The Physics of Miracles
Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2016 12:53 pm
[From the perspective of Eroan Weepingstone, Water Mage of no particular repute]
Few things in life fascinate me anymore, beyond a humble interest in physics. I remain boyishly interested the natural law of magic and miracles, and have developed some reasoned opinions about the laws of supernature.
Let us, for the moment, put aside moralism to a point. Though I am sure everyone can agree on the debased nature of the rites of Pyrous, we do not need to spend much ink discussing their fallen aspect or dreadful character. Their priests are capable of calling down miracles despite all that, and that in and of itself raises a question: if godliness is not a product of virtue, then what necessarily is it? If the saint and the villain are both calling down what appears to be the same manifestations, we can no longer comfort us in saying the world cares very much about the justice of it all.
Consider a second problem. A novice priest will fail as often as succeed in producing a manifestation via their prayers, even in their most dire hour of need. Once again, the stories we tell ourselves respecting the gods seem to lead us astray from reality. Either, by way of example, Astraeva is fickle with regards to healing the sick and needy... or she is not, in any great sense, aware of the need.
This leads to what I regard as the soft problem of divinity, that by a layman's interpretation of events (prayers are answered by gods) the gods seem... not very attentive or particularly useful to the common man. After all, we are then saying that the gods care more about a villain's unjust but properly executed malediction than a commoner's soulful cry for help.
I propose to solve this dilemma by revisiting the nature of miracles, in light of the facts that we find ourselves in possession of.
Let us first gather up the facts in an orderly fashion:
1) Succesfully invoking miracles through prayer occurs far, far more commonly among priests and templars than any other follower.
2) Among priests and templars, repetition improves the rate of a miracle manifesting.
3) The "corpus" of miracles does not appear to be greatly, if at all, differentiated by faith. For example, Astraeva can be called to produce disease, Pyrous to heal the sick.
4) With rare exceptions, the actual need or intrinsic virtue of the petitioner does not appear to have any bearing on the success of a miracle manifesting.
In light of which, I put forth the following:
There are two types of miracles, which I will describe as common and exceptional miracles.
The nature of a common miracle depends on the practice of the man performing it far more so than the god being called. The divine figure is either unaware or only partially aware of the precise circumstance of a miracle, insofar as they are unable (or unwilling) to make moral decisions based on virtue and need. Any description I give of them will sound rather much, to the trained ear, like conventional magic. In short, the priest attains a state of being in which they can draw down an insensate divine energy and shapes it according to rote and rites. Pyrous may prefer to burn the innocent alive, but the priest heals instead because Pyrous has no direct say or possibly even knowledge of the manifestation.
In the common miracle, it is the individual's will and connection to the divinity that has the directive influence on the result. In essence, the priest "takes" or "becomes" part of the divinity briefly to manifest the miracle. The god is not implicated in the results of the miracle except insofar as the priest is an ordained representative of the god. This can be understood much in the same way a lieutenent wields authority in the name of a master while the master is away.
The nature of the exceptional miracle is the kind more classically understood. The god, through mechanisms unknown, becomes aware of a situation and decides to intervene directly with full will and intention. There is no necessity for a priest in this case, simply a god motivated to employ godly powers toward any given end.
Unlike the common miracle, this remains fully in the hands of the divinity. This accounts for most of the truly spectacular and uncalled-for manifestations of godly might. These also give us insight into the actual drives and desires of the god in question.
By understanding the physics of miracles, one may begin to appreciate the wonderful complexity of our world and the forces that dwell herein. Where once there were huddled masses praying toward gods who could not give them heed, we now have priests performing miracles with empirically provable results. Further advancement in theoretical thaumaturgy can only benefit society by greater leaps and bounds.
Few things in life fascinate me anymore, beyond a humble interest in physics. I remain boyishly interested the natural law of magic and miracles, and have developed some reasoned opinions about the laws of supernature.
Let us, for the moment, put aside moralism to a point. Though I am sure everyone can agree on the debased nature of the rites of Pyrous, we do not need to spend much ink discussing their fallen aspect or dreadful character. Their priests are capable of calling down miracles despite all that, and that in and of itself raises a question: if godliness is not a product of virtue, then what necessarily is it? If the saint and the villain are both calling down what appears to be the same manifestations, we can no longer comfort us in saying the world cares very much about the justice of it all.
Consider a second problem. A novice priest will fail as often as succeed in producing a manifestation via their prayers, even in their most dire hour of need. Once again, the stories we tell ourselves respecting the gods seem to lead us astray from reality. Either, by way of example, Astraeva is fickle with regards to healing the sick and needy... or she is not, in any great sense, aware of the need.
This leads to what I regard as the soft problem of divinity, that by a layman's interpretation of events (prayers are answered by gods) the gods seem... not very attentive or particularly useful to the common man. After all, we are then saying that the gods care more about a villain's unjust but properly executed malediction than a commoner's soulful cry for help.
I propose to solve this dilemma by revisiting the nature of miracles, in light of the facts that we find ourselves in possession of.
Let us first gather up the facts in an orderly fashion:
1) Succesfully invoking miracles through prayer occurs far, far more commonly among priests and templars than any other follower.
2) Among priests and templars, repetition improves the rate of a miracle manifesting.
3) The "corpus" of miracles does not appear to be greatly, if at all, differentiated by faith. For example, Astraeva can be called to produce disease, Pyrous to heal the sick.
4) With rare exceptions, the actual need or intrinsic virtue of the petitioner does not appear to have any bearing on the success of a miracle manifesting.
In light of which, I put forth the following:
There are two types of miracles, which I will describe as common and exceptional miracles.
The nature of a common miracle depends on the practice of the man performing it far more so than the god being called. The divine figure is either unaware or only partially aware of the precise circumstance of a miracle, insofar as they are unable (or unwilling) to make moral decisions based on virtue and need. Any description I give of them will sound rather much, to the trained ear, like conventional magic. In short, the priest attains a state of being in which they can draw down an insensate divine energy and shapes it according to rote and rites. Pyrous may prefer to burn the innocent alive, but the priest heals instead because Pyrous has no direct say or possibly even knowledge of the manifestation.
In the common miracle, it is the individual's will and connection to the divinity that has the directive influence on the result. In essence, the priest "takes" or "becomes" part of the divinity briefly to manifest the miracle. The god is not implicated in the results of the miracle except insofar as the priest is an ordained representative of the god. This can be understood much in the same way a lieutenent wields authority in the name of a master while the master is away.
The nature of the exceptional miracle is the kind more classically understood. The god, through mechanisms unknown, becomes aware of a situation and decides to intervene directly with full will and intention. There is no necessity for a priest in this case, simply a god motivated to employ godly powers toward any given end.
Unlike the common miracle, this remains fully in the hands of the divinity. This accounts for most of the truly spectacular and uncalled-for manifestations of godly might. These also give us insight into the actual drives and desires of the god in question.
By understanding the physics of miracles, one may begin to appreciate the wonderful complexity of our world and the forces that dwell herein. Where once there were huddled masses praying toward gods who could not give them heed, we now have priests performing miracles with empirically provable results. Further advancement in theoretical thaumaturgy can only benefit society by greater leaps and bounds.