Putting down the cookie cutter
Posted: Mon Nov 25, 2013 4:18 pm
Aloha friends,
So thank you for the two new shops. Mazjer's Spice shop and Sully's Tavern. It's always good to see the city growing and opening many of the locked doors. Even more exciting should new doors appear.
While perusing Sully's, I was a little irritated to find a lack of food/non-alcoholic items. I'm aware we have a cooking skill in game, but let's be honest, no one is going to work it seriously as a "craft" which can make "money." This leaves me confused as to the lack of food items and RP items in shops at the moment. I'm also severely aggravated by the stock in Pearl's shops in general, but that's for another time.
Because I was irritated and wanted to make sense of what I've seen so far between the five different taverns, four of which are on New Archai, I did some number crunching.
The items in the taverns are sorely bland and recycled versions of what I am assuming was the first tavern, The Blackheart Inn. So much so that out of the 49 items between the five taverns, 25 of them are duplicates (that's 51% of tavern items which are not unique, and I did not account for variants with the same noun outside of this clever number: "a tankard of ale", "a copper tankard," and "a copper tankard of ale.")
These are the items that were recycled in their entirety with the caveat of the [descriptor] tankard [noun]:
I'm also pretty sure that the Royal Tankard used to be stocked with carbon-copy items from the Blackheart Inn, or it might be the irritation talking. At least the taverns appear to have been improving in unique item stock based on how old/new the tavern is to the game, so there is that at least.
Now, really, any excuse can be made up in game about this. But I'm assuming it's a lack of time/creativity/care in regards to how these taverns (and a number of Pearl's shops) have been stocked. When a new shop opens, I am consistently disappointed in the imagination and usefulness that has gone into the items.
I completely understand items are not everyone's thing, but for all that is holy and good.... please consider the theme of Pearl. It is the capital city. It is supposed to be the hub of trade and the base of the Archai Trading Company. The shops and their items are at best, backwater apprentice items from the swamps of Tetherias.
I further understand that everyone is a volunteer here and participation from players in building the world is highly encouraged. But I really must insist that when you do something (especially something which affects the playability of the city we are all in right now) it be done with consistency, planning and some modicum of adding value to the game. Carbon copying items from one tavern to another does not add value to the game, and serves only to disappoint players in the novelty of a new area/store/etc.
When I checked Mazjers I was further stricken with the thought that while those items might be interesting for RP purposes, they are really very useless overall right now. The addition of other RP items to complement the spices would have fleshed out the shop as a whole and made it feel more dynamic. A mortar and pestle perhaps? A wooden drying rack? A glass spice jar? An aromatic sachet of patchouli for those characters with more pomp than others.
Other shops in Pearl can stand to be fully fleshed out as well. The Inn, for example, could benefit from hygiene RP items like bars of soap, towels, bath robes and other assortments like pillows, blankets, umbrellas. The possibilities really are endless.
I realize this post might be a little bit of a hobby horse from certain points of view, but I think if you want the areas you create to come alive, you should consider expanding some of the outlines of ideas that are currently active shops in the game. I'd also like to mention that my frustration with these shops is not directed to anyone personally, but stems from the recognition of wasted potential. I enjoy this game, and I'd prefer to see it succeed.
So thank you for the two new shops. Mazjer's Spice shop and Sully's Tavern. It's always good to see the city growing and opening many of the locked doors. Even more exciting should new doors appear.
While perusing Sully's, I was a little irritated to find a lack of food/non-alcoholic items. I'm aware we have a cooking skill in game, but let's be honest, no one is going to work it seriously as a "craft" which can make "money." This leaves me confused as to the lack of food items and RP items in shops at the moment. I'm also severely aggravated by the stock in Pearl's shops in general, but that's for another time.
Because I was irritated and wanted to make sense of what I've seen so far between the five different taverns, four of which are on New Archai, I did some number crunching.
The items in the taverns are sorely bland and recycled versions of what I am assuming was the first tavern, The Blackheart Inn. So much so that out of the 49 items between the five taverns, 25 of them are duplicates (that's 51% of tavern items which are not unique, and I did not account for variants with the same noun outside of this clever number: "a tankard of ale", "a copper tankard," and "a copper tankard of ale.")
These are the items that were recycled in their entirety with the caveat of the [descriptor] tankard [noun]:
A flagon of mead x3
some salted peanuts x5
some crusty black bread x2
a jug of wine x3
a decanter of moonshine x3
a .. tankard .. ale x3 (a tankard of ale, a copper tankard, a copper tankard of ale)
a bottle of champagne x3
a pitcher of ale x3
I'm also pretty sure that the Royal Tankard used to be stocked with carbon-copy items from the Blackheart Inn, or it might be the irritation talking. At least the taverns appear to have been improving in unique item stock based on how old/new the tavern is to the game, so there is that at least.
Now, really, any excuse can be made up in game about this. But I'm assuming it's a lack of time/creativity/care in regards to how these taverns (and a number of Pearl's shops) have been stocked. When a new shop opens, I am consistently disappointed in the imagination and usefulness that has gone into the items.
I completely understand items are not everyone's thing, but for all that is holy and good.... please consider the theme of Pearl. It is the capital city. It is supposed to be the hub of trade and the base of the Archai Trading Company. The shops and their items are at best, backwater apprentice items from the swamps of Tetherias.
I further understand that everyone is a volunteer here and participation from players in building the world is highly encouraged. But I really must insist that when you do something (especially something which affects the playability of the city we are all in right now) it be done with consistency, planning and some modicum of adding value to the game. Carbon copying items from one tavern to another does not add value to the game, and serves only to disappoint players in the novelty of a new area/store/etc.
When I checked Mazjers I was further stricken with the thought that while those items might be interesting for RP purposes, they are really very useless overall right now. The addition of other RP items to complement the spices would have fleshed out the shop as a whole and made it feel more dynamic. A mortar and pestle perhaps? A wooden drying rack? A glass spice jar? An aromatic sachet of patchouli for those characters with more pomp than others.
Other shops in Pearl can stand to be fully fleshed out as well. The Inn, for example, could benefit from hygiene RP items like bars of soap, towels, bath robes and other assortments like pillows, blankets, umbrellas. The possibilities really are endless.
I realize this post might be a little bit of a hobby horse from certain points of view, but I think if you want the areas you create to come alive, you should consider expanding some of the outlines of ideas that are currently active shops in the game. I'd also like to mention that my frustration with these shops is not directed to anyone personally, but stems from the recognition of wasted potential. I enjoy this game, and I'd prefer to see it succeed.