Skill system overhaul suggestion - Maceman
Posted: Mon Feb 22, 2016 10:19 am
As with all RPGs involving a skilling system, the player is required to do x action x amount of times until they level up.
Because of this system skill levels become highly unbalanced which causes an unrealistic level gap between players and constant, senseless farming.
My suggestion?
A more logical and roleplay-required advancement system.
One that promotes roleplay and removes unneeded and extensive "Grinding" that ruins roleplay.
Remove classes: Your actions, skills and roleplay define your character's "Class"
"If you wish to be good at a skill then you need to be educated by another via roleplay and training."
This gives true meaning to the academy and creates a system where players are taking apprentices and forming bonds, creating groups, businesses and clans.
Retiring your character? "Nonexistent" Permadeath due to story arc? Your apprentice can continue your legacy!
Realistic businesses and clans can be created this way, guild masters, a master in that specific skill can train others!
"But what about the problem where someone with enough time can master everything!?"
Simple, the amount of ranks you can have is limited to your intelligence points.
A normal human should have at least 10 intelligence points.
Anyone has the option to forget ranks via command.
"The Academy grants you one skill of your choice to be Educated in when you arrive."
Untrained: Has no training in this skill and minimal knowledge.
(Everyone starts here)
Trained: Has minimal training in this skill, but no formal education.
(Has become an apprentice of another Character and was trained)
Educated: Has been formally and officially trained in this skill.
(Has been formally and further trained by another Character)
Proficient: Has extensive training and education in this skill.
(Gained through unlocking traits by training others)
Mastered: Has officially mastered this skill and can educate others.
(Has unlocked all trainable traits in the skill)
Preeminent Skills: Rare traits within skills that are not gained alongside training.
(Can be gained through a great accomplishment or story related event/godly boon)
Mastered Rank and Preeminent Skills are primarily gained through taking apprentices and ranking them up.
Skills: Blacksmithing(Weapons, Armor and Smithing), Carpentry, Alchemy, Botany, Fighting, Marksmanship, Magic, Finesse(Rogue skills), Athletics(Anything movement), Prayer(Divine Magic).ect
Ranks: Level of the skill
Traits: Learnable actions within a rank
Things like Mining, Woodcutting, Farming and Foraging are too simple and common knowledge to be -Skills- but each skill has traits to improve these "Actions"
*How does this all work?
When you start out the Academy grants you Educated through a single skill of your choice.
To become Proficient you have to unlock a number of "traits" by training others. (Unlock does not mean you gain access to those traits, it means you will gain them upon ranking up)
To unlock traits you must apprentice someone until they rank up. (Each time they rank up you may choose one trait to unlock)
Each rank requires a certain amount of traits to be learned. (Usually based on %)
To train someone they must be in your party and they must be your apprentice, this allows you to give them access to certain traits of your choosing that you know.
*How do i learn a new Skill from scratch?
First, find someone that is at least Educated in the skill you're wanting to learn(Academy is a great place for this, looking on the forums for teachers is good too!)
Second, become their apprentice, while in their party and while also being their apprentice you have access to any trait they choose to give you.
Third, after using a number of traits for the first time you will rank up and gain each of those traits that you used permanently without needing to be in your master's party.
A Mastered Master can train anyone up to Proficient, but to become Mastered you must apprentice and train others.
What are everyone's thoughts on this system? Replacing the age old numbered skill and leveling system with something more stable(Easily balanced) and roleplay oriented?
This system is also one step forward to freeing people from "RPG Leveling" and into something more realistic and advanced that cant be cheesed out of!
Because of this system skill levels become highly unbalanced which causes an unrealistic level gap between players and constant, senseless farming.
My suggestion?
A more logical and roleplay-required advancement system.
One that promotes roleplay and removes unneeded and extensive "Grinding" that ruins roleplay.
Remove classes: Your actions, skills and roleplay define your character's "Class"
"If you wish to be good at a skill then you need to be educated by another via roleplay and training."
This gives true meaning to the academy and creates a system where players are taking apprentices and forming bonds, creating groups, businesses and clans.
Retiring your character? "Nonexistent" Permadeath due to story arc? Your apprentice can continue your legacy!
Realistic businesses and clans can be created this way, guild masters, a master in that specific skill can train others!
"But what about the problem where someone with enough time can master everything!?"
Simple, the amount of ranks you can have is limited to your intelligence points.
A normal human should have at least 10 intelligence points.
Anyone has the option to forget ranks via command.
"The Academy grants you one skill of your choice to be Educated in when you arrive."
Untrained: Has no training in this skill and minimal knowledge.
(Everyone starts here)
Trained: Has minimal training in this skill, but no formal education.
(Has become an apprentice of another Character and was trained)
Educated: Has been formally and officially trained in this skill.
(Has been formally and further trained by another Character)
Proficient: Has extensive training and education in this skill.
(Gained through unlocking traits by training others)
Mastered: Has officially mastered this skill and can educate others.
(Has unlocked all trainable traits in the skill)
Preeminent Skills: Rare traits within skills that are not gained alongside training.
(Can be gained through a great accomplishment or story related event/godly boon)
Mastered Rank and Preeminent Skills are primarily gained through taking apprentices and ranking them up.
Skills: Blacksmithing(Weapons, Armor and Smithing), Carpentry, Alchemy, Botany, Fighting, Marksmanship, Magic, Finesse(Rogue skills), Athletics(Anything movement), Prayer(Divine Magic).ect
Ranks: Level of the skill
Traits: Learnable actions within a rank
Things like Mining, Woodcutting, Farming and Foraging are too simple and common knowledge to be -Skills- but each skill has traits to improve these "Actions"
*How does this all work?
When you start out the Academy grants you Educated through a single skill of your choice.
To become Proficient you have to unlock a number of "traits" by training others. (Unlock does not mean you gain access to those traits, it means you will gain them upon ranking up)
To unlock traits you must apprentice someone until they rank up. (Each time they rank up you may choose one trait to unlock)
Each rank requires a certain amount of traits to be learned. (Usually based on %)
To train someone they must be in your party and they must be your apprentice, this allows you to give them access to certain traits of your choosing that you know.
*How do i learn a new Skill from scratch?
First, find someone that is at least Educated in the skill you're wanting to learn(Academy is a great place for this, looking on the forums for teachers is good too!)
Second, become their apprentice, while in their party and while also being their apprentice you have access to any trait they choose to give you.
Third, after using a number of traits for the first time you will rank up and gain each of those traits that you used permanently without needing to be in your master's party.
A Mastered Master can train anyone up to Proficient, but to become Mastered you must apprentice and train others.
What are everyone's thoughts on this system? Replacing the age old numbered skill and leveling system with something more stable(Easily balanced) and roleplay oriented?
This system is also one step forward to freeing people from "RPG Leveling" and into something more realistic and advanced that cant be cheesed out of!