[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • First impressions, one week in.
Page 1 of 1

First impressions, one week in.

Posted: Mon Apr 11, 2016 7:49 am
by
Well, I've been playing about a week now. I'm still out on Academy Island. However, sometimes these first impressions are useful. So, I thought I would keep track of my thoughts, in case they are useful. If they're not useful, feel free to ignore them.

Please keep in mind... they are only first impressions. As I learn more, often these impressions are proven wrong or I understand how it should be. These are just my raw thoughts:

* The pace of the mud is nice. In the academy, it almost feels like a forest retreat.
* There should be a default colorset, which should not be almost entirely white. My first impression of the game was very bland. Also, colors really need added to equipment. I understand materials need to be colorless, but EQ should have some flare.
* I was expecting base CoffeeMud crafting system. However, when I found that I could not view the skill tree, I knew things would be different.
* Not being able to view the skill tree is frustrating. How long do I have to forage before I get a new skill? When does my next new skill come? My only chance is to attempt to reach level X and hope I get something new.
* So now I'm carrying around 150 lbs of foraged goods. So.... what do I do with these? I can't cook them all!
* Why is salt so precious of a commodity? Can't I boil beans without salt?
* I really want a mapper. I have the .jpg maps and it's pretty easy to navigate. However, being able to see where I am on the map would be so very useful. However, the forums indicate that the best mapers are buggy because we can't get the room ids (vnums). That, to me, seems like a glaring hole in the code. GMCP, ATCP, or MSDP... any of these protocols is so, so, so needed.
-- OK, I found the mapper, but shouldn't this be in a github repository somewhere? And without MSDP, we'll see how good this one is...
-- (Actually, not too bad. Needs some polish, but not bad at all...)
* Spinning up a new character is a very slow effort. However, I sense that this is just a game that has slow progression. Still, to get wood chopping, I have to have foraging at level 5. Thats...1000 uses / 3 = 300 forages. That's very very slow.
* So, I start cooking something, my fire goes out, and my ingredients disappear? Hmmm... odd.
* Abundance of gold is very low at the start of the game. Gathering 192 credits for a hatchet took nearly an RL day's work.
* The fact that I can walk out of a room in the middle of a fight... Kind of surprising.
* My last mud was RP-rich. I miss being able to emote quotation marks such as:
emote nods thoughtfully and says, "That is an interesting idea you are proposing," while puffing his pipe.
* I miss being able to add my name into the middle of an emote, such as:
emote Chuckling slightly, $n says, "Well, let's not get carried away."
emote ^g$n nods, "^wWhile powerful, some things are worth providing.^g"
* Academy island is huge... Either it's too big or the rest of the world is massive. However, if salt is only found on academy island, then I'm guessing it's too large. Some of these areas should probably be moved to mainland... but then again, I've never left the island. :)
* I finally used the "Commands" command. Umm... wow. There are so few commands here. Yet, such a rich environment. Most muds have more socials than this one has commands. *eyebrow* *hmm*

So, take them as you will. They are my raw thoughts as I had them.

Re: First impressions, one week in.

Posted: Mon Apr 11, 2016 10:44 am
by
I'll allow someone more qualified to address your questions, these are a bit too technical for me but I'd like to take a moment and welcome you to the game.

One thing I feel confident enough to comment on is the skill tree concern that you mentioned. The staff has told us a more complete skill tree will be made available soon. The reason nothing official has been made public at this time is because they are still tweaking things like what level certain skills get unlocked and what skills unlocks them.

I know there are several players around that can share with you their unofficial lists of where certain skills get unlocked. I do not use trade skills all that much, so I doubt I will be much help in that regard.

Re: First impressions, one week in.

Posted: Mon Apr 11, 2016 10:58 am
by
I find that the island is sufficiently small, it seems larger than it is.
Including all the roadways and secret areas i have discovered it is only about 700 rooms total.
That's with 10-11 hunting areas and a town.

