[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • The Crafting Review -or- How Coraleth Moved Dragon Summit
Page 1 of 2

The Crafting Review -or- How Coraleth Moved Dragon Summit

Posted: Fri Feb 14, 2014 10:28 pm
by
Yes, that is a Rocky and Bulwinkle reference. Don’t judge.

At this point, I’ve gotten a little experience in crafting in the game and in the spirit of hopefully improving the game and keeping the devs informed of player experience, I thought I’d give a full-scale review of my experience with crafting as it stands now.

If you don’t want Cora’s crafting life story, you can skip ahead to the observations or recommendations, but it should inform you of how I came to these points. This post will be broken up into several parts:

So You Want to Be a Crafter?
Observations on this Experience
Recommendations Based on this Experience
Speculating on Speculating
That’s Not All, Folks!







So You Want to Be a Crafter?

When I first started the game, I had not considered what the monster that is crafting really was. I played as I often do, choosing a caster class and portraying the somewhat erudite mage with lots of fancy elemental metaphors. Crafting started as a simple attempt to gather up some sought after stat points, the only one of which was my very first level of foraging, and it was charisma. “Digging in the dirt makes people like me!” I thought. Well, I haven’t seen any since then, but having a non-combat interaction was something new to me in this type of skill-based MUD and I was willing to give it a shot. Once I found the economy page, after several hours of reading the forums, I determined that I wanted Coraleth to be a jewelcrafter because obviously gold doesn’t rust, and he’s a nydine water-mage.

Little did I know the horror I was inflicting upon myself.

Crafting is a long, long process. The shortest amount of time to make something from scratch, assuming you stay in the same room with a fire or whatever else you might need already present, is two minutes. One for gathering, and one for crafting. This will /never/ happen, which means that crafting takes between five and ten minutes for a simple item, depending on the rarity of the resource, your skill in finding it, your speed in moving from place to place, and finally setting up somewhere to work.

Foraging and cooking were my first foray into the crafting world, in which I agonized and agonized over trying to locate salt, and had no clue where to get herbs or even what they were. I still don’t really, but I did eventually find salt several days later when I was mining, and later kicked myself to learn that there was salt in town. Regardless, I gleefully located rice in ample quantity and set about building fires in the forest so I could cook some hundred pounds of rice. I was somewhat devastated to learn that we don’t actually have to eat in SI, and moreover it sold for all of 1 doubloon, which is how much I’d get for the salt alone, but as I said, I had it in me I wanted to be a jewelcrafter, so this was all preparation and getting to know the system.

By this point, I’d gotten into the basics of all of the gathering professions of course, with the exception of fishing and skinning, which I eventually stumbled across on my own. Everything unlocked at 5, I was beginning to see a pattern, and I eagerly set to mining on Dragon’s Summit, mostly in the entrance where I didn’t have to deal with too many orcs. Actually, this turned out to be an ideal spot, because sooner or later, someone would trip over me, and we got to RPing, which was a lot of fun – after all, this is a multiplayer game, and its real success is due not solely to game mechanics but to interaction with other people.

I had not unlocked any other professions, because I was dedicated to reaching jewelcrafting and, as seen on the economy page, that meant mining. Fighting off orcs as best I could with my dinky T1 water blast and some basic CC skill, I anticipated unlocking my first profession from mining as I approached the reoccurring 5s rule, and sure enough, after bypassing 5 (which would have normally been another gathering skill, but there’s none after mining) I hit 10 and unlocked stone sculpting! It wasn’t what I wanted, but it was a start, and while I was making good money selling off all of my gathered resources, I wanted to see what this new profession could do. Compared to cooking, it was blissfully simple: plop down the stone, and go at it! Apparently, nydine have pretty sharp claws that can carve stone (Rply, I keep a chisel, kindly donated by one of my ever present orcish companions, but this is - thankfully - not necessary). I located some non-descript stone and carved up my first chess piece, and promptly sold it for 8 doubloons. It may not seem like much at first glance, but considering the stone sold for only 1, that was eight times the profit for me! I was much impressed and quite happy. My skill in this, while not my primarily intended profession, went on to provide a very adequate gift to one of Cora’s only friends at the time, and reasonable money to reward my effort.

Week or two later of 10-15+ hours a day sculpting stone and gathering metal, I unlocked blacksmithy, and was encouraged via RP to pursue it further by one of Cora’s friends. I could now use two of the three types of material mining gives, and I was again very happy, even though I had really wanted jewelcrafting to be next. In retrospect, however, it made sense – smelting came with smithy, and it’s a really nice skill to have it you plan on working metals. I was also pleasantly surprised that I got two bars instead of the expected one when smelting as in other games with crafting elements, meaning that smelting did not (usually) lose me any profits. Once more, what I could make did provide some RP clout. Though I was unable to provide for everyone in the Conclave meeting, making useful items out of useful materials for people became a source of pride, if not a source of revenue (both Cora and I have a bad time pricing things, especially for friends).

