Page 1 of 2
Male v Female characters
Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2014 11:00 am
by
I got the idea for this topic from the gambling thread and I thought it could use its own discussion. I have noticed a trend in most games where we feel the need to “protect” female characters. I guess this is our basic instinct for chivalry in the real world where women are regarded by some to be vulnerable and less physically capable.
I think this real world application has no place in our games where female characters are every bit as capable as their male counterparts. Male and female characters in this type of fantasy setting have the exact same stats and abilities as the male characters. Unless you play your character as something like a demure farmwife; females in these types of games are not in any need of protecting.
I think as men we all want to be seen as a hero rushing in and fighting for the honor of a female. In Shattered Isles unless your specific role play dictates otherwise all the PC's are considered adventurers and should be considered to be epic level characters. I would think the female characters would be offended by the thought that they need to be “protected”.
Am I alone in feeling this way or is this a valid debate?
Edit to add:
I am not suggesting that I'm ok with crossing the boundary into legitimate sexual harassment.
Re: Male v Female characters
Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2014 11:56 am
by
This is something I feel pretty strongly about. As an individual, and as a female, I was never brought up with the belief that I was something that needed special protection or consideration. To do so was not only a way to encourage the behavior it was often trying to combat, but it separated the genders even more. Separation has never done any good for equality, and I understand this and have experienced it on multiple levels. I haven't excelled in male dominated fields because I got special treatment, I excelled because I proved I was as good as, if not better than, my male counterparts and that I needed no special treatment. I do think this is a valid form of discussion. Not only that, but every female I have ever known would slap someone who tried unnecessarily to defend them as fast as they would slap someone who was actually being offensive.
However, sexual harassment and assault are never ok, no matter if you're male, female, or gender-fluid.
Doxx I do want to thank you for this. This isn't something I can usually form a post about without getting aggressive.
Re: Male v Female characters
Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2014 3:36 pm
by
This is a subject we've been discussing as a staff as well, although on a larger scale. Anselm would be better suited to address this as he's been writing something up already.
Re: Male v Female characters
Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2014 3:41 pm
by
Roleplay should be dealt with in-game. As an adventurer, and an "epic level" character, in game you would have no idea who was who. Npcs and PCs are the same in game.
If you're a chivalrous knight then you may feel its your duty to protect all people, not just women. Maybe, I'm a thiefly assassin-y type, and I want to lull you into a false sense of security, and learn your secrets, or motives, or where you hide your shiny stuff. Maybe you're a mark.
Its all roleplay and should be roleplayed.
Re: Male v Female characters
Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2014 4:22 pm
by
If I offend a female character in-game I think it is a bit silly for a male character to jump to her aid simply because she is a female. Unless it's your RP style there is no "weaker" sex here in Shattered Isles.
The point I was trying to make in my original post is that male and female characters should be treated equally in a game such as Shattered Isles. As an example if I were to slap female A in some RP interaction that we are having how do you justify male B jumping to her aid and assaulting me or lecturing me on how it is inappropriate to strike a female.
A female character is every bit as capable as the male characters. There is no difference in stats or abilities. The need to jump to a female characters aid simply because she is a female should not exist in a roleplaying game where all things are mechanically equal between the sexes. It is my opinion that real world chivalry should not apply here in our game world. It is not logical for it to exist unless your specific RP dictates that you are helpless or in need of protecting.
Re: Male v Female characters
Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2014 4:56 pm
by
I think speculation on a PC's roleplay should remain IC, and should in fact not be discussed in the OOC forums.
The instance that ignited this issue stemmed from precisely that -- a mention of IC roleplay in an OOC setting. Had this not occurred, we'd likely not be having this discussion.
Anselm already shared with us a rather informative post on the separation of IC/OOC and the importance of not cross-charactering which can be found
here.
It would behoove us all to continue this separation when discussing things on the OOC forums, and strive to consider that what a PC does in game is not in fact what the person driving that PC believes and/or is like in real life.