Keep in mind that there are some challenges there that are likely not intended to be completed until later in life as well.

Re: First impressions, one week in.

Posted: Mon Apr 11, 2016 12:19 pm
by
Typing colorset will open up the world of color to you.
The skill tree is somewhat intuitive, wood carving from chopping, etc.
The skill progression is slow, there’s no way to get around that, hopefully this creates more unique skill sets for the PC’s because of the needed focus.
Your earnings per hour / gold picks up quickly.
The emote command won’t allow you to put in quotes. You can string an emote with quotes though, ie. Gesture and says, “Hi there.”
The HELP command is your best friend. Even if you don’t get exactly what you want, it will direct you in the right direction.
Welcome to SI!

Re: First impressions, one week in.

Posted: Mon Apr 11, 2016 7:35 pm
by
galaban wrote:Well, I've been playing about a week now. I'm still out on Academy Island. However, sometimes these first impressions are useful. So, I thought I would keep track of my thoughts, in case they are useful. If they're not useful, feel free to ignore them.

Please keep in mind... they are only first impressions. As I learn more, often these impressions are proven wrong or I understand how it should be. These are just my raw thoughts:

* The pace of the mud is nice. In the academy, it almost feels like a forest retreat.
* There should be a default colorset, which should not be almost entirely white. My first impression of the game was very bland. Also, colors really need added to equipment. I understand materials need to be colorless, but EQ should have some flare.
* I was expecting base CoffeeMud crafting system. However, when I found that I could not view the skill tree, I knew things would be different.
* Not being able to view the skill tree is frustrating. How long do I have to forage before I get a new skill? When does my next new skill come? My only chance is to attempt to reach level X and hope I get something new.
* So now I'm carrying around 150 lbs of foraged goods. So.... what do I do with these? I can't cook them all!
* Why is salt so precious of a commodity? Can't I boil beans without salt?
* I really want a mapper. I have the .jpg maps and it's pretty easy to navigate. However, being able to see where I am on the map would be so very useful. However, the forums indicate that the best mapers are buggy because we can't get the room ids (vnums). That, to me, seems like a glaring hole in the code. GMCP, ATCP, or MSDP... any of these protocols is so, so, so needed.
-- OK, I found the mapper, but shouldn't this be in a github repository somewhere? And without MSDP, we'll see how good this one is...
-- (Actually, not too bad. Needs some polish, but not bad at all...)
* Spinning up a new character is a very slow effort. However, I sense that this is just a game that has slow progression. Still, to get wood chopping, I have to have foraging at level 5. Thats...1000 uses / 3 = 300 forages. That's very very slow.
* So, I start cooking something, my fire goes out, and my ingredients disappear? Hmmm... odd.
* Abundance of gold is very low at the start of the game. Gathering 192 credits for a hatchet took nearly an RL day's work.
* The fact that I can walk out of a room in the middle of a fight... Kind of surprising.
* My last mud was RP-rich. I miss being able to emote quotation marks such as:
emote nods thoughtfully and says, "That is an interesting idea you are proposing," while puffing his pipe.
* I miss being able to add my name into the middle of an emote, such as:
emote Chuckling slightly, $n says, "Well, let's not get carried away."
emote ^g$n nods, "^wWhile powerful, some things are worth providing.^g"
* Academy island is huge... Either it's too big or the rest of the world is massive. However, if salt is only found on academy island, then I'm guessing it's too large. Some of these areas should probably be moved to mainland... but then again, I've never left the island. :)
* I finally used the "Commands" command. Umm... wow. There are so few commands here. Yet, such a rich environment. Most muds have more socials than this one has commands. *eyebrow* *hmm*

So, take them as you will. They are my raw thoughts as I had them.
I can answer a few others for you.

All of the stuff you forage can either be sold to players who cook, you can use them to cook, or you can just toss them.

