[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • Initial Impression of Combat Changes
Page 1 of 1

Initial Impression of Combat Changes

Posted: Thu Oct 27, 2016 7:15 pm
by
As the title suggests, these are some of my initial impressions. Currently, I have done very limited amounts of testing and I wasn't terribly engrossed in hunting previously, but these are just my first knee-jerk reactions and experiences.

I started out on the Academy, which I must have quite over-leveled, as I was taking no damage from fire trolls while naked. It did give me some interesting tests of overwhelming power, and I was surprised to find that my close combat could kill things in two hits, even with weapons dropped in the Academy. I was even more surprised to discover that my third tier magic took five times that on average to kill the same type of mob. It left me exceedingly worried that spell damage might not scale with level at all.

So naturally my next stop was to go to the strongest thing I knew how to reach easily, and that was ogres. Even with good peddle armor, they were knocking me around for 25-35 a hit, and when I attacked them, with spell or weapon, I did no damage. So clearly, that did not work well, and spell damage did have some calculation based on level.

Finally ended up at statues where I found an 'even' fight, or at least as close to one as I could get. Without armor, they could hit as much as 20, but with armor, it was a far more manageable 5-10 per hit. Here at last I could see that while my weapon could hit for solid swings, it was a bit more random, far more so than my spells, which were consistently hitting solidly or decently. In terms of skill level, my CC and t3 spell are about even. If I had been naked, spells would have been better for hitting more frequently, but with the new armor penalties, my spells failed anywhere from 30-60% of the time depending on luck, bringing the two about even in terms of to-hit.


--

Overall, in terms of even fights, things haven't changed overmuch it seems, which is good. Ideally, we would want to find some challenge in our combat, rather than a grind. That said, this game has a grind component as part of its main function (ie, leveling skills), and the changes may make doing so much more difficult in the future. If the experience I had two-shotting academy mobs is intentional and not just a matter of current balance (and if I am highly overleveled as I think I am, it may supposed to be), then grinding CC and other attack oriented skills and spells will be much more difficult. On the other end of the spectrum, however, standing in an orc melee being completely impervious could lead to defensive skills being quite easy to train, indeed even autonomously so. That could end up being a long-term problem.

My experience with spells seems to suggest that there is likely a level-based component and a skill based component still (ie, as it used to be), and that the level component may be a % allowed through or something of that nature. What this means is that spells are still heavily limited to your skill level with them, rather than the level of mob you are fighting. If correct, I'm not certain how I feel about this, but so long as spell damage remains more consistent or on average equal to melee damage, I have no real problems with it. However, if I'm wrong and there's a cap on how much we can do to lower level mobs, I may also not be certain how I feel about it for an entirely different reason. While it would mean that our attack spell training would be far easier, it would also deny us the same sense of progression.
---- (Note: I could be completely wrong, and skill and level both increase damage, in which case it is simply that the ogres I fought had too much armor or something of that nature. I do not have enough evidence to say one way or another.)

While on the topic of spells, using my old coldsteel armor does quite impede casting. I'm likely going to dislike it in the short term as I adjust, but hopefully as I replace armor with something that doesn't conflict, the total damage using spells will be higher due to consistency of numbers and to-hit. As long as that total damage increases at an equal to or greater than rate of damage taken from using lower armor, then all should be well, but that will take much more testing than the short time I've put in.

There is one last thing that I worry about these changes, and that's group hunts. With the Academy being completely decimated by my manly skills with a blade, were I to lead or participate in a hunt there, it might take all the fun out of it for those low level players coming along. Conversely, if I were to join a group of high level players going to fight ogres for the city hunts, I might as well put on a costume and start cheering, because I'll be nothing more than a mascot. While there may yet be some use in the latter case via allowing players to far more easily train their attack skills (I don't think anyone's two-shotting ogres yet, but I could be wrong), the former case may be much harder to solve.




In any event, these are my first looks at the system and I'll give them more examination in the coming weeks. I leave you with this irony I much enjoyed as my Kalethian Nydine was fixing his 0-skills.

You now feel more skilled in Fire Building.
You have advanced your religious standing.