Upon reaching the next milestone, I was quite distraught to learn that jewelcrafting did not follow what I had come to see as the expected route. I had gladly gathered up several bundles of both gems and metals, and even had promised to make everyone in the temple a gift of some piece of platinum-lapis jewelry which we could have all shared and looked to with pride as members of the Kalethian faith. Daunted, but undeterred, I once again returned to the mountain after ensuring that jewelcrafting was indeed in-game. That was when my real lessons in crafting began. Through contact on the forums with the devs and learning more about how crafting is implemented and will eventually be implemented, I discovered several taboos which were located approximately nowhere, learned that the quality of material is ultimately non-important in most if not all current crafting skillsets, discovered that crafting is considered to be a completely separate style of gameplay, and that most of the process is a very lonely and isolating experience that is under no circumstances intended to be shortened in any way.

Finally, after beating my head against the rock until I had the brow of a caveman, I reached the last milestone and the final eureka moment: Jewelcrafting was mine! I was somewhat alarmed and amused to discover all the items I could make were ‘simple’ – either this was a quick addition, or my suggested system was already in place at least somewhere. Though distraught to discover a hairpin required two pieces of metal while a pot only requires one, I was nonetheless overjoyed with my Neanderthal metalwork and set upon perfecting it with the thousands of tons of material I had ripped from the ground. And thus does my narrative end, but my crafting journey continue.

Still have a lot of gems I’m not using though…


Observations Based on this Experience

- In general, my experiences with crafting have been pretty good. Though crafting can be an exceptionally tedious process at times, it has proven to be extremely therapeutic and relaxing. Many of the RP connections I have with others came as a result of crafting, be it from people stumbling over me while I was working, or gifts and sold items allowing me to connect with other people and characters. In short, crafting is good!

- My first experiences with crafting are largely trial and a lot of error. The help files were my primary source for information, but detailed information on crafting and resources is virtually nonexistent without a lot of research and sifting through some misinformation (a misunderstood comment from another player led me to believe that ‘rare resource spawns’ were a part of the game, when in fact they are a bug). The misinformation can be a good thing, as it might encourage one character to ask another, but in practice this has proven to be the opposite – whether the misinformation given unintentionally, or outright refusal to share ‘secrets’ in one case, the blackout on etiquette and information caused me to make assumptions, some of which ran afoul of the ‘intended system.’

- Besides some well-known bad examples, the money-to-effort ratio is pretty decent. I hope that, as the lists are filled in and levels increase, that profit too should increase relative to the time it might take one to hunt at a certain level. Given the time it takes to actually increase crafting levels, especially post-10 when a single point of craft can be as much as fifteen points of CC, this will be hard to manage, as getting to higher levels and killing things with lots of money and loot is a significantly faster path to wealth by design and will always be the better method of wealth creation by far, especially to new players.

- Placement of resources can have a profound impact on player to player interaction. Without mining where I did, I might never have met Blink, and from there all the myriad other personalities I’ve come to know, love, and fear within the world. When I first came here, I was shy as many new players are, and by being filtered into the right spot where interaction was inevitable, it helped to break me out of my shell.

-That said, the length of time it takes to level, collect resources, and turn those resources into something, can be as much isolating as empowering, especially when the resources are off the beaten path. The refining process does not necessarily have this problem, as many crafting skills require a flame, which can be found in taverns where people might congregate or elsewhere (another thing I wish I would have known so I didn’t have to burn Tallwood Forest down making boiled rice). Of course, fear of having your resources stolen can be an issue as well, though thankfully this has only occurred once to me. As a result, this isn’t a major issue to me at this time.

-At current, the system does and does not lend itself to specializing. I had never intended to know more than enough foraging to save my life, and then focus purely on mining from there. However, I had to experience all the other gathering skills before I could reach my intended destination. This is not a bad thing. As I mentioned, stone sculpting, while not what I intended to learn, proved to be especially useful to the RP life of Cora. Fortunately, there are ways within the current system that allow one to use all resources, while focusing on one skill over another. How? Chessboards. Skillwise, it is a lot better to choose a 1-resource item to make, like a pawn, and there is no difference economically between a 1 and 2-piece item in stone sculpting. However, making a 2-piece item cuts my carving time in half, allowing for quicker money and less skill points, ultimately allowing for specialization if you are trying to advance one skill over another (my stone sculpting ended up around 8, while my smithy went to 11. This was largely a result of chessboards, the 2-piece, being available at 5, rather than smithy’s 2-piece items which at current come at 10).