Crafting is like a really time consuming second project for most people. We do have a few players who do nothing but craft though, so it's possible. Most normal skills are pretty easy to train. The game is slow paced I guess, but I've played other MUDs like DragonRealms, where you'd be lucky to max a character in 4 years, so I guess this isn't bad in comparison.

Skill trees will be available in a few months. They avoided putting them out, because the combat/crafting/magic system are all changing, so they won't be accurate. Some of the players have put out lists for certain classes and professions, but some like to keep them a secret for whatever reason.

Salt is pretty easy to get, you get a lot of it when you mine for it, unlike gems and ores. Sure, you COULD cook without salt, but it wouldn't be as good. If your fire goes out, it basically spoils your attempt at making the food, which is why all the stuff poofs. You can use the fire in the INN to have a source that will never go out.

The mapper in MUSH works pretty well, though I don't know what client you use.

The money in the academy is pretty bad, but once you move on to Pearl, it will pick up dramatically. Blink also runs hunts every week, all levels can attend and it's an even split across the board. It's a really good way for new players to get coin!

Being able to leave a room is basically the "flee" command from most other games, execpt you can just move and not have to bother with spamming FLEE if you're in trouble. At some point the monsters will chase you, depending on the area and aggressiveness of the monsters. But that will be put in sometime later.

You can still do all of those things emote wise, it's just a different way of doing it. Trystan provided some examples. You can put anything after any social command as well, in order to spice it up. Some players have them used automatically when they use the command. It's really up to you.

There could probably be more social commands, but you can really cover a lot of them from the emote and other social commands. I would like to see more though. I'm sure they are coming. *raising your eyebrow is just "raise" and to raise your hand, it's "raise hand"*

The game itself is actually very small when you compare it to a lot of the other, older MUDs out there. In DragonRealms, it would literally take you a RL hour to walk to far away places. Talk about absurd. I think once you get everything mapped out, you'll notice it's not all that big. I believe there's an auto-walker floating around somewhere for one of the mappers as well, if you don't want to walk or have a translocate spell.

Edit: This is the only 1 of 2 MUD's that I've played where you can custom design your own armor and items to exactly fit your character. They have peddles every so often to do this and your temple members will usually spot you some funds to get whatever you want.

Re: First impressions, one week in.

Posted: Mon Apr 11, 2016 7:57 pm
by
All valid observations, really. The color thing would be a nice and probably simple change to start, though I'm fine with non-colored equipment.

As for the crafting, it's definitely unusual! I pretty much do nothing but craft while I'm here, and normally you can find me in the Black Heart Tavern on Academy Isle, where I try to help new players get acclimated to the system and give them a chance to meet some people and learn about the world. I've been busy this week though, and mining for gems on the mainland, so I haven't had much chance to get back there. Sounds like you're already getting used to some of the nuances, but I'd still be happy to answer any questions should you run into Coraleth.

One last note on the emotes: "double" quotations don't work, but 'single' quotations do. Not as nice as I would like, but at least it is functional for the longer emote-chats if you want them.

Also, welcome to Shattered Isles~

Re: First impressions, one week in.

Posted: Mon Apr 11, 2016 9:16 pm
by
galaban wrote:Well, I've been playing about a week now. I'm still out on Academy Island. However, sometimes these first impressions are useful. So, I thought I would keep track of my thoughts, in case they are useful. If they're not useful, feel free to ignore them.

Please keep in mind... they are only first impressions. As I learn more, often these impressions are proven wrong or I understand how it should be. These are just my raw thoughts:
Thank you very much for taking the time to provide this feedback. We take it all into consideration when making changes and future decisions.

Re: First impressions, one week in.

Posted: Tue Apr 12, 2016 6:35 am
by
Snaek wrote:Thank you very much for taking the time to provide this feedback. We take it all into consideration when making changes and future decisions.
Oh, sure thing. Don't weight it too heavily, though. After all, I'm still playing! :) Granted, I'm still on Academy Island, but I'm seriously considering leaving the island... maybe tomorrow, perhaps.