's current location is two fold. Yes, there are coding limitations to set this to follow the target as they move (although you can reestablish your search at any time I believe), but we also like that there's some room for error. A chance for the target to keep running. The reworking of the skill will reflect this better in that whatever it is that you are locking onto is very much in that moment. It's a glimpse, a still photo, not a live stream of that target.
Feel free to keep the topic going. It's all good info that will factor into what tracking morphs into. (No nerfing planned in the reworking of this skill.)
Tracking someone by their real name is a known issue that will be resolved when tracking cycles around for scheduled maintenance.
Tracking a flyer is something we purposely removed. I realize this is a bit tricky while we are stuck in limbo between technical tracking and whatever form of spiritual searching this is transforming into. There are no current plans to restore this as part of the skill.
The issue with tracking to someone's current location is two fold. Yes, there are coding limitations to set this to follow the target as they move (although you can reestablish your search at any time I believe), but we also like that there's some room for error. A chance for the target to keep running. The reworking of the skill will reflect this better in that whatever it is that you are locking onto is very much in that moment. It's a glimpse, a still photo, not a live stream of that target.
Feel free to keep the topic going. It's all good info that will factor into what tracking morphs into. (No nerfing planned in the reworking of this skill.)
Re: Tracking
seems an easy fix for tracking names?
use the code that says .. if standingPosition (trackName) == Flying...tracking = FALSE
and change it to .... if disguiseName (trackName) = TRUE, tracking = FALSE.
etc etc, lol
X.
use the code that says .. if standingPosition (trackName) == Flying...tracking = FALSE
and change it to .... if disguiseName (trackName) = TRUE, tracking = FALSE.
etc etc, lol
X.

Re: Tracking
For most situations that works and we correct it when the reports come in about a skill or command blowing someone's disguise. There's a few instances though like tracking that call on something different and that's the issue. We've come a long way with protecting the identities of thieves and assassins and the playerbase has done a good job of not exploiting the loopholes that do exist.
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Tracking
If someone can articulate why Kaiah is disguised as Joe Snuffy, sure. But most times, people can't articulate why she is or isn't present for one thing or another, so I doubt they could explain why she's believed to be Joe.Since tracking is, at least in my interpretation, a semi-magical skill, I'm not sure that using it to track someone who happened to be in some sort of disguise would be an abuse.
If they are just saying they know she's Joe just because, I would call that abuse of OOC knowledge, simply because there's no way or reason for them to know. I say this because it's happened multiple times to me, largely because the playerbase is small and there's only a handful of us that can use mask or disguise.
Disguise IS working in game, at the moment. The only thing is that people just can't start pulling on someone's face to try to remove the disguise, which I'm in favor of, and the funky height limit they have going on (a ten foot tall goblin would be terrifying). Before you know it, some people would be pulling on every new player's face to see if it's a disguise.
Re: Tracking
Tracking currently leads to a location, not to a character. If Aruskin were tracking Kaiah, and were led to a location that did not contain Kaiah, the reasonable inference would be that Kaiah had moved on from the location. Another possibility would be that Kaiah was there, but hiding. Disguise would be a distant third possibility. Now, if this happened several times, and each time it happened Joe Snuffy was present while Kaiah was not, then it might make sense to suspect that Snuffy was Kaiah in disguise. I've yet to encounter a situation at all like this in game.Shadowbane wrote:If someone can articulate why Kaiah is disguised as Joe Snuffy, sure. But most times, people can't articulate why she is or isn't present for one thing or another, so I doubt they could explain why she's believed to be Joe.Since tracking is, at least in my interpretation, a semi-magical skill, I'm not sure that using it to track someone who happened to be in some sort of disguise would be an abuse.
If they are just saying they know she's Joe just because, I would call that abuse of OOC knowledge, simply because there's no way or reason for them to know. I say this because it's happened multiple times to me, largely because the playerbase is small and there's only a handful of us that can use mask or disguise.
Disguise IS working in game, at the moment. The only thing is that people just can't start pulling on someone's face to try to remove the disguise, which I'm in favor of, and the funky height limit they have going on (a ten foot tall goblin would be terrifying). Before you know it, some people would be pulling on every new player's face to see if it's a disguise.
It seems to me that your objection may be more to the way the WHO command works than it is to tracking.
--Aruskin