[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • Tracking - Page 2
Page 2 of 2

Re: Tracking

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 6:14 pm
by
I wrote up a short scenario to help sum up in my own mind the current and hopefully future mechanics/workings of tracking.
Thanks Voegelin for starting this thread and helping me with my understanding of the skill.
I apologize for the length... spoiler tags would be really nice (hint, hint) ;)
----------
Deep in the Tallwoods....
Two scouts sit under a large oak tree. One, an elder Avardi, and the other a young goblin.
Eabo: I'z notz surez what dis trackinz all aboutz...
Laniea: Of course not, you do not know how to use your senses yet. Let me see if I can help you.
Laniea ponders a moment.
Laniea: Look at the ground in front of you Eabo. Tell me what you see.
Eabo stares at the ground for a few moments.
Eabo: I seez grass an dirt. Maybeez a buckz hoof printz goin off eastz. Oh an a rabbitz droppin!
Laniea sighs.
Laniea: You are using just your eyes Eabo. Look at Me. Tell me Whom I pray too for a good hunt.
Eabo glances at Laniea for a moment and snorts.
Eabo: Datz eazy... Yooz askz Tetheriz.
Laniea pops Eabo on his bald head.
Laniea Do not take this lightly Eabo. But what is it you see to tell you this?
Eabo ponders a moment.
Eabo: I'z kinda seez an auraz all aroundz you. Kindaz likez a colour but notz quite.
Eabo tilts his head a moment then gasps
Eabo: I'z notz seez it! I'z thinkz it!
Laniea chuckles for a moment and nods.
Laniea: You are begining to understand. The power of the Gods touch us, and mark us.
Laniea glances over to the right.
Laniea: Now, look at that rabbit over there. Look at it the way you looked at me.
Eabo raises an eyebrow in a puzzled expression for a moment, then turns to the rabbit.
After a few moments, Eabo lets out a small gasp.
Eabo: I'z seez!
Eabo furrows his brow.
Eabo: I'z notz sure whatz I'z seez, but I seez sumthin.
The rabbit suddenly hops away to the west. Eabo starts to turn to follow it with his eyes but
Laniea reaches out to hold Eabos head still.
Laniea: Keep looking where the rabbit was Eabo.
Eabo stares at where the rabbit was for a few moments. His eyes suddenly widen.
Eabo: I'z seez! Rabbitz stillz their... or waz.
Laniea nods his head.
Laniea: So you know the rabbit, you know what it looks like both with your eyes and your mind, yes?
Eabo nods his head yes, still with a bit of bewilderment on his face.
Laniea: Now Eabo, relax... your body and mind. Now look for that specific rabbit. Use your eyes and mind
to look at the world around you.
Eabo takes a deep breath and slowly looks around while thinking about the rabbit. Suddenly his head turn to the west.
Laniea: Tell me what you are -seeing- Eabo.
Eabo: I'z seez lot'za colourz...kinda. Deyz in swirlz an patternz.
Eabo tilts his head
Eabo: I'z seez to du westz... Kinda uh patternz likez dat rabbit.
Laniea rises and pulls Eabo up with him.
Laniea: Go to it Eabo.
The two move off to the west...
Eabo appears puzzled.
Eabo I seez du rabbitz herez... But du rabbitz gone.
Laniea: That is right Eabo. When you looked for the rabbit, the rabbit was right here. But it has hopped off somewhere else now.
Eabo furrows his brow for a moment then suddenly relaxes and begins to look at the world around him.
After a few moments, Eabo points to the north and takes off.
Laniea grins slightly and follows closely.
An hour passes with the two chasing rabbits and other creatures around the woods. They finally stop to rest...
Eabo: Whatz about folkz lanieaz? Dey not critterz likez rabbitz.
Laniea: True Eabo, but we are a part of this world so you can find them just like you did the rabbit.
Eabo snorts.
Eabo: wellz dat shouldz make findin myz friendz easy!
Laniea ponders for a moment.
Laniea Yes and no Eabo. You know our friend Danika the vukasin?
Eabo: Surez! weez hab good dinnerz and talkz all nightz wit herz!
Laniea smiles and simply says: Find her.
Eabo snickers and murmurs- No problemz.
Eabo begins to calmly look and think... A minute passes, then another.
Eabo: Maybeez she to far awayz... or sleepin?
Laniea nods his head no.
Laniea: I know for a fact she is nearby. Try a bit longer Eabo.
Eabo nods and continues. After awhile he turns to the west.
Eabo: I tinkz maybe dat wayz... itz hardlyz sometinz I can recognize.
Laniea nods and motions them to move on in that direction.
Following Eabos tracking, the two finally come to the Tavern and enter it.
It is filled with students enjoying a drink and a good talk.
Eabo looks around the room but does not find their friend Danika. He glances up at Laniea with a puzzled expression.
Laniea grins at Eabo and moves them to a booth at the back of the room and sits next to a large male Argali.
Eabo sits also while still looking around the room.
The Argali leans over and whispers to Eabo: Hello friend, I hope you did not eat too much last night.
Eabo turns sharply and gasps as the Argali winks at him.
Laniea whispers quietly: Yes Eabo, this is Danika. She is in disguise. You found where she was only because you were skilled enough
to sense Danikas pattern. Her skill... if a little better might not have allowed you to even catch that faint pattern.
Danika leans forward again with a grin: And you really didn't find me now did you Eabo. Only where I was the last time you looked for me.
Eabo shakes his head no and snickers in agreement.
Danika: Now if you had been tracking Bruno the Argali, or perhaps just an Argali in general, it would have been much easier for you I am sure.
Danika winks at Eabo again as Bruno the Argali orders a round for the three of them.

Re: Tracking

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2015 6:57 pm
by
Tracking to a location often leads to a character. Unless something has changed with the tracking command, you still use "track [character name]" to use the skill. "Track Kaiah" and "track Joe" would take you to the same place.

Seeing as people have magically figured out my most elaborate disguises in the past and been completely unable to explain why, I would think that this would be a pretty obvious concern. Now, newer members of the player base may be better roleplayers than those in the past, which is great. Can't say it won't always be a concern, because people like being right more than they like being honest. Just the way it is.

Re: Tracking

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2015 9:06 pm
by
Personally, I am hoping that mechanic wise, it will be trackers skill verses disguisers skill if the tracker is looking for the 'real' characters name. If tracking the disguise persona, it should be less difficult.

Re: Tracking

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2015 4:36 pm
by
I'm perfectly fine with them tracking the disguised name. That's what it's there for.

If a low level track can see through a high level disguise, though, it's just another broken thing in the game that needs additional fixes to bring it in line.

Re: Tracking

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2015 7:49 pm
by
I was not aware that the new skill system was already in the game. I must have missed the update notes on that.

Re: Tracking

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2015 11:48 pm
by
Can't say I know either way, I don't bother keeping up with the updates. I know only what I've actually tested.

It's probably time for another round of testing.

Re: Tracking

Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 3:03 am
by
To reiterate: tracking as currently configured leads to a location, not to a character. As such, it does not "see through" a disguise.

--Aruskin

Re: Tracking

Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 6:09 am
by
If the disguised person's location is found using the undisguised name, then it's technically able to "see through" a disguise because the user knew, IC or OOC, to try tracking the disguised person's actual name.

I don't believe for a second people are honest enough to not go "this person can disguise themselves, so it has to be them, even if no one saw them." There aren't many here that can disguise, so there's about 25% chance that someone trying to breathe life into the game without staff aid is going to get screwed, and promptly quit and do their own thing.