Page 1 of 4
Info Boards?
Posted: Tue Oct 29, 2013 12:25 pm
by
So has anyone been logging percentages and levels yet?

Re: Info Boards?
Posted: Tue Oct 29, 2013 3:31 pm
by
Yes, though I admit my percentages and notes are mostly regarding Barbarians for which I have been doing large amounts of testing for the class from Alpha up through now. If you have any questions regarding my notes, I welcome any messages! Sorry if that doesn't help, I'm sure many others have made notes here and there!
-Kschilan's player
Re: Info Boards?
Posted: Tue Oct 29, 2013 5:29 pm
by
I have been keeping a record of skills earned to include the level they are earned, from what skill or NPC they are learned from, and what THEY unlock. Krell has been immensely helpful, and we've been trading notes as we go. I've been keeping stuff on warriors, but as I level my assassin (and templar when they get released) I'll keep track of that as well.
Re: Info Boards?
Posted: Tue Oct 29, 2013 6:41 pm
by
I am really interested in any merchant skill tree. Because I nearly slit my wrists just leveling foraging to learn other stuff and I'm like "AGAIN?" I don't want to spend hours chopping wood if it doesn't get me what I want. I've been doing an assassin but I forgot to pay attention to the 1st few levels
Re: Info Boards?
Posted: Tue Oct 29, 2013 7:14 pm
by
I think it makes sense for a complete list of which skills get unlocked and at which levels to be made available for the players. It is not logical that an aspiring mage does not know which skills to practice to unlock the next spell that he is working towards. It makes even less sense for a tradesman to not know which ability will help them to learn the next.
The OOC frustration alone is enough to justify a complete list being released. I'm not keen on spending countless hours testing each ability just to see what I may or may not get at later levels. I think we need more comprehensive information available to us and not just the first couple of unlockable skills.
I find it very hard to believe that a thriving port city does not have this information readily available. We have guilds and temples and leaders among the population. Shattered Isles as a whole is not just populated by the dozen or so PC's that are logged on during the course of the day. There are hundreds of townspeople, craftsmen, tradesman etc. So why is this information hidden?
We should have had maps available from the beginning as well. I'm not sure why it has taken this long to get them and props to Xercien's player for creating them. I can go to any city in the world and find a map. I have never once been told by a store owner or employee that exploring and making my own maps is half the fun.
Full disclosure on skill trees and readily available maps of all the common areas are in my opinion, quite logical. Prior to the maps being added to the website of the academy; if I were a new player trying the game out, i would have lasted roughly 5 minutes and I would have moved on to another game.
Re: Info Boards?
Posted: Tue Oct 29, 2013 7:49 pm
by
exactly. especially the map thing. it makes no sense for players to even have to submit their maps for "official" use on the website. Those maps should already be made. When I made rooms for dgate and when I made rooms for the mud I tried to launch, the very first thing I did was draw the map out before I even did room descriptions.
Re: Info Boards?
Posted: Tue Oct 29, 2013 8:38 pm
by
Too late to discuss what should have been done. We are a community that moves forward. We never made maps because we have a million other things on our plates that are equally important. We always hoped and counted on the fact that the player base would help build the community in these ways. We were fortunate enough to have that happen and now we're all benefiting from it. Some might call that things going according to plan.
As for the skill list, this is always going to be a battle. I never understood why other games worked so hard to keep information from players. The player base always pieces this information together anyway. At DragonCon this year we sat in on a panel that actually discussed this in some detail. It was a theme of the times apparently. A desire not to spoil things for players. A way to encourage interaction so that instead of reading from a list and knowing everything, you experienced the surprise of unlocking something new. The shared interaction between a new and old player over what's in store for them. Newer games make it all available. Nothing is a mystery. I'd like to be somewhere in the middle. There should be some sense of discovery.
In either case, it doesn't help anyone to put up incomplete data. An unfinished map doesn't help you and a skill tree list that is still evolving will just confuse you. As the game grows, more information becomes available.
Lastly, while I appreciate your realistic comparisons, some understanding that this is a game and these things do not just up and make themselves goes a long way. Creating a city does not mean it comes with a map. It does't mean all its inhabitants know every piece of information to share with your character. These things come with time.
Re: Info Boards?
Posted: Wed Oct 30, 2013 12:09 am
by
If that is your interpretation of what I am suggesting and if this is an ever evolving system that is a fair enough response. I do however maintain the opinion that I think it is unreasonable to expect the players to level every skill just to see what gets unlocked next without more guidance available to them.
I think a game like Dragon's Gate could get away with more secrecy of which abilities you get next because the skill progression was more linear. For example as a mage you just needed to level spellcasting to unlock the next ability. We didn't necessarily need to know what we got next because it was just a single skill. There was no guess work on whether or not it was worth it to you to level an individual skill just to see what you got next. Shattered Isles has multiple skills that need to be leveled to unlock abilities. I do not think the veil of secrecy is as forgiving with this style of skill progression.
Edit to add:
I did not mean to imply every inhabitant knows every piece of information to share with my character but as a vibrant and fully inhabited town I should have most of this knowledge inherent in my character. Since I cannot actually interact with every NPC I think it is reasonable to expect that my character knows basic information about my chosen profession and I think it is fair to assume I know the city and surrounding areas well enough to get around reasonably well.
Re: Info Boards?
Posted: Wed Oct 30, 2013 12:32 am
by
It's still our intention to publish a limited skill tree list for each class under their web page. I'll never be in favor of sharing all of the abilities gained because I strongly believe in the experience a player can have unlocking a high level skill that isn't widely known to exist or how to gain it. This is crucial to me when trying to create a world you can immerse yourself in. Maybe we can sell a gaming book with all the cheats and tricks of the game for those that want to spoil the fun of discovery.
We're in agreement that there is a need for this. We're compiling those lists for the websites. The goal is to give you enough information to see where each branch can lead while still leaving you the element of surprise as you cross into those higher levels. I realize it's frustrating, it's equally so on our end as we not only try to compile these lists for ourselves, but also change them on a regular basis to make more sense as new abilities are added. I think in the end most skill trees will be easy to figure out. Air unlocks more air, lightning more lightning. Mining unlocks blacksmithing, blacksmithing unlocks smelting and so on. They are all related if you stop to think about it. We've gone a step further to add multiple paths to unlock the same ability, like with Hiding and Close Combat unlocking backstab for thieves. This is to accommodate the different playing styles and role play choices each player makes.
All of your assumptions are fair from your character's perspective, but you as the player know better than that and have to roll with what's available. You know better than most given your time in Alpha that we will go as far as the community as a whole takes us and right now we're really moving forward with a great community.
Re: Info Boards?
Posted: Wed Oct 30, 2013 12:44 am
by
I don't fully agree but I can see what you're saying seems to be a fair enough compromise. I just needed a moment to express my opinions. It's been on my mind for awhile. Maybe next i'll fully express my opinion on why I think we need more official staff input on racial/religious backgrounds, conflict, and role-play. lol