Economy

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Economy

Post by Creon »

It has occured to me after reviewing some old logs about the problems facing the devalue of the doubloon. One of the big issues it that a higher level player can sit and reap coin by killing lower level mobs in only a few hits. So I may have thought of something to help counter this. I prepose that not every creature drop coin. The higher the monster the higher the chances of continous coin. This eventually would raise the overall value of the doubloon, and it seems as far as coding something that is much easier than a three coin type system. Additionally crafting items as they are sold could have a counter placed on the PC where they could only sell so many crafted items, before the vendor says they have enough of that item. After a cooldown of i dunno 6 hours the counter would reset and allow the PC to continue to sell.

V/R
Draven
User avatar
Vexing
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 204
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 2:17 am

Re: Economy

Post by Vexing »

Eh... If one person does the work and puts in the time, they should reap the reward.
But the price should be driven by the laws of supply and demand. As in... only craft something when it is actually wanted, or needed to craft something else.
Perhaps spawn rates in certain areas should plummet if a certain animal is over hunted. (Not that any area seems to represent an ecosystem for population cycles to be accounted for.)
Ideally, a high level person will not linger grinding the lower level areas simply because they are capable of more profitable hunting.

I think the economy would do better if the processed products of one person were needed by another.
Instead of everyone only needing raw goods and then selling to a vender who is likely stocked to the gills from the other dozen people grinding that skill.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Economy

Post by Shadowbane »

And what are lower level characters supposed to do to raise the necessary funds to be competitive in a peddle, in order to get the upgrades they need from those 'collectors' out there? Hope for a handout? If higher level mobs are the ones that have the best chance of dropping coins, how are lower level characters supposed to hunt and repair their armor and weapons, on top of setting aside enough to get better stuff in the future? Hunting in some form or fashion needs to yield some kind of profit. Animals don't drop coins, but they drop materials that can be used to make money. The crypt doesn't drop a lot in terms of money and loot, but for a new character, it's a good start to work them up to squatters or statues or wendigo, then to vampires and trogs and ogres or trolls. I can't speak for anyone else, but I tend to hunt at my character's level. The only time I use something of a lower level, I'm actively training a skill and it takes literally the entire day to make a halfway decent profit.

What we need are regular money sinks of some kind. We have peddles and custom orders that are designed to remove doubloons from the system, but when a small handful of characters control the market ('It's IC for my character to hog everything, honest!') then it pushes others away. Why bother, right? But there's other ways to bleed money out of the market. Maybe home owners can pay a monthly 'property tax' that keeps the building maintained and safe. If they don't pay it, they run the risk of pests, damage from the elements, maybe people being able to break in. It could make for a fun little scenario and even help with character progression. If the player has to leave for an extended period of time (deployments, health, etc) then they can send an email or assist to staff and talk to them about putting a hold on it until they can return. People could also pay a regular banking membership fee or something in order to be able to store a certain number of things there. If pets become a thing, they could be expensive and you'd have to raise them, feed them, train them, etc. If you lost it in a fight or someone was a tool and killed it just 'cause, you can get a new one of the same from the pet merchant and start at square one again, for a price. (That could also be a time sink, too, for really unique or fancy pets with utility, like hauling or riding. Gotta raise it and train it in order for it to be useful!) Once ships are figured out, those could be huge money sinks. I'd like to see functioning ships being managed by groups of people, where everyone has to contribute a certain amount in order to meet an overall fee to pay to maintain it. After all, ships are expensive. They require constant maintenance, you have to keep supplies fresh and stocked, the crew needs to be paid, and if you're in a fight with someone or something, you gotta repair it. That's a money AND a time sink.

If people have to wait for a timer to make money, or have to train and train and train in order to be able to hunt the monsters that actually drop coins and loot, it'll push players away. There would be no reward for leveling or hunting, so why bother? Not everyone has the luxury of training all day because of work or school or whatever, so those people would be at an even greater disadvantage. We don't need to have mobs with no money, we just need more things to spend money on.
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
User avatar
Vexing
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 204
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 2:17 am

Re: Economy

Post by Vexing »

I think we need less of the trash loot, and put more of a quality factor on goods determined by skill in production. Which would greatly affect value.
Dabloons are entering the playing field at an alarming rate.... and not enough people are just scraping by barely able to make ends meet.
Monty Haul anyone?
I mean, if this is a world where everyone has all they need, of course the dabloon will end up worthless.
That's the problem with DIYers, they find a way to not have to pay.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Economy

Post by Creon »

Just wanted to clairify not every monster A has coins 60% of the time while monster B which is a highèr level monster drops (80%). Also Kaiah's concern is warented and my counter is that lower level players will be encouraged to either level up to be able to seek higher reward. Or go in parties with more experienced players or even players of their lvl.