-Gathering skills are primary skills until they unlock crafting skills, at which point they become secondary skills. This observation comes as a result of the unexpected jump in jewelcrafting’s placement. The level of mining and other gathering skills has no discernable effect on the efficacy, quantity, or quality of the items gathered. Their sole purposes therefore are unlocking crafting skills and providing raw materials for said skills. Whether you are 1 or 100, you will be gathering most material at a rate of 1-3 per shot (in terms of mining. There are some outliers, like salt, which is very, very numerous when gathered, and other gathering skills also can exceed this number depending on material, but not skill). The speed at which one presses through these skills is therefore relatively pointless, because of the crafting corollary.

-Crafting corollary: There is no way at all to speed up the process of leveling crafting skills. I think most power gamers will decry this as a shame, but I believe this is one part of crafting that is actually working as intended. This is the real reason why crafting and combat are two very different aspects of the same game. After passing through the ‘nice’ leveling region of 1-11, it will require literally thousands of pounds of material to advance crafting, and therefore it is and becomes the main focus and primary skill of the crafter. The fact that crafting can and likely should be done in truly safe regions falls in line with the ‘separate track’ philosophy of leveling crafting vs. adventure.





Recommendations Based on Observations

-First and foremost, there needs to be a decision made on the philosophy of crafting. There seems to be this idea that crafters do not and will never need combat skill, but my shield block did not hit 15 from rocks being cast off when I hit them with my mining pick. The concept of ‘risk versus reward’ is present sporadically, leading crafting to appear to be tacked on and haphazard as a result, while in other places it is seen to have no risk, with effort replacing risk in this equation of value.
Reconnecting adventure and crafting is not necessarily a bad thing, if properly implemented. This does not mean - and should not mean - that a crafter’s combat skill must equal their crafting skill. There needs to be safe, low level places where gathering can be done. Why? Because crafting is a long and tedious process, even more so if you aren’t the one doing it. You can’t expect that someone will want to watch over you and kill orcs or whatever else might harry you while picking up sticks or poking at rocks. However, if you really want to implement risk vs. reward in a more consistent fashion, my suggestion is as such: make the material more important in terms of the sales price of items, and then make those higher level materials more difficult to attain without combat readiness or assistance.
If the material has a higher effect on the end profit, it will encourage crafters to team up with adventurers to attain those materials. The crafters collect resources to be turned into profit, the adventurers can protect them, and the two methods of wealth generation can be shared at the end.
Problems with this suggestion are: material has no qualitative effect on most crafted items, as they are purely cosmetic; increasing the price of the gathered material may encourage high level adventurers with low level gathering to sell off the materials for ample profit and cut the crafters out completely as, whether you are 1 or 50, you’re going to get material at about the same rate whether it’s lead or platinum; due to the length of time crafting takes, profit sharing after a hunt is over will still be difficult and require a large measure of trust and/or time (on the other hand, this could be good RP time, too).

-Be more transparent about the dos-and-don’ts of crafting. While it was my system that drew the greatest attention from the devs, now that I have used speculate and understand the inherent flaws with resource implementation I realize that everyone who has ever leveled a crafting skill, regardless of whether they realize it or not, has ‘cheated.’ The fact that my system was not discovered or reported is due in large part to the way the gathering system is currently implemented, the resource distribution within areas, and most of all the utter lack of knowledge of right, wrong, and intention. Without documentation, the only thing players have to work with is experience, or devs descending from the heavens when they do something wrong. The latter of which wastes everyone’s time and slows down game development, and thus being upfront would be ideal. This, however, I can solve myself – I plan on writing up a basic information crafting guide for players relatively soon that I hope you’ll sticky in the general section. For more information on this problem and some solutions, see my tirade ‘Speculating on Speculating.’

-Along this line, consider removing ‘no resources’ from the random spawn in resource areas. It may not be realistic, as there are times (many times in fact) in which a miner might find nothing, but this is one of the times in which game balance and mechanics has to trump realism. This will not solve the problem completely, as rooms are limited to a sole resource as is, but it will lessen the accidental cheating. To fully fix the problem, it would require this change and much more firmly delineated resources in rooms and areas , or making sure that overlap means two possible resources are in a room.

-When placing new resources, make sure that adventurers will want to pass through the area if possible. Anything that helps to facilitate interaction between players can be beneficial to the community, especially with a small population as MUDs tend to have. Perhaps there are farms on the way to the gnome mines, and inside the mines beyond the relatively safe entrance, terrible dark things want to murdilate people and drop lots of loot for adventurers, etc.