Re: Male v Female characters
Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2014 5:10 pm
by
I think people are reading way more into things than they should. I don't know where this thing started but I do know that I have not seen anyone being treated differently just based on gender alone. I think because the player population is so small people are assuming that if you treat one female character/player one way then you treat them all that way. And not taking the time to consider, maybe they have an reason for being a jerk to that character. They could be a Pearlean Redneck. Or even an OOC player for treating another player that way. There is also no IC basis to think this exists as most of the positions of powers are held by female characters, so just going by example they are in the majority. Even when someone has expressed something they were promptly beaten down by female characters.
As it is, one blanket statement that this is not allowed IC is treading dangerous waters. I can see it being an OOC ruling just due to mutual respect. But it should not be addressed in an IC way. I think you're coming too close to placing IC restrictions on bigotry in general, if that's the case you just cut your opportunities for RP to nothing. RP is conflict. Every good story has conflict. While I don't have a misogynistic character, I feel it shouldn't be disallowed. I would welcome the RP and the beat downs from female characters. Same as if I played a racist, or a religious zealot. One form of hate is no more acceptable than the other, you can't ban one and not the others. Then that just comes down to your own personal belief structures and has no place in open role-play games. Someone is offended by something no matter what you do. I remember getting called out once because back in the day I used to cyber, a lot, and they asked me how it felt to take advantage of women online and that it should be banned in RP games. That was their own personal belief, because I didn't do anything that wasn't mutual and most times I didn't initiate it. Should that have been banned because one person was offended? As a Devalin I was offended by the way Nikolas treated me on first arrival. Should racism be banned? In this case it is true "racism" because it is a different race where as our racism doesn't make sense since we're all humans.
I'll come out and say if I act like I'm better than someone, it has nothing to do with their gender it's because I naturally feel superior to everyone. And equality is double edged. You can't crusade for equality and then act shocked when you get it. I treat women the same as men, meaning I don't give them special or preferential treatment. I'm not going to hold back IC or OOC because of some warped sense of humanitarian justice, doing so is actually doing more damage than good. By treating them different we're reinforcing the belief that they still NEED a man's protection and APPROVAL just to be EQUAL. Which is a type of misogyny in and of itself. I date strong women, they would kick my ass if I pulled that fake chivalry crap to soothe my own ego and guilt about being born male. I don't like weak women that need to be coddled and protected from the big mean world that may hurt their feelings. Again, I have yet to see that kind of thing IC or OOC in regards to gender inequality and don't believe this to be an epidemic in this community.
Re: Male v Female characters
Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2014 5:30 pm
by
I do not see where this particular discussion is crossing any off-limit boundaries between IC and OOC. No one is discussing cross charactering or taking OOC knowledge into the game to benefit our character. I am challenging the practice of taking an OOC and arguably an archaic thought process into our IC interactions with our fellow players.
Re: Male v Female characters
Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2014 5:44 pm
by
Just to be clear I am not criticizing the RP of the chivalric knight, the damsel in distress, or the racist/bigot/jerk etc. I am referring to the player that jumps to the damsels aid simply because she is a female. I think this is an OOC kneejerk reaction based on OOC system of beliefs.
Re: Male v Female characters
Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2014 6:13 pm
by
Whilst I have a much longer reply I must write up for later, for now I will say this:
If one cannot separate the difference between racism and anti-religous behaviour of fictional races (and yes, humans count in this instance because they would be targeted for being humans, not based on the colour of one's skin) and gods from misogyny, which is directed towards a quite real gender/identity, then this is a significant problem. There is, in fact, a rather large bit of rampant misogyny.
In fact, no one is asking that women characters (and their players) be treated special. What is being said, and it is going to start happening, that the misogynistic comments and acts are going to cease. Slut-shaming? Objectification of women? Sexualisation of women? Feeling free to use whore, slut, bitch, etc but can't manage to type out 'penis'? Comparing men to women in an attempt to feminise them because being feminine equates bad/lesser/weak? All misogynistic acts.
Gaming is not just a safe place for men, it will be a safe place for women as well. Women should not have to endure countless acts of sexism daily, only for them to return the their flats and be doused with it in fictional worlds.