Furthermore a new player being competitive in a bidding system against players that are 4 or 5 years old will never have a edge. Just like in real life the rich can out bid the poor.

From what I can tell staff has addressed this by having custom orders.

The idea is to raise the value of the doubloon the best way imo that is the most efficent code wise would be this idea.

V/R
Draven
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Economy

Post by Shadowbane »

And if less money drops, it will take longer for new characters to get better get because they'll spend the bulk of their money on repairs, which aren't cheap. "Level more" is about the same as "git gud". Too much of a time sink isn't fun, and let's not forget some already complain about a grind. Games are supposed to be played for fun and entertainment, not be more work than it's worth, so making players work longer for rewards will make them go find something more satisfying to play.

The game economy doesn't need to mirror real life, since our economy is kind of crappy anyway. Newer players and characters need to have the same opportunities as the more veteran ones when it comes to peddles or events, or they may just not bother. If people want more life and new blood in this game, it needs to be accommodating to the low level character. Acquiring money doesn't need to be our biggest challenge, our biggest challenge should be contributing to the game's story and lore.

It's really a case of not having enough to spend money on, hence the need for some huge and regular money sinks.
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
User avatar
Vexing
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 204
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 2:17 am

Re: Economy

Post by Vexing »

If money doesn't matter.
And peddles are equal opportunity..
Who even wants player made items?
They don't. I guess that's why they end up sold to vendors.

Where is this magical RP taking place, and what is it about?
There has to be more then arguments in a bar and trying to cyber. (aka being a dick)
Or grinding relentlessly to get good in a skill no one has much use for, until you have gotten good in it. (being a bot)

Maybe I have missed the goings on due to awkward playtimes.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
User avatar
RPGer
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 175
Joined: Sat Aug 15, 2015 4:40 pm
Location: USA

Re: Economy

Post by RPGer »

We still have a fairly moderate player base. From what I have experienced so far, the scaleing on the economy should solidify
as the base grows. But I do not believe it is (or even should be) a 'get it set and let it go' type of system.
It is something that will need to be continually tweeked. Just hopefully less and less often as time goes on.
There is still a lot to come with combat changes that will also affect how well coin can be made by hunting.
As far as Player made items- as long as houses need furnished or redecorated, there will be a market.
Want a new pair of cloths or a new bag? We may start seeing different options in materials etc. from players soon.
Higher level cooks have very good oportunities as well, just ask eabo for some popcorn. Depending on who you are, he probably wont give you any but
he may tell you he can get you some... for a price ;)
The price of those items is based not only on the skill it takes to make them, but also on the value of the raw materials.
I have noticed a lot of the so called trash drops thinning out from what it was before, often replaced with things that
can be bartered or used.
And speaking of bartering, I am glad to see some more activity with this lately.
Peddle auctions... yea, that is something that is entirely up to the playerbase. Does an older player want to encourage
the newer ones by giving them a chance to bid or not? That is something I hope everyone keeps in mind regardless of their
characters frame of mind.
RolePlay and storylines- There are staff directed lines going on now and there are player initiated lines that may or
may not have staff involvement going on also. We do need to remember that staff is really focused on getting systems and
updates in place to make sure they are working as planned on a schedule.
Some of these lines may even include new money sinks.
@Vexing- I think RP primetime is around 7 or 8 pm eastern, but even then it all depends on what your char. is up to or into or trying to get into or out of. As I mentioned above, some things go on without staff here and there.
CoralScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 122
Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm

Re: Economy

Post by CoralScribe »

Now, I'm not an economist, nor do I suspect, or expect, that they have one on staff. But from my experience and my arm-chair design philosophies, there are plenty of issues with the current monetary system. I've detailed some of them in the past and I'm grateful to see at least some of those challenges have been met in the time I've been gone. Unfortunately, changing them at this point, after years of open development with no character wipes inbound (thank goodness), is going to be an extremely tricky business. Most characters who have been here for years have accumulated substantial wealth, and simply robbing someone of it at this point would earn no nods of sympathy from the players its taken from. Adding more money sinks is probably the answer, so I agree with Kaiah's position, but getting them to work right and only target those upper echelons of the ultra wealthy will be difficult.