-Allow Speculate to be used in combat. Yes, it allows us to get information about an area, but since it doesn’t actually provide those resources, it’s a fair trade off to making it more possible to be group-oriented via hiring adventurers and providing RP opportunities.

-When adding more items to the crafting lists, make sure at least one 2-piece item is early on the list for non-recipe based crafting (ie, anything but cooking and smelting pretty much) to allow for specialization options without having to throw away/vendor materials. Conversely, make sure there is always a 1-piece item too.

-Really experiment with allowing players to make more meaningful items. At current, most items created are purely cosmetic, and will only be collected by people who want to RP as being ‘civilized’ or possess a home where they can have a cabinet full of pots and pans. I know that the system does not allow for resource material to matter except in terms of vendoring, so as you approach implementing armor and possibly weapons, I recommend seeing if a recipe-based system such as exists in cooking can be used to create different strengths of armor and/or weapons. If the end result can be modified (a level 1 recipe might absorb 5 damage while a level 10 recipe might absorb 15, etc), then as long as the recipe is specific, the material can have a direct correlation to the quality of the armor (by allowing only bronze in early recipes, then iron, etc). If that armor can be further customized by having non-specific quality items in the process, such as a ‘buckle’ that could be made of any type of metal added somewhere into the description of the final item, you have the potential for making real meaningful items, in which quality and worth can be determined by the player making it, or the player commissioning it. And that would be fantastic and truly reward the crafter.
Had to bold this, because I think this is most important in the long term.

- This isn’t so much a recommendation, but a suggestion in moving forward: try to find some way of making gathering and crafting a more engaging and active process. The method I had for leveling encouraged active participation in the process. Ultimately, it is the same basic process I will use going forward once I begin leveling my crafts again: speculating, locating, and mashing the gather button – the MUD equivalent to whack-a-mole. While I am glad for the time it takes to craft, it does not encourage or require direct participation in the process; this has allowed me to do RL work (which is good!), read up on the forums, and even type up all of these recommendations, but those are things I am doing while not paying full attention to a game, which has been traditionally defined as ‘something you do for enjoyment.’ I enjoy this sort of thing, because I am exceedingly patient and perhaps a mite bit insane, but crafting would have wider appeal as an option for going forward if there was some way players could do more than hit a button and wait. I have no specific recommendations, however, for two very important reasons: there are hundreds of ways in which the system could be altered each with their own pros and cons, and second, it would likely require a drastic overhaul of the crafting code, which would not be advisable at this stage of development.
Another thing I would love to see but would likely require a drastic overhaul and may be contrary to the intended system would be to have skill points given not just in the initial use, but throughout the process – meaning there would be no good reason to ‘break’ early and restart for skill, since more could be acquired through waiting. Sadly, I suspect that would require changes to the skill system code itself, and that would be extremely unadvisable at this stage of the game.

-Big Lizard Crafting: just because you lack forearms doesn’t mean you should be denied some way of participating in tradeskills, too! Some sort of dragon/wyvern specific crafting would be awesome, perhaps something that would allow them to make scale pouches or special gems for their lairs, or even some sort of active building process for their lairs! The last of those suggestions may be the hardest, but the upcoming races should still have some way of crafting too, because crafting is a very enriching experience, RPly and otherwise.

-Holy Kaleith! Why in heavens name are armlets 5 pieces of metal? That’s 5 pounds of metal to create an item with no weight that sells for 16 doubloons! I make more money flooding the vendor with coal white pawns! ;p
Whining and joking aside, I know that the prices will be looked at pretty soon. Please also consider the amount of resource that goes into making items, too – hairpins requiring more metal to make than a pot or shovel doesn’t make sense realistically, nor in game mechanics.
As a side note, I don’t think I ‘messed up’ once in jewelcrafting. Better double check the fail chances for that skill (unless that is why the skill requires so much metal, but that’s a pretty flimsy reason).

-Needs more cowbell.





Speculating on Speculating

If there is one thing about crafting I hate the most, it is speculating. It is not that there is a flaw in the concept of this skill – being able to know what is in a room before digging it up is somewhat useful. It is the way in which the skill is implemented and where it is implemented, that lead to significant problems in the player’s crafting life.

First of all, speculating doesn’t do anything for you that your gathering skill couldn’t. You want to know what’s in the ground? Dig. You want to know what plants are nearby? Forage. Done and done. If you are looking for a particular resource, or there are no resources available, move on. The problem with this system, however, is that the devs consider it illegal. If you hit the 20 second mark and discover there’s a vein of opal, when you’re looking for cobalt, and you don’t stick around to mine up the completely useless material, you are seen as ‘cheating the system’ in some way. What seems to have been completely forgotten is that, since speculate unlocks at 10 gathering skill, players will have ALREADY GOTTEN USED TO THIS SYSTEM OF DIGGING AND MOVING. I understand the danger that it poses as a form of power leveling, but implementing speculate at the point where power leveling begins to look a lot more acceptable while basically allowing the behavior through lack of communication at earlier levels is sort of a huge poke in the eye to players and an insult to their intelligence.
There are two ways of solving this problem, one that is asinine and I don’t want, and one that is slightly better, but requires the honor system.

The first is the most draconian: make gathering a 60 second process that doesn’t tell you what you are gathering until the end, either it be success or fail, just like crafting skills currently are. It’s a bazooka against a fly moment, but it would be effective, as speculating would be the only way to find what you are looking for in any timely fashion. As a note, this would screw over lower level players seeking to know what they are digging up, and furthermore would encourage accidental cheating since players will not necessarily know the difference between failing a lot and nothing being present at all.

The second is giving speculation as a starting skill, or having it unlock from level 1 foraging. If players are given the skill and told to use it, they will do so. People are creatures of habit, and if you encourage the right habits from the start, they will continue to follow those habits so long as they feel rewarded for doing so. Speculation at an early age will guide them towards what they feel is useful at the time, and it will allow players to make informed decisions on what to gather and where. While it does not do anything for the potential problem of power-leveling gathering skills, it at least creates the early habit of not doing so as a means of locating what you want to gather.

Right now, Speculate being implemented as it is and where it is makes players see it as a means to artificially increase the time it takes to level a gathering skill. Please reconsider its placement on one of the methods mentioned above or perhaps an even better one.







That’s Not All, Folks!

Crafting in its current state is quite playable and fills a niche that I don’t find often in MUDs. It has been fun for me, and has given my character a different type of depth, one that can be useful as conversation piece, or in creating said conversation pieces. I am hopeful that, as the game continues to progress and other parts of the game fill in, that trade skills will have their time to be evaluated and advance. I am also hopeful that these suggestions will be considered for implementation as that time rolls around.

If there is one thing I want the devs to take from this exceptionally long piece, it is that their game does, and should, encourage player to player interaction within the context of a greater world. Crafting has done this for me, but it might not do this for everyone without some evaluation of the system, be it the underlying process, the placement of continuous flames, or simply where people gather their resources. I hope that my experiences, observations, and recommendations will aid you as you move forward.

If you, be you dev or player, have anything you wish to share about the crafting process as you have come to understand it, please feel free to share here. I’ll also be happy to discuss any point I’ve made and see if there are even better options for moving forward. Now that I have my character’s intended goal, I can finally relax in the inn and make shinies – so I’ve got plenty of time!

Re: The Crafting Review -or- How Coraleth Moved Dragon Summ

Posted: Sun Feb 16, 2014 12:34 pm
by
This was a well-crafted post. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it.

Re: The Crafting Review -or- How Coraleth Moved Dragon Summ

Posted: Sun Feb 16, 2014 4:21 pm
by
Thanks! It may be a bit lengthy, but all I want is to help out a little bit.

PS. The pun did not escape me ;p

Re: The Crafting Review -or- How Coraleth Moved Dragon Summ

Posted: Sun Feb 16, 2014 6:08 pm
by
This post is incredibly well-written with its detailed observations and understanding of the crafting system.

Certain things I fully agree with and recommend a fix to:
Along this line, consider removing ‘no resources’ from the random spawn in resource areas. It may not be realistic, as there are times (many times in fact) in which a miner might find nothing, but this is one of the times in which game balance and mechanics has to trump realism.
This will help crafters immensely.
Why in heavens name are armlets 5 pieces of metal? That’s 5 pounds of metal to create an item with no weight that sells for 16 doubloons! I make more money flooding the vendor with coal white pawns! ;p
Prices need to be looked at, that's for certain. Along the same lines this flows into a suggestion that I have concerning crafting and the mountain of uses that one faces. While understanding crafting is supposed to be tedious and an alternative to hunting and combatants, a 1:1 ratio past level 11 is simply daunting, to say the least. Here is what I propose:

The uses one gains from crafting an item is based off the material required. If it requires 5 pounds of material, one gains 5 uses. People might claim that this presents an unfair leveling advantage, but one must keep in mind that this material must still be gathered in the first place, and the time for both crafting and gathering more than makes up for this.

Other recommendations of mine are as follows:

Possibly have a rare "rich" gain when gathering, one gets a 10 pound amount at a go.

In the crafting lists, once one has unlocked an item, the next level has a "upgraded version" of that item, if you will. If you learned how to make a simple necklace out of bone at level 1 (which one does), at level 2 one learns how to make "an intricate necklace" or some variation thereof.