The main reason why game economies fail is the infinite inflation problem. Money simply appears in the system when an item is sold or a mob dies, rather than a certain amount of money existing within a closed or semi-closed system and that wealth being distributed through the purchase of goods, taxes, etc. There's plenty of reasons for this, the primary one being, arguably, that a sense of progression is felt from those with the Achiever in their blood to see that money number go up. From that perspective, this system is functional - the number keeps going up. There are dangers, of course.

I came from a game called Horizons that has several more years on it than this one, and 98% of the gear there is player made. Ironically, that did not actually create a system by which money changed hands and today, you just ask someone with the skill to make gear, spend hours learning to make it yourself, or go nude. (I prefer that last one~ Then again, I played a dragon there.) Paying someone for it is almost useless, as the only money sinks in it are completely laughable, and almost completely avoidable. In short, crafters took all the money at first, had nothing to spend it on, and the economy fell apart. You might say, oh, but we have a housing system here - well, so did they. And it was initially a hard purchase to make. But also like here, there is no money sink involved in keeping it - other than subscribing, but that's not the game economy. ;p

Now due to the fact that gear isn't player made and there are more things to spend coin on here, even if the most expensive items are gated behind rare peddles, we aren't likely to hit that critical mass yet. But we will eventually if nothing changes. This is a long-term problem, so I don't think it needs immediate action and I'm sure the devs themselves realize that action will need to be taken eventually. Some of what has been suggested are good options, and I especially like the idea that negligent payments can potential lead to ruined houses from a purely RP-inducing role. And pets. Raising animals would be awesome. Many of Kaiah's examples are ones that have worked well in the past. I will add another, though.

I also suggest that a greater difference in armor is made. I recently started playing with the combat system, and with my fancy new Coldsteel armor and low skill, I can safely hunt ghosts on Academy Isle, make about 2-5 doubloons a kill. Generally, by the time my inventory caps out with junk items to sell and I head back to repair my armor, I spend about 60-70% on repairs, and still tend to end up with a small profit, which is nice. But my armor, not counting my shield, is one level short of top-tier. Since the damage done to your armor appears to not have anything to do with the amount of damage you take (a 1 hp hit and a 20 hp hit don't seem to have any different effect on durability), I probably *shouldn't* be making a profit hunting these low of creatures in this armor. These mobs were designed for lower skilled players and, while I am at that skill, I don't actually need the armor I use (I use it for RP mostly, and fire trolls. Ouch.) It may be prudent to increase the amount of effect armor has in terms of absorbing damage based on the material, but also increase the cost to repair as well. This would make it a good idea to have multiple types of armor for multiple situations, leading to more purchases of peddle and non-peddle. You might only need bronze for training hunts like I'm on in order to overcome the money-to-repair ratio, but you'll want the higher armors for riskier monsters like frost trolls, who should pay enough to make that durability/payout ratio worthwhile.

Unfortunately, until the combat system is fully implemented, this balancing of armor and repair cost can't be adjusted, as one depends on the other. Nor is it the end all, as the tank/leader will inevitably take more damage to their armor as the result of being the one in the front, while pansies like Coraleth hide in the back and throw spells, and then receive an equal split even though the tank has the repair costs. And none of this touches the upcoming dragon/wyvern dilemma as they do not wear armor at all, so this sink doesn't apply to them.

Ultimately, there are a lot of ways the devs could move forward, and I'm sure they're thinking about it. The food peddle is a great example of it working right: we bid on the cost for the right of first-purchase. If someone rich wanted it, either all to themselves or just to make sure they got as much as they wanted, they'd have to bid higher and higher to make it happen. As the individual cost went higher, the likelihood of buying a lot and denying others went down, as it became too expensive to do so. Now this is on something innocuous - food isn't a major gain though with the recent stam changes it might be nice, I haven't played with it - but I could see a somewhat similar situation for something with a smaller number of items that could more fairly distribute between the rich and the poor. It'll take a lot of work, but fortunately I don't really know any characters or their players that would be jerks enough to create a 'hogging it all' situation, so a smaller community helps in this regard. It should hold until more extensive economic review can be made.

We'll have to see what comes of it.
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....

**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
User avatar
Vexing
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 204
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 2:17 am

Re: Economy

Post by Vexing »

Well party splits can be solved be agreeing as a group, that all repairs will be handled before shares are divvied out.
Overhead is a standard accounting principle.
But that's an RP issue.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Post Reply