I am also concur with Coraleth that some of the items are for purely RP purposes only, and the lists would do well to have a bit of an update. I know I will be working on several suggestions of my own, and encourage all crafters whether they be amateur, journeymen or those who intend to go the whole nine yards to write up ideas as well.


V/r,

Ryan

Re: The Crafting Review -or- How Coraleth Moved Dragon Summ

Posted: Sun Feb 16, 2014 8:43 pm
by
NotXavier wrote:The uses one gains from crafting an item is based off the material required. If it requires 5 pounds of material, one gains 5 uses. People might claim that this presents an unfair leveling advantage, but one must keep in mind that this material must still be gathered in the first place, and the time for both crafting and gathering more than makes up for this.

It is an interesting idea, but I'm not sure that the skill system code would be able to support it (not that I have any idea what that code looks like or can do). Unfortunately, the time-based difficulty appears to be the absolute intention of the craft-based option for leveling. In other words, under no circumstance should this process be shortened, no matter how much we may want it to be. This built-in time requirement is the primary way, and reason why, crafting is a different track and experience of leveling.


On the bright side, rare resource spawns are in game, though they are apparently a bug. I've found iron in a place it should not be (a non-unique resource) but also marble and bloodstone. Even if this is a bug, I recommend keeping it. You only get 1-3 of the resource, and it is a fun surprise to find.


Also, it turn out that the system you describe and I also suggested on the crafting suggestions/item list tread on the How You Can Help board does exist for at least some crafts. Jewel crafting has simple items, and then 'normal' (without adjective) items after leveling a bit. I still think a similar system can work throughout, but I didn't repost those suggestions here, as it was already a bit long ;p



Edit: misread you. It would be nice to get more than 1-3 of a resource from time to time, but I'd prefer, if possible, that skill level in gathering be the source of it - ie, that at 10 gathering, I can start getting 4 resources a shot, and at 20, get 5, etc.

Re: The Crafting Review -or- How Coraleth Moved Dragon Summ

Posted: Mon Feb 17, 2014 4:30 am
by
Heya mate,

Wow, first of all, thanks for well-written, in-depth and informative review and critique. This is the kind of stuff we're looking for, and we encourage all players to take the same route you've done here (not necessarily in word count, because obviously not every topic will need it, but the thought behind it!)
- My first experiences with crafting are largely trial and a lot of error. The help files were my primary source for information, but detailed information on crafting and resources is virtually nonexistent without a lot of research and sifting through some misinformation (a misunderstood comment from another player led me to believe that ‘rare resource spawns’ were a part of the game, when in fact they are a bug).
You're right, the help files and the website are pretty lacking in this area. It's something we're gonna improve and we hope all players benefit from it. If there's information you think would be valuable that isn't placed here (or information anyone thinks would be valuable), please don't hesitate in sending it to support@shatteredisles.com

We'll probably never list when certain crafting skills unlock, because we want them to be rewarding (trust me, we're aware the lists themselves need beefed up. It's probably very disheartening at times to see some of them)

There's rare spawns, in that they're rare for their specific gathering spot. Ravenswood and walnut come to mind. You'll be unlikely to ever find ruby or diamonds again, for example, in the academy. This was an oversight on the area settings, and unfortunately wasn't found out until much later. If you find something that'd probably be consider very rare in a low area, it's probably best to report it just in case it's an oversight.
Besides some well-known bad examples, the money-to-effort ratio is pretty decent. I hope that, as the lists are filled in and levels increase, that profit too should increase relative to the time it might take one to hunt at a certain level. Given the time it takes to actually increase crafting levels, especially post-10 when a single point of craft can be as much as fifteen points of CC, this will be hard to manage, as getting to higher levels and killing things with lots of money and loot is a significantly faster path to wealth by design and will always be the better method of wealth creation by far, especially to new players.
As you level, the wealth of items sold does increase. We're actually gonna have an overhaul of the value system for craftin', because there's no reason items in the same level gained, with the same amount of resources used and the same time to craft them should see a seven doubloon difference. We'd like it to go off material used (in addition to item crafted as you increase in levels, naturally). It doesn't make much sense for a pine and walnut toy to each sell for one doubloon. So that's in the pipeline.
That said, the length of time it takes to level, collect resources, and turn those resources into something, can be as much isolating as empowering, especially when the resources are off the beaten path. The refining process does not necessarily have this problem, as many crafting skills require a flame, which can be found in taverns where people might congregate or elsewhere (another thing I wish I would have known so I didn’t have to burn Tallwood Forest down making boiled rice). Of course, fear of having your resources stolen can be an issue as well, though thankfully this has only occurred once to me. As a result, this isn’t a major issue to me at this time.

If someone's coming in and stealing your resources, then they need to RP a way for you to get them back or interact with you. If that's not happening, please send in an assist or email to support@shatteredisles.com

We should probably update the help file to list that taverns are good places to find fires.
-First and foremost, there needs to be a decision made on the philosophy of crafting. There seems to be this idea that crafters do not and will never need combat skill, but my shield block did not hit 15 from rocks being cast off when I hit them with my mining pick. The concept of ‘risk versus reward’ is present sporadically, leading crafting to appear to be tacked on and haphazard as a result, while in other places it is seen to have no risk, with effort replacing risk in this equation of value.
I don't think anyone ever said that, and that certainly isn't how we feel. It's a mostly risk and consequence free alternative, economically, to combat skills. You'll raise them, and need them in some cases, yes. But outside of skinning (and even the skinning mobs are relatively lower), there's very little danger in gathering.
When placing new resources, make sure that adventurers will want to pass through the area if possible. Anything that helps to facilitate interaction between players can be beneficial to the community, especially with a small population as MUDs tend to have. Perhaps there are farms on the way to the gnome mines, and inside the mines beyond the relatively safe entrance, terrible dark things want to murdilate people and drop lots of loot for adventurers, etc.
This is something to consider and we'll discuss, and I agree with you!
-Really experiment with allowing players to make more meaningful items. At current, most items created are purely cosmetic, and will only be collected by people who want to RP as being ‘civilized’ or possess a home where they can have a cabinet full of pots and pans. I know that the system does not allow for resource material to matter except in terms of vendoring, so as you approach implementing armor and possibly weapons, I recommend seeing if a recipe-based system such as exists in cooking can be used to create different strengths of armor and/or weapons. If the end result can be modified (a level 1 recipe might absorb 5 damage while a level 10 recipe might absorb 15, etc), then as long as the recipe is specific, the material can have a direct correlation to the quality of the armor (by allowing only bronze in early recipes, then iron, etc). If that armor can be further customized by having non-specific quality items in the process, such as a ‘buckle’ that could be made of any type of metal added somewhere into the description of the final item, you have the potential for making real meaningful items, in which quality and worth can be determined by the player making it, or the player commissioning it. And that would be fantastic and truly reward the crafter.
The customisation system is, unfortunately, rather buggy. It was in at some point in alpha, but.. the finished products don't look nice. I really like NotXavier's suggestion of adding an item learned the previous level to every level following it, but with a different, higher-quality adjective to it. It'd give some separation, uniqueness, and help buff up the item lists.

Hopefully, in the future, we'll be able to put a fully customised system in to allow the players to add their own colour and flavour to their crafted wares.
Another thing I would love to see but would likely require a drastic overhaul and may be contrary to the intended system would be to have skill points given not just in the initial use, but throughout the process – meaning there would be no good reason to ‘break’ early and restart for skill, since more could be acquired through waiting
I have to admit this I'm not sure how to respond to this. This is a bug, that's the good reason not to break early. We'll talk about perhaps improving the process slightly, but there's never any good reason to abuse a bug.
-Holy Kaleith! Why in heavens name are armlets 5 pieces of metal?
There's definitely some issues in terms of balance for what kind of items take <insert amount> of crafting material. Please feel free to add items like this that should be tweaked in this thread, or new one.

There's several things following my next quote, and amongst them are many strong suggestions. However, they also seem to be based off the sentences I'm going to respond to, so I thought I'd address this alone whilst telling you we'll discuss those other suggestions as well.
The problem with this system, however, is that the devs consider it illegal. If you hit the 20 second mark and discover there’s a vein of opal, when you’re looking for cobalt, and you don’t stick around to mine up the completely useless material, you are seen as ‘cheating the system’ in some way.
You've made several other comments like this in the entirety of the post, whether it be to have a clearer signal of etiquette and what's allowed or isn't allowed in crafting. I wanted to respond to this one specifically because I feel it holds the intent behind the others, along with something else.

No, we don't consider that illegal. Finding something you aren't looking for and leaving isn't illegal. Not at all. That'd be very burdensome to young crafters who don't have speculate. There's always going to be times, for example, when you're searching for tin but it runs out and you come across stone, but you don't need it, so you want to move on quickly. That's fine. Or you're looking for tin and come across other veins, so you move to keep looking. Again, absolutely okay.

What isn't okay is something which is unfortunately all too common.

The intentionally seeking out of 'nothing' spots, or trying to find rooms which were improperly set to have no resources in them, but still able to be mined/foraged/chopped, then when the gatherer comes across a vein/tree/forage-able good, they leave. Because they aren't actually looking for goods to gather, no, they're looking for 'nothing' spots in which to keep failing for quicker, faster leveling.

There is the lesser issue, and by lesser it isn't too often abused, is repeatedly starting a gathering skill and immediately leaving to stop it, only to restart again, within a matter of seconds. That's circumventing the delay system.

We made failure a lesser delay because we didn't think it was fair to make failing at something take as long as succeeding, when success is a minute or over. We wanted to allow players to move on to finding the resources they were looking for if this was the case, because crafting skills require such a large amount of raw materials to level.

What we didn't anticipate, however (and this isn't something limited to a specific style/type of player, combat or crafter), was many people purposefully seeking out failures in their skills to level faster. I, personally, would have liked to think it was clear we were trying to help players out when they failed, so they wouldn't be punished for a low success rate or those times when a resource node is teetering out. Unfortunately that doesn't seem to be the case.

Now we're going to have to revisit the failure system and how we approach it, in addition to several other looks we need to give crafting. We'll also add some 'dos and donts' to the help files and help pages.

We're thankful for your suggestions and the thought you put into this post, as well as those that've responded to you. It's always great, and helpful, to receive this amount of feedback.

Cheers!

Re: The Crafting Review -or- How Coraleth Moved Dragon Summ

Posted: Mon Feb 17, 2014 5:30 am
by
I have a couple things I want to touch on.

Gathering and crafting do not have to be done by the same individual. Gathering, in its own right, is a means of income. Beyond direct sales from character to character, we've set up resource shops so that gatherers may sell their spoils and those whom craft may purchase their raw materials without leaving town. Maybe this works better in theory, but I haven't heard any reports one way or the other within the game.

As for stopping a gathering skill, while not finding what you want and leaving prior to completing the extraction may be acceptable, doing it repeatedly does not look good. There is a fine line between moving rooms continually when it's something you don't want and appearing like you're circumventing the delay timer, because it does circumvent that timer.

Re: The Crafting Review -or- How Coraleth Moved Dragon Summ

Posted: Mon Feb 17, 2014 5:32 am
by
Thanks for taking the time to read through it! Sorry I talk a lot ;p


It is unfortunate that the customization doesn't work properly, but I know that's a problem to tackle in the future. Though to be clear, I don't mean peddle-quality level of customization, but individual parts to make up the whole, allowing one recipe to have multiple outcomes. There are simpler things to work on first, as well as many other parts of the game to expand.


Anselm wrote:We made failure a lesser delay because we didn't think it was fair to make failing at something take as long as succeeding, when success is a minute or over. We wanted to allow players to move on to finding the resources they were looking for if this was the case, because crafting skills require such a large amount of raw materials to level.

What we didn't anticipate, however (and this isn't something limited to a specific style/type of player, combat or crafter), was many people purposefully seeking out failures in their skills to level faster. I, personally, would have liked to think it was clear we were trying to help players out when they failed, so they wouldn't be punished for a low success rate or those times when a resource node is teetering out. Unfortunately that doesn't seem to be the case.
The crafts do require a rediculous amount of resources, so I certainly do not want to see this changed. The system at current does reward failure - up until the point that the crafting skills are unlocked. I'm not sure how else to change it beyond what suggestions I've already offered, except one other possibility: unlock the craft skills sooner, or have craft skills unlock from other craft skills (such as jewel crafting coming from blacksmithy, as smelting and some day armor will).

As you said though, this likely goes beyond crafting, but my more limited experience with the adventure side of things handicaps any useful advice or experience I can offer at this time.

Re: The Crafting Review -or- How Coraleth Moved Dragon Summ

Posted: Mon Feb 17, 2014 5:38 am
by
Austere wrote: Gathering and crafting do not have to be done by the same individual. Gathering, in its own right, is a means of income. Beyond direct sales from character to character, we've set up resource shops so that gatherers may sell their spoils and those whom craft may purchase their raw materials without leaving town. Maybe this works better in theory, but I haven't heard any reports one way or the other within the game.
I think the gathering system as it relates to making money for even non-crafters is working as intended. I see posts up in the trade section from time to time, and prior to unlocking crafting, it made very adaquet money. Plus, those merchants resell the things people sell to them, which has been fantastic for leveling smelting, or just plodding along my craft skill. In addition, this is a good way to remove money from the economy (the resale higher than the sale). I have no other recommendations on this point.

Re: The Crafting Review -or- How Coraleth Moved Dragon Summ

Posted: Mon Feb 17, 2014 11:02 am
by
What a good thread. Lots of ideas and responses. You've all touched on things I was going to bring up.
I like the way different crafts work for each other. Smithing can make pots to cook in or a shovel to dig with, glass blowing makes the glass for a monocle. I'm always looking forward to new items.
Oh and there's a lot of salt to be mined because almost every recipe needs it. I'm always running out.
Thanks for the good read.